Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Colonial NSW. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Colonial NSW. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Margaret Catchpole – Convict, Midwife and Letter Writer – Richmond, Hawkesbury – NSW – 1762–1819

Twice sentenced to death in Suffolk, twice reprieved, transported for life on the Nile, and remembered today less for the romance later written about her than for the letters she sent home from the Hawkesbury — Margaret Catchpole (1762–1819) is one of the few convict women whose own words still speak clearly across more than two centuries. She cooked for the colony’s commissary at Woolloomooloo, nursed free settlers’ wives through their “lying-in”, rented a small farm near Richmond, watched the river rise over the housetops in flood, and never married. Her letters and the Rouse family notebooks show her trading cloth and haberdashery on a small scale; Richard Cobbold’s later novel turned that trade into a tidy village shop that the surviving evidence does not support. The story that made her a Suffolk heroine after her death mixed her real life with fiction.

Later imaginative portrayal of Margaret Catchpole by Richard Cobbold, 1845 etching.
Later imaginative portrayal of Margaret Catchpole — etching and aquatint by Richard Cobbold, published 1845 as the frontispiece to his partly fictional History of Margaret Catchpole. Cobbold never met her; there is no known surviving portrait made from life. Image: Richard Cobbold; Wikimedia Commons; public domain.
Later imaginative oil portrait titled Margaret Catchpole by Richard Cobbold, about 1840.
Oil painting titled “Margaret Catchpole” by Richard Cobbold, about 1840 — another later imaginative portrayal, painted decades after her death. Image: Richard Cobbold / Ipswich Borough Council Collection; Wikimedia Commons (PD-Art); public domain.

Suffolk beginnings

Margaret Catchpole is usually dated to 14 March 1762. Percival Serle’s Dictionary of Australian Biography places the birth at Nacton, Suffolk, and names her father as Jonathan Catchpole, a head ploughman. Museums of History NSW and the NSW Blue Plaques entry give the year 1762 in Suffolk and leave the parish less pinned down; some later biographical accounts also name her mother as Elizabeth Catchpole and point to a same-day baptism in another Suffolk register. The date is as firm as those secondary readings of the baptismal evidence allow; the parish is not settled beyond dispute.

She grew up on the farms where her father worked and became a skilled horsewoman. Formal schooling was slight. She went into service with various families until, in the early 1790s, she was employed as under-nurse and under-cook by Mrs Elizabeth Cobbold, wife of the Ipswich brewer and banker John Cobbold. Serle records that while with Mrs Cobbold her courage and resource saved three children from death. The Blue Plaques account says Elizabeth taught her to read and write, and that the two remained friends. Elizabeth Cobbold kept up the correspondence after Margaret was transported.

Former Tolly Cobbold Cliff Brewery, Ipswich, 2020 — later fabric than Margaret’s workplace.
The former Tolly Cobbold Cliff Brewery on Cliff Quay, Ipswich, photographed 10 October 2020. The surviving building and fabric are later than Margaret’s day; it marks the Cobbold family’s Ipswich riverside, not her workplace standing unchanged from the 1790s. Image: PeterSouthEast99; Wikimedia Commons; CC BY-SA 4.0.
Ipswich Docks and Cliff Quay on the River Orwell, 2008.
Ipswich Docks from the Orwell Bridge, 29 October 2008 — Cliff Quay to the right. Margaret later wrote that the hills and houses of Sydney Cove put her in mind of the Cliff on the Orwell. Image: Bob Jones; Wikimedia Commons / Geograph; CC BY-SA 2.0.

The coach gelding, May 1797

Margaret left the Cobbolds in mid-1795. After months of serious illness and unemployment, on the night of 23 May 1797 she stole John Cobbold’s coach gelding — described on Cobbold’s reward handbill as a strawberry roan crop coach gelding with a black mane and “nag tail” — and rode it about seventy miles (around 110 kilometres) to London. Museums of History NSW, drawing on Home Office and newspaper records, says she was dressed “in man’s apparel”, was committed to Newgate on 27 May charged with stealing a horse worth £30, and was caught when she tried to sell the distinctive animal to a Moorfields horse dealer on the morning of 25 May. She revealed that she was female and confessed, including her former service with the Cobbolds.

Engraving of Newgate Gaol in the City of London (George Dance’s prison).
Newgate Gaol in the City of London — historical engraving of George Dance’s prison, where Margaret was held for nearly six weeks after her arrest in May 1797 before transfer to Ipswich County Gaol. Image: Wellcome Collection; Wikimedia Commons; CC BY 4.0.

She spent nearly six weeks in Newgate before transfer to the county gaol at Ipswich. Tried at Bury Assizes on 9 August 1797, she was convicted of felony and horse stealing, sentenced to death, and recommended for mercy on condition of transportation for seven years.

Over the wall, March 1800

She was still in Ipswich Gaol nearly three years later when, in March 1800, she escaped, using a clothesline to scale the roughly 22-foot (6.7 metre) wall, and went on the run disguised as a sailor. The State Library’s older “Convicted” page and Museums of History NSW both give that escape; she was retaken within a few days. Tried at Bury Assizes on 31 July for being “at large after transportation”, she was again sentenced to death and again reprieved — this time to transportation for life.

What Cobbold invented, and what he did not

Around these hard facts later grew the story of Margaret’s devotion to a sailor-turned-smuggler named William Laud: that she left the Cobbolds because of him, stole the horse to help him in London, escaped to marry him, and that he was shot dead on a Suffolk beach when she was recaptured. Serle’s older dictionary retells that romance as if it were settled fact; Museums of History NSW treats Cobbold’s Laud plot as fiction written for a moral story. Richard Cobbold, son of John and Elizabeth, published The History of Margaret Catchpole, a Suffolk Girl in three volumes in 1845. He used family memory and Margaret’s letters, then rewrote and invented freely, put genteel English into her mouth, and later editions still claimed she had married a wealthy settler and died prosperous in 1841. That ending belongs to fiction, and was long confused with the real career of another horse-stealing convict, Mary Reibey. Margaret Catchpole never married.

The Nile, 1801

She sailed for New South Wales on the convict transport Nile in June 1801 with about ninety-five other women prisoners, in convoy with the Canada and the Minorca. Free settlers on the same ships included Richard and Elizabeth Rouse; Rouse family tradition, recorded by Museums of History NSW, credits Margaret with helping at the birth of their son John Richard, born at sea off Rio de Janeiro on 27 August 1801. The Nile reached Port Jackson on 14 December 1801. In her letter to Mrs Cobbold dated 21 January 1802 she wrote that she had landed on “the 20th Day of Desember 1801”, and that the hills and houses put her in mind of the Cliff on the Orwell:

“As i was a Going to be Landed, on the Left hand of me, it put me in mind of the Cleeff - Both the housen and Lik wise the hills so as it put me in very Good spirites seeing a places so much Like my owen nativ home.”

She also told Mrs Cobbold, in the same letter’s strong capitals, that this was “THE WICKEDES PLACE I EVER WAS IN ALL MY LIFE” — while still noticing the gardens, the geraniums running seven and eight feet high, and the pretty birds.

View of Sydney Cove from Dawes Point after Joseph Lycett.
View of Sydney Cove from Dawes Point, after Joseph Lycett (c.1775–1828). A later colonial view of the harbour Margaret entered in December 1801, not a picture of her landing day. Image: Joseph Lycett; Wikimedia Commons; public domain.

Cook at Woolloomooloo

Within two days of landing she was cooking for commissary John Palmer and his wife Susan at Woolloomooloo. She worked there about eighteen months. In that period she received a ticket of leave, which gave her freedom of movement beyond Sydney and the right to find work on her own account. Writing to her uncle she was proud of the company she kept:

“i am well Beloved By all that know me and that is a Comfort for i all wais Goo into Better Compeney then my self that is a monkest free peopell whear thay mak as much of me as if i was a Laday—Becaus i am the Commiseres Cook.”

A postscript on that letter mentions a man who kept her company and would marry her if she liked — “he is a gardner he Com out as a Botnes”. Museums of History NSW identifies him as almost certainly James Gordon, a botanist collecting for a London patron, rather than the plant collector George Caley. Margaret was not for marrying.

Richmond Hill — nurse, midwife, overseer

By about 1804 she was on the Hawkesbury. Her October 1806 letter to her aunt and uncle Howes in Ipswich says she had been two years up the country at Richmond Hill nursing Mrs Rouse, that the Rouses, who had come free, respected her “as one of ther owen famely”, and that when Richard Rouse was made superintendent and master builder at the lumber yard at Parramatta she was left overseer at his farm — “But it was to Lonsum for me so i Left”. Between 1804 and 1806, on her own account and as read by Museums of History NSW, she shuttled among the Rouse, Dight, Wood and Faithfull households for lying-in. Baptism and family records line up with her nursing Elizabeth Rouse around the birth of George Rouse (20 May 1804), and with attendance connected with the Dight and Faithfull births in 1804–1806.

She signed as a witness to a building contract for additions at John Dight’s Durham Bowes at Richmond — the NSW Blue Plaques programme notes that property as the only surviving homestead where she is known to have been in service, and the plaque stands there today at 22 Inalls Lane, Richmond.

Hawkesbury River at North Richmond, December 2024.
The Hawkesbury River at North Richmond (Richmond Hill country), December 2024 — the river country of the floods Margaret described in 1806 and 1809. Image: MrActiniuM; Wikimedia Commons; CC BY 2.0.

Floods, letters and a small farm

Margaret’s letters of October 1806 and October 1809 give rare eyewitness detail of the Hawkesbury floods of those years; Museums of History NSW treats them as central evidence for those rises. In 1806 she wrote of being in the water up to her middle trying to save what she could, and of losing pigs to the flood. Of August 1809 she wrote:

“the higest that was ever noun By the whit men it went over the topes of the housen and many poor Cratuers Crying out for marcey Crying out for Botes firen of Gunes in destrees it was shoken to hear.”

She rented a “smorll farm” and lived in a “Littell Cotteg”, sometimes with a little child or two staying with her, hired a man to work the land, and did a good deal of the work herself. By September 1811 she reported thirty sheep, forty goats and thirty pigs, and two dogs for protection because she lived alone — and friends among the women she had nursed “thay Cannot do with out me I am Loked upon very well”. Elizabeth Cobbold sent boxes of cloth and haberdashery; some Margaret wore, some she sold. Cryptic entries in Richard Rouse’s notebooks for 1805–07, cited by Museums of History NSW, record sales from “Margreat Catchpole to Mrs Rouse” of handkerchiefs, bobbin, check and Irish cloth. Cobbold’s novel turned that trade into a tidy village shop at Richmond Hill. Richmond village was not laid out until 1811, so a formal shop of the romance kind is unlikely; small-scale trading in cloth is what the letters and notebooks support.

On 1 January 1808 she put her name to an address of loyalty to Governor Bligh from settlers and inhabitants. Museums of History NSW notes she was one of only nineteen female signatories, still not free and not a landowner in her own right — a measure of confidence rather than legal status.

She wrote of Aboriginal people, of wildlife, of the first convict coalminers at Coal River (Newcastle), and of the roughness of colonial life. In early 1807, with Mrs Palmer’s help, she sent to Mrs Cobbold the skins of a pair of “mountain cockes and a hen fessant” — lyrebirds — in a cedar case on HMS Buffalo. They reached Ipswich Museum labelled as sent from Botany Bay by Margaret Catchpole.

“I am not for marrying”

Again and again the letters return to independence and to longing for a pardon and her “owen nativ Land”. In her last known letter to the Cobbolds, 1 September 1811, she wrote:

“i am Liven all a Loon as Befor in a very onest way of Life hear is not one woman in the Coloney Liv Lik my self.”

She was granted an absolute pardon in 1814 on Governor Macquarie’s recommendation. She did not go home. She stayed on the Hawkesbury, still nursing and midwifing, still helping others. Cobbold and some later writers speak of her keeping a little shop after her pardon; what can be shown from her own letters and the Rouse notebooks is the earlier small trade in cloth and haberdashery, not a documented village storefront.

Death at Richmond, 1819

Her last service was nursing a shepherd ill with influenza on the Pitts’ property near Richmond. She caught the infection and died on 13 May 1819. She was buried the next day in St Peter’s churchyard, Richmond, by the Rev. Henry Fulton. The burial register, as quoted by Serle and by Museums of History NSW, records her as “age 58 years, came prisoner of the Nile in the year 1801”. The Sydney Gazette took no notice. No headstone marked the grave. Late nineteenth-century local memory, including a letter from George Matcham Pitt to the Evening News in December 1890, preserved the story of that last illness on the Pitt farm.

St Peter’s Anglican Church, Richmond, photographed 2009 — later church fabric; churchyard burial site.
St Peter’s Anglican Church, Richmond, photographed 2009. Margaret was buried in this churchyard on 14 May 1819 by the Rev. Henry Fulton; no headstone marked her grave. The church building in the photograph is later than the burial; the churchyard is the right site. Image: Sardaka; Wikimedia Commons; CC BY 3.0.

Afterlife — book, stage, and the sorting of two women

A quarter of a century after her death, Richard Cobbold’s 1845 book made Margaret a metropolitan heroine. Plays followed, including Margaret Catchpole, the female horse-stealer; Sydney’s Royal Victoria Theatre staged a production in October 1846. Some readers thought Cobbold’s prosperous married heroine was Mary Reibey. Clergy who feared hurt to the Reibey family tried to stop the book; Cobbold later regretted the confusion but kept the married ending. Australian research from the 1890s — Barton’s serial “true story”, Bonwick’s documents, the Richmond burial register — finally separated the two women. Mary Reibey is on the twenty-dollar note. Margaret Catchpole keeps the letters.

Sources

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

John Knatchbull and the Murder of Ellen Jamieson – Sydney, 1844

On a Saturday night in January 1844, a widow named Ellen Jamieson was keeping her little shop open late on the corner of Kent Street and Margaret Place in Sydney. Her two young children were asleep upstairs. Just before midnight a man came in asking for vinegar, and a few minutes later a neighbour across the road heard a terrible noise from inside. The man was John Knatchbull, a former Royal Navy commander from one of the best-known families in Kent, by then a ticket-of-leave convict with a long record behind him. Ellen died of her injuries twelve days later. Knatchbull was tried, found guilty, and on 13 February 1844 he became the first man hanged at the new Darlinghurst Gaol, in front of one of the biggest crowds Sydney had ever seen.

I've mentioned Knatchbull briefly in my post on Darlinghurst Gaol & Darlinghurst Court, and he heads the list in my page on the Hangings at Darlinghurst Gaol, but his story deserves a page of its own. It takes in a baronet's household in Kent, the Napoleonic Wars, a pickpocketing charge at Vauxhall Gardens, the Bathurst road, Norfolk Island, and finally a courtroom where his barrister tried a defence no colonial judge had heard before. Most of all, though, it is about Ellen Jamieson and the two children she left behind, and I've tried to keep them in view the whole way through.

Lithograph portrait of John Knatchbull, 1844
John Knatchbull, from an 1844 lithograph now held by the National Portrait Gallery in Canberra. Credit: Unknown artist, National Portrait Gallery, Canberra, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A Baronet's Son from Kent

Even Knatchbull's birth year isn't settled. The Australian Dictionary of Biography gives "1792?" and says he was probably the John Knatchbull baptised on 24 January 1793 at Norton, near Provender, in Kent. His biographer Colin Roderick, whose 1963 book is the standard account, puts his birth in 1789. The plate on his coffin in 1844 read "aged fifty-six". So take your pick, but somewhere between about 1787 and 1793.

His father was Sir Edward Knatchbull (1758–1819), 8th Baronet, of Mersham Hatch in Kent, and his mother was Sir Edward's second wife, Frances, daughter of Thomas Graham. The ADB describes Sir Edward as "a rollicking squire who married three times and had at least twenty children". John was a younger son in a very crowded house. According to Roderick (as summarised on Wikipedia), his mother died in 1799, and the children were left in the care of a governess. He went to school at Ashford and later to Dr Charles Burney's school at Greenwich, and the ADB says he also went to Winchester.

Oil sketch of Sir Edward Knatchbull and his family by John Singleton Copley, 1800 to 1803
John Singleton Copley's oil sketch for his big portrait of Sir Edward Knatchbull, 8th Baronet, with his children, painted between 1800 and 1803. John was still a boy then and is probably one of them, though I can't tell you which figure he is. Credit: John Singleton Copley, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

When Sir Edward died in 1819 the baronetcy went to John's elder half-brother, also Sir Edward Knatchbull, who followed his father into Parliament. That half-brother's name will come up again, right at the end of the story, on the papers found in John's pockets.

The Navy, and How It Ended

In August 1804, as a boy, Knatchbull joined the Royal Navy as a volunteer, the usual way in for a gentleman's younger son. Over the next few years he served in a string of ships: the ADB lists the Ardent, Revenge, Zealand, Sybille, Téméraire, Leonidas, Cumberland, Ocean and Ajax. He passed his lieutenant's examination in November 1810 and served in the Shearwater off Spain until he was invalided home in August 1812.

In December 1813 he was commissioned to command the sloop Doterel in the West Indies, but he missed the ship. Roderick's research found that he went down with yellow fever in Barbados while trying to catch up with her. He was reappointed to the Doterel in September 1814, and in 1815 he brought her from Bermuda by way of the Azores back to Portsmouth. Then came Waterloo, the navy was cut back hard, and Knatchbull was retired on half-pay.

What finished his naval career wasn't a battle. It was a wine bill. While the Doterel was at the Azores in April 1815 he had run up a debt with the British vice-consul at Fayal, Thomas Parkin, and the bills he gave in payment were not honoured. Parkin complained to the Admiralty, and in 1818, as the ADB puts it, his pay "was stopped by the Admiralty because of a debt he had incurred in the Azores". Roderick found that the Admiralty decided his "conduct was unbecoming the character of an officer" and took his name off the navy list. I couldn't find any record of a court-martial. For what it's worth, the Sydney paper The Australian told a different story in 1844, claiming he was dismissed from the service for tyranny. I've found nothing in the official record to back that up.

"John Fitch" at Vauxhall Gardens

Not much is known about his life between 1818 and 1824. In his own memoir he claimed he fought in South America, but there's no proof of it. What is certain is that on the evening of 30 June 1824, at a crowded fireworks night at Vauxhall Gardens in London, a gentleman named de Dompierre found that his coat pocket had been cut and his pocket-book taken. A man calling himself John Fitch was already in police hands on suspicion of picking pockets, and he had a blank cheque and several sovereigns on him.

"Fitch" was tried at the Surrey Assizes in Guildford in August 1824. The ADB and The Times report give the date as 21 August, while the ship's muster for the convict transport (quoted by Museums of History NSW) says 19 August. The Times reported that the judge, Justice Burrough, "perfectly knew who" the prisoner really was. He was found guilty of what the ADB calls "stealing with force and arms" and was sentenced to transportation for fourteen years.

Transported to New South Wales

Knatchbull sailed on the convict ship Asia and arrived in Sydney in April 1825; Roderick gives the date as 29 April. He was sent to Bathurst, where official records called him "John Fitch" or "John Fitch, alias Knatchbull". In November 1826 he was made a constable to the mail service, carrying the mail on foot between Bathurst and Mount York. He was given a ticket-of-leave on 24 August 1829 after helping to catch eight runaway convicts. His ticket was then moved to Liverpool, and by 1831 he was an overseer on the Parramatta Road.

For a while it looked as if he might settle down. He didn't. In December 1831 he paid for clothes at Charles Bailey's shop in George Street with a cheque signed, supposedly, by Judge James Dowling. The cheque was a forgery. Bailey later spotted him in the market and had him arrested. On 22 February 1832 the Supreme Court found him guilty and sentence of death was recorded against him. It was commuted to seven years at Norfolk Island.

The forged cheque in the name of Judge James Dowling, 1831
The forged cheque, made out in Judge James Dowling's name, that was used as evidence against Knatchbull in February 1832. Credit: State Records of New South Wales (now Museums of History NSW), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Norfolk Island: Poison and Mutiny

Knatchbull spent several months on the prison hulk Phoenix in Sydney Harbour before sailing for Norfolk Island on the Governor Phillip in October 1832. During the voyage some of the convicts plotted to poison the crew and guards and seize the ship, with Knatchbull, the one man aboard who could navigate, meant to sail her to South America. The plot was betrayed and failed. The ADB records it simply as "a conspiracy... to poison the ship's company".

On the island he had a stroke in 1833 that left him partly paralysed. In January 1834, when a large group of convicts rose against the guards, Knatchbull said he was too ill to take part, though he had offered to command a ship if they captured one. When the rising was put down, he turned informer for the acting commandant, Captain Foster Fyans. At the trials that followed, twenty-nine men were sentenced to death, and the judge, William Burton, gave Fyans a serve for taking Knatchbull's confession. The ADB quotes him:

"He was the chief of the mutineers, the man you should have named first in the Calendar. You have saved his life, or prolonged it. He never can do good."

Keep Justice Burton in mind. Ten years later, he would be the judge at Knatchbull's murder trial.

Port Macquarie, the Ticket-of-Leave, and Back to Sydney

Knatchbull's Norfolk Island sentence came on top of his original fourteen years, so when he got back to Sydney in May 1839 he still had time to serve. He was in poor health and was sent to Port Macquarie as an invalid. Roderick says he was later put in charge of the punt across the Hastings River. On 8 July 1842 he received a new ticket-of-leave, and in July 1843 it was altered to Sydney so he could work on the coaster Harriet for its owner, Thomas Lewis.

John Rae watercolour of Hyde Park with Darlinghurst Gaol in the distance, 1842
Hyde Park, Museum, Darlinghurst Gaol, Sydney Grammar School, Burdekin's and Lyons' Terraces, 1842, by John Rae. This was the Sydney Knatchbull came back to. Credit: John Rae, State Library of New South Wales, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

By the end of 1843 Lewis was insolvent and Knatchbull was out of work. He was lodging with Charles Hollowell in Clarence Lane, and he told Hollowell he owned the Harriet and was only waiting for her to be sold to pay his rent. He had also become engaged to a young widow named Harriet Craig, who had introduced him to Hollowell as a free man. The wedding was very close. His barrister said in court that it was to be the next morning; The Dispatch, as quoted by the Dictionary of Sydney, said the Monday. Either way, he had no money to pay for it.

Saturday Night, 6 January 1844

Ellen Jamieson ran a small shop from her home on the corner of Kent Street and Margaret Place, a few streets back from the harbour. That's how the Sydney Morning Herald described the location in its trial report. The Dictionary of Sydney puts her home in Erskine Street, which is close by, but I've gone with the address given in the 1844 papers. She had been widowed just over a year earlier, when her husband Robert, a steward on the Rose steamer and a native of Glasgow, died in December 1842. She had two small children, Mary, known as Polly, and Robert, known as Bobby. Her age isn't certain: the Herald reporter at the inquest thought she was about 30, while Wikipedia, citing her NSW death record, gives 35. Neighbours said she did a good trade, and one woman told the inquest that Ellen often changed banknotes for her. People knew she had money in the house.

John Shalless, a builder who lived opposite in Margaret Place, wasn't well that night. At about ten o'clock his wife warned him that a boy had seen a suspicious-looking man hanging about. Shalless went out onto his verandah and watched him walk up and down outside Mrs Jamieson's shop for more than an hour and a half. He saw the man go in and out, sit on the kerb, and throw something at her little white dog. At about twenty to twelve a customer, Mrs Elizabeth Brown, went into the shop and found a man behind the door "getting some vinegar". He bade them both good night and left.

A few minutes later Ellen came to her door, wiping her hands, and the man stepped up, spoke to her and followed her in, pushing the door shut behind him. Shalless told his wife, "I hope he does not mean to rob her." Then he heard the door slam and something fall. He ran across the road and found the door locked, and from inside he heard what he described as "some strokes given as of some one breaking a cocoanut with a hammer". He saw a light moving upstairs and the man pulling back the blind to look out.

Shalless asked a private watchman for help and was told, "Well, what is that to me?" So he roused the neighbours himself. While some watched the front, others broke in the back door. They found Ellen lying unconscious and bleeding heavily from wounds to her head, and the man standing behind the front door. He didn't fight. As they grabbed him he called out, "O! don't strike me." Constable Bryan Norton took him to the watch-house. Upstairs, the neighbours found Ellen's two children in bed, crying.

The weapon took a while to find. About two hours later Mrs Jaques, a neighbour, lifted the mattress on Ellen's bed and found a tomahawk hidden between the mattress and the battens, with fresh blood on it. Charles Hollowell knew it at once. It was his, and it had been lying in his back yard, where his lodger could get at it.

At the station Inspector Molloy searched the prisoner. In his trousers and pockets were a woman's pocket, which looked as if it had been torn from her clothes, and money totalling £17 2s 8d. He also had three bills of exchange for £50 each, made out to be drawn on his half-brother, Sir Edward Knatchbull, along with three blank ones. There was blood on his trousers and on his boots.

Twelve Days

Ellen Jamieson didn't die that night. The surgeon, Mr Jones, found several fractures of her skull. Her neighbours nursed her for twelve days, and she died between seven and eight o'clock on the morning of Thursday 18 January 1844. Mrs Brown, who used to do her mangling and mending, was with her at the end.

The inquest was held the same day at M'Kenzie's public house on the corner of Clarence Street and Margaret Place. Knatchbull was there and cross-examined the witnesses himself. The jury took about a minute to return a verdict of wilful murder, and the coroner made a point of praising Shalless "for the praiseworthy manner in which he had acted". The Herald said four or five hundred people waited outside. When Knatchbull was bundled into a hackney coach to go back to gaol, the crowd hooted and hissed.

The Trial: 24 January 1844

Knatchbull came to trial in the Supreme Court only six days after the inquest, on Wednesday 24 January 1844, before Justice William Burton, the same judge who had dealt with him on Norfolk Island. The Attorney-General, John Plunkett, prosecuted. His barrister was Robert Lowe, a newcomer to the colony who would later become a well-known figure in British politics.

Woodcut of John Knatchbull in court, 1844
"Knatchbull, as he appeared on his Trial", a woodcut from the booklet The Life of J. Knatchbull, published in Sydney in 1844. Credit: Unknown artist, H. Evers (publisher), State Library of New South Wales, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Lowe started on the indictment itself. Knatchbull had been charged as "John Fitch alias John Knatchbull", and Lowe objected to the name. The court amended the indictment to "John Knatchbull" only, and he pleaded not guilty. Lowe then asked for the trial to be put off, saying a settler from the Clarence River named John Tattersal could give Knatchbull an alibi. Justice Burton refused, as the affidavit didn't say clearly what Tattersal could prove.

The Crown's witnesses told the same story they had told at the inquest. Then Lowe did something unusual. He didn't really argue that Knatchbull hadn't done it. Instead he told the jury that even if every witness was right, Knatchbull was one of those people "for whom laws had not been made". Insanity, he said, could affect the will without touching the intellect, so that a man could know perfectly well what he was doing and still be driven to it by something he couldn't resist. He pointed to the recent M'Naghten case in England. He asked how a man born into a noble family, with every advantage, could have "fallen, step by step, into the lowest depths of disgrace, unless urged on by some resistless demon of insanity". And he asked why a man about to be married would do such a thing, when he had bills on his brother in his pocket that he could have cashed.

This was what came to be called the plea of "moral insanity". The ADB says Lowe raised it "for the first time in a British court", and the Dictionary of Sydney calls it the first time insanity ideas like these were tested in an Australian court. What we do know for sure is what Justice Burton said. He told the jury it was "the first time he (the Judge) had ever heard a doctrine of this kind broached in a Court of Justice", and that it had no place in the law of England, "nor... either in common sense or morality". Lowe had no witnesses to back it up. The two men he called, the Colonial Surgeon Patrick Harnett and a priest who had known Knatchbull in 1817 and 1818, both said they had never been in a position to judge his state of mind.

On motive, Burton told the jury that the money found on the prisoner, if they believed it came from Ellen's house and person, gave them "a probable motive for his conduct". In other words, robbery.

Vanity Fair caricature of Robert Lowe, 1869
Robert Lowe, Knatchbull's barrister, as Vanity Fair saw him in 1869, by which time he was a big name in British politics. Credit: Carlo Pellegrini, Vanity Fair, 27 February 1869, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Verdict and Sentence

The jury found him guilty without even leaving the box. Asked if he had anything to say, Knatchbull spoke of his upbringing and his naval service, claiming he had been in "twenty-one general engagements" and received "eleven wounds", and asked whether such a man would murder "a defenceless woman". Justice Burton sentenced him to death. He told Knatchbull that he had complained of too little time to prepare for his trial, yet he had given the woman he killed far less time to prepare for hers before her Maker.

Before the court rose, Plunkett suggested that the money found on Knatchbull should go to Ellen's children, and Burton agreed to recommend that it be placed in the Savings Bank for them. He also had harsh words for the police, who hadn't marked the tomahawk or the pocket as evidence, and for the watchman who had refused to help. "The public were mainly indebted to Mr. Shalless," he said.

The Appeal and the Plea for Mercy

Lowe wasn't finished. A few days after the trial he went back to the Supreme Court arguing that the sentence was illegal, because the judge hadn't directed that Knatchbull's body be dissected after execution (or, as Wikipedia summarises the petition, buried within the prison). The ADB says the appeal failed, and Wikipedia says the judges gave their decision on 1 February 1844.

There was one more try. According to Roderick, an attorney named Parry Long put a submission to the Governor, Sir George Gipps, on 8 February asking that a petition go to Queen Victoria. On 10 February Knatchbull was told it had failed. The Australian also reported that his two nephews in Sydney had kept him supplied with comforts in gaol and had "used every exertion" to save him. The Sheriff's Office, meanwhile, was writing to the Colonial Secretary on 6 February asking for extra armed guards for the execution. That letter is now in the NSW State Archives collection.

The Confession

Right up to the last weekend, Knatchbull denied the murder. Then he signed a short written confession, which The Australian printed:

"Condemned Cell, Woolloomooloo Gaol, 10th February, 1844. In the name of the Almighty God, Amen. I am guilty of the horrid deed for which I am to suffer death; and may the Lord have mercy on my soul. Amen. JOHN KNATCHBULL."

The papers didn't agree on exactly when or to whom he confessed. The Australian linked it to the "condemned sermon" on the Sunday, while The Dispatch said he confessed fully to Henry Keck, the keeper of the gaol, on the Monday night. The Dispatch added that he said he could not account for what had driven him to it. He also spent his last weeks writing the story of his life, finishing it on the morning of his execution and handing the manuscript to the gaol's governor.

Portrait of Henry Keck, Governor of the Gaol, 1847
Henry Keck, Governor of the gaol at Darlinghurst, drawn in 1847. Knatchbull wrote his life story in Keck's gaol and gave him the manuscript. Credit: William Nicholas, National Library of Australia, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

13 February 1844: The Hanging at Darlinghurst

The gaol at Darlinghurst had only been taking prisoners since 1841, and Knatchbull was the first man hanged there, and the first to go to a gallows built outside its walls, in full public view. Hangings had been public in Sydney for decades, but this was a new stage for them. The Dispatch said it stood "in front of the north gate", on ground so high it "could be seen from almost any part of Sydney". The ADB entry for the hangman puts it "outside the main gate". In my Darlinghurst Gaol post I placed the early public hangings at the main gate on Forbes Street.

People began walking across the Racecourse (today's Hyde Park) from six in the morning: men, women and children, on foot and in carts and carriages. Mounted police and soldiers kept the crowd back behind a chain. The crowd figures vary even within a single newspaper. The Australian's main report estimated "about ten thousand", but a second account printed in the same issue reckoned "between four and five thousand". Later writers, including the Dictionary of Sydney, have gone with more than ten thousand. Either way, it was an enormous number of people for a town the size of Sydney in 1844.

Sketch of the crowd at the execution of John Knatchbull outside Darlinghurst Gaol, 1844
"Woolloomooloo Gaol", Execution of John Knatchbull: the crowd outside the gaol on 13 February 1844. Credit: Artist unknown, State Library of New South Wales, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Just before nine the Sheriff, Keck and Captain Innes went to the condemned cell. Knatchbull walked out between the gaol chaplain, the Rev. Mr Elder, and the Rev. Mr Sharpe of Bathurst, joining in the burial service as it was read. He was dressed in a mourning suit with black gloves and held a white handkerchief. At the foot of the scaffold he knelt and prayed for about five minutes. Then he climbed up, helped by the executioner, Alexander Green, the colony's long-serving hangman. The ADB entry on Green calls this the most famous of the executions he carried out at Darlinghurst.

The cap was drawn over his face. The Australian heard him saying, "Lord have mercy on my soul! Christ have mercy on my soul!" when the bolt was drawn. The two papers don't agree about what happened next. The Australian's second account suggests death came quickly, but The Dispatch reported that the knot had slipped round to the back of his neck, "and the struggles of expiring strength were long and painful". Both said the crowd was quiet throughout. There was no jeering, and afterwards people simply went home.

Illustration of the scaffold outside Darlinghurst Gaol for the Knatchbull execution, published 1897
The scaffold outside Darlinghurst Gaol for Knatchbull's hanging, as drawn for the Truth newspaper more than fifty years later, on 8 August 1897. Credit: Unknown artist, Truth (Sydney), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Afterwards

Before his body was handed over to his family, a cast was taken of his head and face "for phrenological purposes", watched by many of Sydney's doctors. On 28 February The True Sun printed a woodcut of the cast. Early on the Wednesday morning a hearse and mourning coach took the coffin to what The Dispatch called "the Dissenting burial ground". The plate on it read "John Knatchbull, aged fifty-six". The Rev. Dr Ross of the Independent Chapel read the service. The mourners were two gentlemen and two ladies in deep mourning, and one more woman in black who stood apart from them.

What Became of Ellen Jamieson's Children

This is the part of the story I find hardest to read. Polly and Bobby Jamieson had lost their father in December 1842 and their mother in January 1844. A committee was formed to collect money for them, and its members included the Presbyterian minister Dr John Dunmore Lang and John Shalless, the neighbour who had raised the alarm. Lists for donations were left at the banks and on board the Hunter's River steamer.

Then, on 8 March 1844, Robert Lowe, Knatchbull's own barrister, applied to the Supreme Court to be made the children's guardian. The application was unopposed and was granted by the Chief Justice, Sir James Dowling, the same judge whose name Knatchbull had forged on that cheque back in 1831. Lang was furious that the man who had tried to save the murderer was now raising the victim's children, and he attacked Lowe in print.

The children lived in the Lowe household, and Wikipedia's account, drawing on Lowe's biographers, says their place there was somewhere between adopted children and servants. When the Lowes sailed for England on the Kate in January 1850, Polly and Bobby went with them. After that the accounts don't agree. A biography of Lowe from 1893 says Polly died young, soon after reaching England, and that Bobby went on to serve in New Zealand. A later biography from 1976 says Bobby died young in an asylum, and that Polly probably married and came back to Australia. I can't tell you which is right, and I'd rather leave it there than guess.

How Sydney Remembered Him

Sydney couldn't get enough of the story at the time. In the days before the execution a King Street printer advertised a lithograph of "John Knatchbull, the Murderer; and Mrs. Ellen Jamieson, his Victim" for a shilling. The Sydney Morning Herald grumbled that "the sooner he is forgotten the better". Four days after the hanging a booklet called The Life of J. Knatchbull was on sale, and the State Library of NSW still holds a copy. Roderick later wrote that many of the versions that followed painted Knatchbull "as a monster of bloody appetites". His own manuscript life story was eventually published in Roderick's 1963 biography, John Knatchbull: From Quarterdeck to Gallows. More than fifty years on, in 1897, the Truth newspaper was still printing pictures of his scaffold.

For the law, Lowe's "moral insanity" defence is still the part people write about, and it has been studied as an early attempt to bring that idea into an Australian courtroom. For Darlinghurst, Knatchbull was the first of the many people hanged at the gaol. The walls are still there in Forbes Street, and these days they're full of art students rather than prisoners.

The sandstone entrance of the former Darlinghurst Gaol, now the National Art School
The sandstone entrance of the former Darlinghurst Gaol, now the National Art School. Credit: Sardaka, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

For me, the people worth remembering from that Saturday night are John Shalless, who wouldn't look away when the watchman did, the neighbours who broke down the back door, the women who nursed Ellen for twelve days, and Ellen Jamieson herself, a hard-working widow trying to keep a roof over two little children in 1840s Sydney.

Timeline

  • c.1789–1793 – John Knatchbull born in Kent; the ADB says probably baptised at Norton on 24 January 1793, while Roderick gives 1789.
  • August 1804 – Joins the Royal Navy as a volunteer.
  • November 1810 – Passes his lieutenant's examination.
  • 1814–1815 – Commands the sloop Doterel; retired on half-pay after Waterloo.
  • 1818 – Half-pay stopped over the Azores debt, and his name is removed from the navy list.
  • 30 June 1824 – Arrested at Vauxhall Gardens, London, as "John Fitch".
  • August 1824 – Convicted at the Surrey Assizes and sentenced to fourteen years' transportation.
  • April 1825 – Arrives in Sydney on the Asia; sent to Bathurst.
  • 24 August 1829 – First ticket-of-leave.
  • 22 February 1832 – Convicted of forging Judge Dowling's name; death recorded, commuted to seven years on Norfolk Island.
  • October 1832 – Poison plot on the Governor Phillip fails.
  • January 1834 – Norfolk Island rising; Knatchbull turns informer.
  • May 1839 – Returns to Sydney; later sent to Port Macquarie.
  • 8 July 1842 – New ticket-of-leave, altered to Sydney in July 1843.
  • Saturday 6 January 1844 – Ellen Jamieson attacked in her shop near midnight; Knatchbull caught inside.
  • Thursday 18 January 1844 – Ellen Jamieson dies; inquest returns wilful murder.
  • Wednesday 24 January 1844 – Trial before Justice Burton; guilty; sentenced to death.
  • 1 February 1844 – Appeal over the wording of the sentence rejected.
  • 10 February 1844 – Petition for mercy fails; written confession signed.
  • Tuesday 13 February 1844 – Hanged outside Darlinghurst Gaol.
  • 8 March 1844 – Robert Lowe appointed guardian of the Jamieson children.
  • January 1850 – The Lowes leave for England with Polly and Bobby.





Sources

Monday, October 5, 2026

Hangings at Darlinghurst Gaol – The Executions and Famous Prisoners

If you have ever walked along Forbes Street or up Darlinghurst Road past the long sandstone walls of the National Art School, you have walked past the place where Sydney hanged its condemned prisoners for more than sixty years. In my earlier post on Darlinghurst Gaol and Darlinghurst Court I covered the buildings themselves: the convict-quarried sandstone, the radial wings, and how the old gaol became the art school. This time I wanted to look at the darker side of the place, the hangings, and the people who are remembered because of it.

Before I start, a word about how I have gone about this. Nearly every name here belongs to someone who was killed or badly hurt, and to families who had to live with it. Where the records name the victims I have used their names, except for children who were sexually assaulted. Where my sources disagree, I say so.

Aerial photograph of Darlinghurst Gaol in 1930 with the courthouse in front
Darlinghurst Gaol from the air in 1930, with the courthouse at the front and the radial wings behind the walls. Mitchell Library, State Library of NSW (scan uploaded by Adam.J.W.C.), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

From George Street to Darlinghurst

In the years before 1841, Sydney's hangings were carried out at the old Sydney Gaol on the corner of George and Essex Streets in The Rocks. The last man hanged there was Michael Lynch, a sawyer from the Illawarra, on 4 June 1841. Three days later, on 7 June, the prisoners were walked in chains from the old gaol to the new one on Darlinghurst hill, 407 men and 39 women, by one count.

That date matters, because plenty of lists online mix the two gaols up. You will sometimes see the seven men hanged for the Myall Creek massacre listed as executed at Darlinghurst. They were hanged at the old Sydney Gaol on 18 December 1838, nearly three years before Darlinghurst opened, so it always pays to check a date against 1841.

The public hangings, 1841 to 1852

The first hangings

The first two men hanged at Darlinghurst went to the gallows together on 29 October 1841. George Stroud (sometimes spelt Stroode) had murdered his wife Sarah at Concord, and Robert Hudson had killed a fellow convict, Dean West, at the General Hospital in Macquarie Street. The scaffold was put up in the gaol yard and the public were let in to watch: between five and six hundred people, the papers said.

A year later the gaol tried something different. On 8 November 1842 four men convicted of piracy at Norfolk Island, George Beavor, John Jones, Henry Sears and Nicholas Lewis (alias Head), were hanged in the yard, but only people with a written order from the Sheriff, the visiting magistrate or the gaol governor were let in. The Colonial Observer approved: the more private such "disgusting and demoralising spectacles" were, the better. The next morning Stephen Brennan, convicted of murdering Pat Lynch on Norfolk Island, was hanged in the same yard before eighty to a hundred ticket-holders.

John Knatchbull and the scaffold outside the gate

That early attempt at privacy did not last. The first hanging held outside the gaol walls was the one people still talk about, the execution of John Knatchbull on 13 February 1844.

Knatchbull had been a Royal Navy captain who served in the wars against France. He came down in the world, was transported to New South Wales in 1824 under the name John Fitch, and later did years on Norfolk Island for forgery. On the night of 6 January 1844 he went into the little shop Ellen Jamieson ran from her home on the corner of Kent Street and Margaret Place and attacked her with a tomahawk to rob her. Ellen was a widow of about 35 with two small children, Mary and Robert. A neighbour, John Shalless, raised the alarm and the locals broke in and found Knatchbull hiding behind the door. Ellen died eleven days later, on 18 January.

Lithograph portrait of John Knatchbull, 1844
John Knatchbull, from a lithograph sold in Sydney around the time of his execution in 1844. National Portrait Gallery, Canberra, unknown artist, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

His barrister, Robert Lowe (later a British cabinet minister), tried what the judge called a brand-new defence, that Knatchbull had acted under an "irresistible impulse", a kind of moral insanity. The jury did not even leave the box. Knatchbull later confessed in writing, "I am Guilty of the Horrid Deed for which I am justly to suffer Death".

The gallows were built outside the gaol in Forbes Street, by the gate. The crowd that came up Darlinghurst hill on the morning of the hanging was put at about ten thousand: men, women and children, held back by soldiers and police. The rope was not set properly and he took at least two minutes to die. Afterwards a plaster cast was taken of his head "for phrenological purposes", and printers sold pictures of him and of Ellen Jamieson for a shilling.

Crowd gathered outside Darlinghurst Gaol for the execution of John Knatchbull in 1844
The crowd outside the gaol (then often called Woolloomooloo Gaol) for the hanging of John Knatchbull, February 1844. State Library of NSW, artist not recorded, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The hangman in the hut by the wall

The man who hanged Knatchbull, and nearly everyone else in New South Wales for twenty-one years, was Alexander Green. He had arrived as a convict in 1824, worked for years as a flogger, and became the colony's executioner in February 1834. The older biography of him claimed he hanged 490 people, but the historian Pamela Harrison, working from the NSW Capital Convictions Database, puts it at about 251, which is still a frightening number.

In 1842 Green was allowed to build a whitewashed hut at his own expense outside the eastern wall of the gaol, and he lived there for about ten years. The spot later became Green Park, but here is the twist: the park is named after James Green, the local alderman from 1869 to 1883, not the hangman. Alexander Green drank heavily, did a stint as a prisoner in Darlinghurst himself in 1850, was certified insane in 1855 and died in 1879.

The old sandstone gates of Darlinghurst Gaol, now the National Art School
The old gaol gates, now the way in to the National Art School. Photo: Sardaka, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The last public hanging at Darlinghurst

Through the 1840s the public hangings went on; John Ahern in 1845, William Fyfe in 1848 and Owen Molloy in 1849 are all recorded as public, Molloy dying "on the drop in front of Darlinghurst Gaol". The last public hanging there was Francis Thomas Green (no relation to the hangman) on Tuesday 21 September 1852. He was a sly-grog seller who had shot his partner, John Jones, "the Tinker", at Buckley's Creek on the goldfields near Bathurst. A neat dresser to the end, he changed his shoes because they had got dirty and went up the scaffold dressed in white with a small cross around his neck.

It was a drizzly morning, and Bell's Life was more interested in the crowd than the prisoner, complaining that women outnumbered men nearly three to one, including a carriage full of "women of respectable exterior" parked right in front of the drop. That sort of reporting tells you which way public opinion was moving.

You will often read that Francis Green was the last person publicly hanged in New South Wales. He was the last at Darlinghurst, but not in the colony. Public hangings carried on at country gaols for a while; Patrick McCarthy and an Aboriginal man recorded only as Paddy were hanged outside Bathurst Gaol in April 1853, for example. Darlinghurst simply had no more hangings until the law changed.

The law changes: executions move inside the walls

The NSW Legislative Council passed An Act to Regulate the Execution of Criminals on 17 August 1853. Because it changed British law it had to wait for the Queen's assent, and it only took effect in January 1855: the Sydney Law Review says 11 January, while Rachel Franks of the State Library, writing for the Dictionary of Sydney, says it was proclaimed on 10 January. From then on, hangings had to happen inside a gaol before officials and a few witnesses. Britain did not follow until 1868.

The first private hanging under the new law, and according to the historian Steven Anderson the first on the Australian continent, was at Darlinghurst on 28 February 1855. William Ryan had murdered his wife Catherine near the corner of Hay and Castlereagh Streets. The date was kept so quiet that hardly anyone knew, and the women and children gathered outside saw nothing: "the new arrangements prevented the gratification of their curiosity". It was Alexander Green's last job. When Samuel Wilcox and William Rodgers were hanged on 5 July 1855, the rope was handled by his successor, Robert Elliott.

Where the gallows stood

This is something I wanted to pin down, because you will see different answers. From what I have found, there were really four places over the years:

  • 1841 and 1842: temporary gallows in the gaol yard, open to the public in 1841 and ticket-only in 1842.
  • 1844 to 1852: the public scaffold outside the main gate on Forbes Street, on the north-west side. Wikipedia adds that it was later replaced by a platform above the gate, which I have not been able to confirm.
  • 1869 to 1886: a permanent gallows inside the walls at the north-east corner, near Burton Street and Darlinghurst Road: a small platform in the angle of a building, so a prisoner could walk straight from the cell to the drop. Thomas Kelly was the first hanged on it, on 2 January 1872, and the names of those hanged there were recorded on the beam above.
  • 1887 onwards: a new gallows in E wing, built by Hudson Brothers just before the Mount Rennie hangings in January 1887. The old one could be seen from high ground outside the walls, it was within earshot of any crowd outside, and it was too small to hang several people at once.

Between 1855 and 1869 the papers only say the hangings took place "within the grounds" or "within the precincts". In later years, witnesses with a Sheriff's order came in through the courthouse and signed a book before being led through to the gaol.

Drawing of the gallows at Darlinghurst Gaol seen from the keep yard
'The Gallows from the Keep Yard: The Scaffold at Darlinghurst, Drawn by a Confinee', 19th century. State Library of NSW, unknown artist, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Bushrangers on the Darlinghurst gallows

In the 1860s the bushrangers filled the condemned cells. Henry Manns was hanged on 26 March 1863 for his part in the Eugowra Rocks gold escort robbery planned by Frank Gardiner's gang. John Dunn of Ben Hall's gang shot dead Constable Samuel Nelson, the only policeman at Collector, during a hold-up in January 1865. Dunn was hanged on 19 March 1866, aged 19.

Thomas and John Clarke, brothers from the Braidwood district, ran the last big organised bushranging gang in New South Wales. After four special constables were ambushed and killed near Jinden in January 1867, the brothers were hunted down, and they were hanged side by side at Darlinghurst on 25 June 1867.

Captain Moonlite

The bushranger most people have heard of is Andrew George Scott, "Captain Moonlite". Irish-born and raised partly in New Zealand, he had already served time in Pentridge prison in Victoria. In November 1879 he and a band of young men, hungry and broke after being refused work, held up Wantabadgery station near Wagga Wagga. In the shootout with police at McGlede's farm that followed, Senior Constable Edward Webb Bowen was fatally wounded, and Scott's close companion James Nesbitt was shot dead.

Scott and Thomas Rogan were hanged together at Darlinghurst at 8 o'clock on the morning of 20 January 1880. Scott went to the gallows wearing a ring woven from a lock of Nesbitt's hair, and asked to be buried beside him: "My dying wish is to be buried beside my beloved James Nesbitt". The authorities refused. In January 1995 his remains were finally taken from Rookwood and reburied at Gundagai, near Nesbitt's grave. Another gang member, Thomas Williams (alias Frank Johns), was spared in 1880, but after he stabbed a fellow prisoner at Parramatta Gaol he was hanged at Darlinghurst on 14 July 1885.

Carte de visite photograph of Andrew George Scott, Captain Moonlite
Andrew George Scott, 'Captain Moonlite', around 1879. Believed to be by Charles Nettleton; National Portrait Gallery (Victoria Police Historical Collection), restored by Adam Cuerden, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The man who shot a prince

One of the strangest cases is Henry James O'Farrell. On 12 March 1868, at a picnic at Clontarf, he shot and wounded Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh, Queen Victoria's second son. The prince recovered. O'Farrell pleaded insanity but was convicted of wounding with intent to murder and hanged at Darlinghurst on 21 April 1868, after the first attempted political assassination in Australia.

"Nosey Bob", the hangman everyone knew

For most of the later hangings at Darlinghurst the hangman was Robert Rice Howard, known to all of Sydney as "Nosey Bob". He was born around 1832 at Marham in Norfolk, England, came out to Queensland in 1866 and drove a cab in Sydney. In the mid-1870s, while he was still working as a cabman, he lost his nose. He became assistant hangman in 1875 and chief executioner from 1877.

Over twenty-eight years he took part in 62 executions around the state, 59 of them as the man in charge. Rachel Franks, in her 2022 biography of him, counts twelve as bungled, where the prisoner strangled rather than died from the drop. From about 1887 he lived in a weatherboard cottage on Ben Buckler at North Bondi, where he kept bees, fished for sharks, and was said to have trained his horse to fetch beer from the Cliff House Hotel. In November 1887 a gang of young men set on him at Bondi and threatened to hang him. He retired in May 1904, died at North Bondi on 3 February 1906 and is buried at Waverley Cemetery. His assistant George Russell took over as hangman.

Newspaper portrait of the hangman Robert 'Nosey Bob' Howard, 1901
Robert 'Nosey Bob' Howard, as drawn in Truth two days after the hanging of Jimmy Governor, 20 January 1901. Truth (Sydney), unknown artist, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Mount Rennie hangings, 1887

On 9 September 1886 a sixteen-year-old girl named Mary Jane Hicks was tricked into a hansom cab by the driver, Charles Sweetman, and taken to scrubland at a spot called Mount Rennie, in what is now the Moore Park and Waterloo area. There she was set upon and raped by a gang of young larrikins. A passer-by, William Stanley, tried to help her, was driven off with bricks and bottles, and ran all the way to Redfern police station.

Eleven young men were tried before Justice Windeyer in November 1886 and nine were sentenced to death. After a big public campaign five sentences were commuted. The other four, George Duffy, Joseph Martin, William Boyce and Robert Read, aged 17 to 20, were hanged together on the new E wing gallows on 7 January 1887, with about two thousand people waiting outside the gates. Howard made a mess of it: only Duffy's neck was broken, and Martin is thought to have lived for about ten minutes.

It is hard to read about now from either side. A teenage girl went through something terrible and then had her character dragged through some of the newspapers, and four young men died badly on the end of a rope. The reprieved men were all released in November 1896, ten years after their trial.

Louisa Collins, the last woman hanged in New South Wales

Louisa Collins was born Louisa Hall on 11 August 1847 at Belltrees station near Scone. At Merriwa she met Charles Andrews, a butcher, and married him, and the family later moved to Sydney and settled at Botany, where they took in boarders. Charles Andrews died after a sudden illness on 2 February 1887. Two months later Louisa married one of the boarders, Michael Collins, and in July 1888 he too died, after an illness very like her first husband's. The Government Analyst found arsenic in his body. Charles Andrews was exhumed and arsenic was found in his remains as well.

Louisa was tried four times. Three juries could not agree. The fourth, in December 1888, found her guilty of murdering Michael Collins. There was a public meeting at Sydney Town Hall on 3 January 1889 to try to save her, petitions went to the Governor, Lord Carington, and on 7 January two of her daughters went to Government House to plead with him. He would not see them himself and sent his secretary to give them the answer.

She was hanged at Darlinghurst on the morning of 8 January 1889. Even then it went wrong. The lever would not move because the pin holding it was stuck, and Howard's assistant had to knock it out with a mallet while she stood on the trapdoor with the cap over her head, "perfectly upright and motionless". She was buried at Rookwood that afternoon. No woman has been hanged in New South Wales since.

Prison photograph of Louisa Collins taken in July 1888
Louisa Collins, prison photograph dated 28 July 1888, not long after her arrest. Museums of History NSW, unknown photographer, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Other cases Sydney talked about

A few more of the Darlinghurst cases made headlines well beyond Sydney:

  • John Makin, 15 August 1893. John and Sarah Makin were "baby farmers" who took in infants for money; babies' bodies were found at houses they had lived in, including Burren Street, Macdonaldtown. Sarah's death sentence was commuted. John was hanged for the murder of the infant Horace Murray.
  • The Bridge Street burglars, 31 May 1894. Charles Montgomery and Thomas Williams were hanged together for wounding Constable Frederick Bowden with intent to murder, near Circular Quay.
  • Alfred Grenon, 31 January 1895. A Frenchman who shot a watchman, Thomas Heavey, in Elizabeth Bay Road. Heavey lived; Grenon is said to be the last person executed in Australia for attempted murder.
  • Frank Butler, 16 July 1897. Often called Australia's first serial killer. He advertised for mates to go prospecting, had them dig what they thought was a prospecting hole, then shot them and buried them in it. His known victims were Charles Burgess, Arthur Preston and Captain Lee Weller, at Glenbrook. On the scaffold he told Howard impatiently to "Let go!"

Jimmy Governor

Of all the people hanged at Darlinghurst, the one I most wanted to get right is Jimmy Governor, because his story is so often told badly.

Jimmy was born about 1875 on the Talbragar River, near Denison Town, in the central west of New South Wales; that is where the Australian Dictionary of Biography and the Dictionary of Sydney place his birth. His father Tommy Governor (or Grosvenor) was an Aboriginal man from the Namoi River country, and his mother Annie Fitzgerald was raised near Mendooran. The eldest of eight children, Jimmy went to school at Denison Town, Wollar and Gulgong, worked as a fencer and horse-breaker, and was a police tracker at Cassilis from 1896 to 1897. In December 1898 he married Ethel Page, a sixteen-year-old white girl, at Gulgong. At his trial he said, "I always worked, and paid for what I got, and I reckon I am as good as a white man."

Photograph of Jimmy Governor taken in 1900
Jimmy Governor in 1900. NSW State Archives, unknown photographer, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Gilgandra district has a strong claim on his story, and people out that way rightly count him as part of their history. It was while he was breaking horses around Gilgandra that Jimmy met John Mawbey, who gave him a fencing contract at Breelong, on Wallumburrawang Creek about ten miles south-east of Gilgandra. Jimmy, Ethel, their baby, his brother Joe and their friend Jacky Underwood camped on the property. By the accounts given after the event, Jimmy and Ethel put up with plenty of small humiliations from the household: the women laughing at Ethel's baby, complaints about the rations bill, posts rejected.

On the night of 20 July 1900 Jimmy and Jacky Underwood attacked the Mawbey household. They killed or fatally wounded Sarah Mawbey, her children Grace, Percy and Hilda, and the young schoolteacher Ellen (also called Helen) Kerz, who boarded with the family and taught the children. The inquest was held at the homestead, Ethel was locked up at Gilgandra police station, and Underwood was later committed for trial at the Gilgandra Police Court.

Jimmy and Joe then spent fourteen weeks on the run across a huge stretch of the state. Along the way they killed Alexander McKay near Ulan, Elizabeth O'Brien and her baby at Poggy near Merriwa, and Kieran Fitzpatrick, aged 74, near Wollar. Hundreds of police and volunteers hunted them. Jimmy was shot in the mouth in mid-October and caught near Bobin, inland from Wingham, on 27 October 1900. Joe was never hanged; he was shot dead a few days later north of Singleton.

Jacky Underwood was hanged at Dubbo on 14 January 1901. Howard went straight back to Sydney, and four days later, on the morning of 18 January 1901, Jimmy Governor was hanged at Darlinghurst for the murder of Ellen Kerz. Thomas Keneally based his 1972 novel The Chant of Jimmie Blacksmith on his life, and Fred Schepisi made it into a film in 1978. However you read the story, nine people died, and the racism that Jimmy and Ethel lived with is part of it too.

The last hanging at Darlinghurst

After Howard's final double hanging of Digby Grand and Henry Jones in July 1903, for murdering Constable Samuel Long at Auburn, there was only one more execution at Darlinghurst. Nicholas Baxter murdered Mary MacNamara, an older woman, at 2 Sarah Street, Enmore, in July 1907, and was hanged at Darlinghurst on 29 October 1907. The reports said it was carried out "quietly and quickly", and that he died holding rosary beads.

The new State Penitentiary at Long Bay opened in 1914 and Darlinghurst closed the same year. From then on, Sydney's hangings were at Long Bay. The last person executed in New South Wales was John Trevor Kelly at Long Bay on 24 August 1939, and the death penalty for murder was abolished in this state in 1955.

Famous prisoners who walked out again

Not everyone famous at Darlinghurst went there to die. A few of the better-known guests:

  • Henry Lawson. Our best-known writer was locked up at Darlinghurst seven times between 1905 and 1909, mostly for drunkenness and unpaid maintenance, 159 days in all. His poem "One Hundred and Three" (his prison number, 1908) gave the place its nickname, "Starvinghurst Gaol".
  • J. F. Archibald. The founding editor of The Bulletin, the man the Archibald Prize is named after, also did time there.
  • George Dibbs. The future Premier refused to pay £2,000 damages after losing a slander case, and spent a year in Darlinghurst from May 1880, entertaining visitors and working at a lathe supplied by Henry Parkes. He came out more popular than when he went in.
  • Henry Louis Bertrand. The man convicted over the 1865 murder of Henry Kinder was not hanged. He served about 28 years, most of them at Darlinghurst, and in 1891 he painted the watercolour of the gaol below, which is now in the State Library.

People sometimes ask about Ned Kelly's gang. None of them were hanged at Darlinghurst. The closest link is Thomas Reilly, a cousin of Ned and Dan Kelly, who was hanged at Wagga Wagga in November 1889 for shooting a drover's overseer.

Watercolour of Darlinghurst Gaol painted by prisoner Henry Louis Bertrand in 1891
Darlinghurst Gaol in watercolour, signed 'H.L. Bertrand 1891', painted by a long-term prisoner of the gaol. Henry Louis Bertrand, State Library of NSW, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

So how many were hanged at Darlinghurst?

This turned out to be the hardest question of all. There is no single official list that I could find online, and the figures do not agree:

  • The Dictionary of Sydney says a total of 79 people were executed at the gaol.
  • The Wikipedia article on the gaol, drawing on the old NSW Police history website, says 76.
  • When I went through Wikipedia's List of people legally executed in New South Wales and picked out every hanging recorded at Darlinghurst between 1841 and 1907, I counted 76 names. That list is marked as incomplete, so the match with the 76 figure may be partly luck.

I checked as many entries as I could against the original newspaper reports on Trove and the biographies of the two hangmen, and corrected three dates along the way: James Morrison (20 August 1889, not 19 July), Alfred Grenon (31 January 1895, not 7 February) and Frank Butler (16 July 1897, not 17 July). If you know of a name I have missed, please tell me in the comments.

The executions at Darlinghurst Gaol, 1841 to 1907

This list is based on Wikipedia's List of people legally executed in New South Wales, checked against Trove newspaper reports, the Dictionary of Sydney, and the Wikipedia biographies of Alexander Green and Robert Howard. Up to September 1852 these were the years of public hangings at Darlinghurst. From February 1855 every hanging was held privately inside the walls.

#DateNameCrime
129 Oct 1841Robert HudsonMurder of fellow convict Dean West at the General Hospital, Macquarie Street
229 Oct 1841George Stroud (Stroode)Murder of his wife Sarah at Concord
38 Nov 1842George BeavorPiracy at Norfolk Island
48 Nov 1842John JonesPiracy at Norfolk Island
58 Nov 1842Henry SearsPiracy at Norfolk Island
68 Nov 1842Nicholas Lewis (alias Head)Piracy at Norfolk Island
79 Nov 1842Stephen BrennanMurder of Pat Lynch on Norfolk Island
813 Feb 1844John KnatchbullMurder of Ellen Jamieson, Kent Street
913 Aug 1844George VigorsMurder of James Noble in Clarence Street
1013 Aug 1844Thomas BurdettMurder of James Noble in Clarence Street
117 Feb 1845John VidallMurder of Thomas Warne in George Street
1212 Aug 1845John AhernMurder of his niece Mary-Anne Clark, near today's Railway Square
1330 Apr 1847John Kean (Liddell)Murder of Ellen Hyndes near Campbelltown
144 Jul 1848William FyfeMurder of Robert Cox at Kangaroo Point, Moreton Bay
1522 Sep 1848Francis DermottRape, Shoalhaven district
167 May 1849James RichardsonMurder of his wife Elizabeth at Campbelltown
1718 Sep 1849Owen MolloyMurder of John Leonard at Moreton Bay
185 Nov 1850Mogo Gar (Bundjalung man)Murder of Daniel Page on the Bellinger River
195 Nov 1850James WhelanMurder of Catherine Byrnes near Kent Street
2021 Sep 1852Francis Thomas GreenMurder of John Jones at Buckley's Creek near Bathurst (last public hanging at Darlinghurst)
Public hangings end. The Act to Regulate the Execution of Criminals takes effect in January 1855.
2128 Feb 1855William RyanMurder of his wife Catherine near Hay and Castlereagh Streets (first private hanging)
225 Jul 1855William RodgersMurder of Joseph Allsopp at Baulkham Hills
235 Jul 1855Samuel WilcoxMurder of Johanna Smith in Liverpool Street
247 Sep 1858James MoyesMurder of William Alden aboard the ship Oliver Jordan in Sydney
2522 Jul 1859John NorrisRape of a six-year-old girl near Prospect
2616 May 1860William GoodsonMurder of his wife Mary at Kissing Point
2718 Mar 1863Alexander RossHighway robbery and attempted murder of Harry Stephens at Caloola
2818 Mar 1863Charles RossHighway robbery and attempted murder of Harry Stephens at Caloola
2926 Mar 1863Henry MannsEugowra gold escort robbery
301 Feb 1864Thomas McCannHighway robbery and attempted murder of William Saville near Berrima
3119 Mar 1866John DunnMurder of Constable Samuel Nelson at Collector
3214 Apr 1866James CrookwellMurder of Constable William Raymond in the Bargo Brush
3311 Jun 1866Michael GreenMurder of Andrew Shearer at Rushcutters Bay
3418 Mar 1867William Henry ScottMurder of Anne Ramsden (Scott) in Sussex Street
3525 Jun 1867Thomas ClarkeBushranging; attempted murder of Constable William Walsh at Jinden
3625 Jun 1867John ClarkeBushranging; attempted murder of Constable William Walsh at Jinden
3721 Apr 1868Henry James O'FarrellShooting Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh, at Clontarf
382 Jan 1872Thomas KellyAttempted murder of William McLaren at Parramatta Gaol (first on the 1869 gallows)
3918 Jun 1872George Robert NicholsMurders of William Percy Walker and John Bridger (Parramatta River murders)
4018 Jun 1872Alfred Lester (alias Froude)Murders of William Percy Walker and John Bridger (Parramatta River murders)
418 Apr 1873William McCrowMurder of Margaret Ward at Woolloomooloo
428 Apr 1873John ScourceMurder of Elizabeth Lee on Sydney Harbour
431 Jul 1873Julius Krauss (William Cross)Murder of Captain Longmuir aboard the Rifleman
4423 Dec 1873Henry Vincent JarvisMurder of James Muggeridge near Evans Plains Creek
4510 Sep 1875John McGrathRape near Bega
4618 Apr 1876Ah ChongMurder of Po Tie at Parramatta Gaol
4720 Jan 1880Andrew George Scott ('Captain Moonlite')Murder of Senior Constable Edward Webb Bowen, Wantabadgery
4820 Jan 1880Thomas RoganMurder of Senior Constable Edward Webb Bowen, Wantabadgery
4929 Mar 1881William BrownRape of his twelve-year-old daughter, Manning River district
5023 Apr 1884William RiceMurder of James Griffin in Surry Hills
5114 Apr 1885Charles WatsonMurder of William Matthews near Hillston
5214 Jul 1885Thomas Williams (alias Frank Johns)Attempted murder of prisoner William Roberts at Parramatta Gaol
538 Oct 1886Alfred ReynoldsMurder of his wife Rhoda at Newtown
547 Jan 1887George DuffyMount Rennie rape of Mary Jane Hicks
557 Jan 1887Joseph MartinMount Rennie rape of Mary Jane Hicks
567 Jan 1887William BoyceMount Rennie rape of Mary Jane Hicks
577 Jan 1887Robert ReadMount Rennie rape of Mary Jane Hicks
5811 Sep 1888Robert HewartMurder of Thomas Park in a cell at the Central Police Station
598 Jan 1889Louisa CollinsMurder of her husband Michael Collins at Botany
6020 Aug 1889James MorrisonMurder of Constable David Sutherland at Potts Point
6117 Nov 1891Maurice DaltonMurder of his wife Catherine in Foveaux Street, Surry Hills
6213 Jun 1893Edward SmedleyMurder of his wife Phoebe at Quirindi
6311 Jul 1893George ArcherRape and murder of Emma Harrison in Bourke Street, Darlinghurst
6415 Aug 1893John MakinMurder of the infant Horace Murray (baby farming)
6531 May 1894Charles MontgomeryWounding Constable Frederick Bowden with intent to murder
6631 May 1894Thomas WilliamsWounding Constable Frederick Bowden with intent to murder
6731 Jan 1895Alfred GrenonShooting watchman Thomas Heavey with intent to murder, Elizabeth Bay Road
687 Jan 1896Thomas Meredith SheridanDeath of Jessie Nicholls after an illegal operation
6916 Jul 1897Frank ButlerMurder of Captain Lee Weller at Glenbrook
705 Apr 1899Stuart Wilson Christopher BriggsMurders of Margaret Dutt and her grandmother Margaret Millar at Petersham
7118 Jan 1901Jimmy GovernorMurder of Ellen (Helen) Kerz at Breelong, near Gilgandra
7220 Dec 1901Joseph CampbellRape of a nine-year-old girl near Queanbeyan
7314 Apr 1903Thomas MooreRape and murder of ten-year-old Janet (Janey) Smith at Ramsay's Bush
747 Jul 1903Digby GrandMurder of Constable Samuel Long at Auburn
757 Jul 1903Henry JonesMurder of Constable Samuel Long at Auburn
7629 Oct 1907Nicholas BaxterMurder of Mary MacNamara at Enmore (last hanging at Darlinghurst)

It is strange to walk past those gates today, with art students sitting on the steps with their coffee. Most of the people on that list are forgotten now, and so are most of the people they hurt. I think it is worth knowing their names.

Sources

Further reading, not online: Deborah Beck, Hope in Hell: A History of Darlinghurst Gaol and the National Art School (Allen & Unwin, 2005); Rachel Franks, An Uncommon Hangman: The Life and Deaths of Robert 'Nosey Bob' Howard (NewSouth, 2022).