Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Governor King. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Governor King. Show all posts

Sunday, October 18, 2026

Pemulwuy – Bidjigal Resistance Leader of Botany Bay and Parramatta – The 'Rainbow Warrior' and the Search for His Head in England – c.1750 to 1802

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander readers are advised that this page contains the names and images of people who have died, as well as descriptions of violence and the treatment of human remains. Some quotes from colonial records use language of their time.

For a long time Pemulwuy hardly rated a mention in Sydney's history books. Yet for twelve years, from 1790 to 1802, this Bidjigal man led the fight against the new settlement, from Botany Bay to the farms at Parramatta, Toongabbie, Prospect and the Hawkesbury. He was shot and taken prisoner, and he escaped in irons. In the end he was shot dead, and his head was cut off, put in spirits and shipped to England for Sir Joseph Banks. More than two hundred years later, nobody knows where it is.

This is his story, as best the records let us tell it. Most of what we know comes from the people who were trying to catch or kill him, so I've tried to say who said what. I've also tried to sort out the "Rainbow Warrior" name, which a lot of people think is a traditional title. It isn't. It's the title of a 1987 novel.

Engraving of Pimbloy, Native of New Holland in a canoe, 1803
'Pimbloy: Native of New Holland in a Canoe of that Country', engraved after a lost drawing by James Grant, 1803. It's thought it may show Pemulwuy, but nobody can be sure. James Grant (engraved by Samuel John Neele), 1803, State Library of NSW, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Bidjigal Country – Botany Bay and the Georges River

Pemulwuy was born around 1750 near what the British later called Botany Bay, on the northern side of the Georges River. That's according to J. L. Kohen in the Australian Dictionary of Biography. He spoke a dialect of the Darug (Dharug) language. The ADB says his name came from the Darug word pemul, meaning earth. Keith Vincent Smith, writing in the Dictionary of Sydney, gives it as Pemall (bimul), meaning earth or clay. The colonists spelled it every which way: Pemulwhy, Pemulwoy, Pimbloy, Bimblewove and Bumbleway are a few of them.

His people were the Bidjigal (also written Bediagal). Smith describes their country as stretching "from Botany Bay south of the Cooks River and west along the Georges River to Salt Pan Creek, south of Bankstown". Bidjigal, he says, literally means "River Flat Clan". He also notes there was a second Bidjigal clan around today's Castle Hill. According to Colebee and Ballooderry, speaking in 1791, that clan had been wiped out by smallpox.

View across Botany Bay from Inscription Point
Looking across Botany Bay (Kamay) from Inscription Point. Pemulwuy's Bidjigal country ran from the bay along the Georges River. Philip Terry Graham, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The colonists usually lumped Pemulwuy in with the "woods tribes" or "wood natives", people who lived inland rather than on the harbour. David Collins, the Judge Advocate, wrote of an attack in 1793 by people of "the Hunter's or Woodman's tribe, people who seldom came among us, and who consequently were little known".

Bush and sandstone on the Cape Baily Track, Kamay Botany Bay National Park
Sandstone heath on the Cape Baily Track, Kamay Botany Bay National Park. Maksym Kozlenko, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Salt Pan Creek walk at Padstow
Salt Pan Creek at Padstow, the western edge of Bidjigal country as Keith Vincent Smith describes it. Adam.J.W.C., CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Man With the Marked Eye

The British first heard of Pemulwuy in October 1790. Bennelong asked a marine sergeant and his men, who were out looking for a missing convict, to join a war party to kill him. Bennelong told Governor Phillip that Pemulwuy, then about 30, was "well known for having lost an eye" and led a clan at Botany Bay. Captain Watkin Tench put it a bit differently: "a young man, with a speck, or blemish on his left eye".

The other thing people noticed was his foot. Colebee, the Cadigal headman, told Phillip that Pemulwuy was easy to pick because a club had bruised the toes of his left foot. The ADB says his left foot "had been clubbed", which suggested he was a carradhy, a clever man. The National Museum of Australia explains that this wasn't a club foot in the modern medical sense of something you're born with. Colebee said it had been done to him on purpose with a club, and it marked his standing as a carradhy, a man with special powers. Smith says there's evidence Pemulwuy could heal wounds. He also points out that kadaicha men in Central Australia dislocate their small toes so they can travel quickly and quietly to take revenge on an enemy.

Pemulwuy was no simple enemy of Bennelong's either. Smith argues that Bennelong and Colebee, looking back, seem to have worked with him. In November 1790 Pemulwuy stayed for two weeks in Bennelong's brick hut on Bennelong Point. Phillip himself noted that a Botany Bay man had slept at Bennelong's hut for more than a fortnight, "though [Bennelong] said the man was bad, and spoke of him as his enemy".

Sydney Cove, Port Jackson, 1788, watercolour by William Bradley
Sydney Cove in 1788, painted by William Bradley of the First Fleet. William Bradley, Mitchell Library, State Library of NSW, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Spearing of John McEntire – December 1790

John McEntire (also spelt McIntyre) was a convict and Governor Phillip's gamekeeper, one of three armed convicts sent out to shoot game for the hungry colony. The Eora people feared and hated him. Collins wrote that McEntire "had been suspected of having wantonly killed or wounded several of the natives in the course of his excursions after game". Smith adds that he was trespassing on Bidjigal land and shooting animals that were totems and spirit ancestors, like possum, kangaroo, emu and dingo.

On 10 December 1790, McEntire was resting with a shooting party near the Cooks River when they heard something in the bush. Tench's account, quoted on Wikipedia, says they saw men with spears creeping towards them. McEntire said, "Don't be afraid, I know them", laid down his gun and walked forward talking to them in their own language. He followed them for about a hundred yards, chatting the whole way. Then one of them jumped onto a fallen tree and threw his spear, which lodged in McEntire's left side. Tench wrote that the man had "a speck or blemish on his left eye", and that he'd clearly been in the settlement lately because he was freshly shaved. "I am a dead man," McEntire cried.

Surgeon John White found the spearhead had gone into McEntire's lung and was barbed with "small pieces of red stone". The ADB says those red stone barbs confirmed that the thrower was a Bidjigal man. Other Aboriginal people in the settlement told the surgeons it was "Pemullaway, of the tribe of Bejigal". McEntire hung on for weeks and died on 20 January 1791.

The Cooks River at Canterbury
The Cooks River at Canterbury. John McEntire was speared near the Cooks River in December 1790. David Latimer, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Phillip's Punitive Expeditions

The National Museum says Phillip had been fairly tolerant up to then, even though he'd been speared himself at Manly Cove a few months earlier. This time he was furious, because he believed McEntire had been unarmed and the attack was unprovoked. Tench's own account, as summarised on Wikipedia, says Phillip first ordered ten Bidjigal men killed and their heads brought back, and two more captured. Tench talked him down to taking six prisoners. Smith, in the Dictionary of Sydney, describes the orders as killing six men and capturing two for execution. Wikipedia calls it the biggest military operation since the colony was founded. About 50 marines marched out under Tench on 14 December 1790, carrying hatchets and bags for heads.

They never found anybody. On the second day they met Colebee at Botany Bay, who told them Pemulwuy had gone south and was a long way off. As Smith puts it: "The expedition was a failure, and a second one was a farce."

Portrait of Captain Arthur Phillip by Francis Wheatley, 1786
Captain Arthur Phillip, painted by Francis Wheatley in 1786. After McEntire was speared, Phillip sent out the colony's first punitive expedition. Francis Wheatley, State Library of NSW ML 124, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Portrait miniature of a Marine officer, possibly Watkin Tench
A Marine officer, possibly Watkin Tench, c.1795. Tench described Pemulwuy's eye and led the hunt that never found him. Attributed to Frederick Buck, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Twelve Years of Resistance – Prospect, Toongabbie, Parramatta and the Hawkesbury

From 1792, Pemulwuy led raids on the settlers at Prospect, Toongabbie, the Georges River, Parramatta, Brickfield Hill and the Hawkesbury River. According to the National Museum of Australia, the first was at Prospect in May 1792. The Bidjigal burnt huts, took maize crops and attacked travellers, and the farms they hit were right on their own land. The National Museum calls it an attempt to stop the farming settlements from taking hold. By April 1794 the fighting between Aboriginal people and the farmers was "frequent and extensive". In what the National Museum calls the "Battle of Toongabbie", a European reprisal party cut off the head of a warrior they'd killed and carried it back to Sydney as proof.

Collins called Pemulwuy "a most active enemy to the settlers, plundering them of their property, and endangering their personal safety". But Collins was also honest enough to say that most of the attacks came from the settlers' "own misconduct", including the kidnapping of Aboriginal children. The ADB notes the raids were mostly for food, especially corn, or were payback.

Even in the middle of all this, Pemulwuy could walk into Sydney. In January 1795 Collins recorded that "Pe-mul-wy, a wood native, and many strangers, came in" to an initiation ceremony at Farm Cove, where Pemulwuy acted as sponsor for one of the youths. Nobody tried to arrest him. That May his followers wounded a convict near the Brickfields, around today's Chippendale. In December 1795 a story went around that John Caesar, the African convict known as "Black Caesar", had killed Pemulwuy. Smith says it turned out to be false. Runaway convicts were joining him by then, and the government issued a proclamation calling on them to surrender.

Engraved portrait of David Collins
David Collins, the Judge Advocate, whose Account of the English Colony is the main record of Pemulwuy's war. Engraved by A. Cardon after T. T. Barber, 1804, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Battle of Parramatta – March 1797

In March 1797 Pemulwuy led a raid on the government farm at Toongabbie. There'd been a run of robberies at the Northern Farms near Parramatta. Smith places them near where the Burnside Homes later stood, and Wikipedia gives the modern suburbs as Oatlands and Carlingford. A party of armed settlers and soldiers went after the raiders. At sunrise they came on more than 100 Aboriginal people and chased them towards Parramatta, then gave up and went into town for a rest.

About an hour later, Pemulwuy and "a large body of natives" followed them right into Parramatta. The National Museum says he threatened to spear anyone who tried to stop them. Smith writes that Pemulwuy, in a rage, speared a soldier. Spears flew, the soldiers and settlers opened fire, and at least five Aboriginal warriors were killed in the first volley. Pemulwuy went down with seven pieces of buckshot in his head and body, and he was taken to the hospital badly hurt. Writing much later, in the 1870s, the journalist John Henniker Heaton claimed that 50 people were shot in the fighting.

Government House, Parramatta, 1805, by George William Evans
Government House, Parramatta, in 1805, painted by George William Evans. This was the town Pemulwuy marched into in March 1797. George William Evans, State Library of NSW, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Escape, and the Man Guns Couldn't Kill

Then Pemulwuy did the thing that made him a legend. Still carrying the shot, and with an iron on his leg, he escaped from the Parramatta hospital. Late in April 1797 the governor met several groups of Aboriginal people near Botany Bay, and Pemulwuy was among them. Collins wrote that he had "perfectly recovered from his wounds" and "escaped from the hospital with an iron about his leg". He spoke with one of the gentlemen in the party and asked whether the governor was angry, "and seemed pleased at being told that he was not".

After that, the ADB says, the Darug came to believe firearms couldn't kill him. In Collins's words: "Through this fancied security, he was said to be at the head of every party that attacked the maize grounds." In 1800 John Washington Price, the surgeon on the convict ship Minerva, wrote that "Pummil-woy" had "lodged in him, in shot, slugs and bullets about eight or ten ounces of lead, it is supposed he has killed over 30 of our people". Smith puts it simply: the legend grew that guns couldn't kill him, "but in the end he proved mortal".

Parramatta from May's Hill, c.1824, by Joseph Lycett
Parramatta from May's Hill, about 1824, by Joseph Lycett. Joseph Lycett, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Prospect Hill seen from Pemulwuy Lake
Prospect Hill (Marrong) seen from Pemulwuy Lake. Cumberland Council says Pemulwuy is believed to have used the hill in his fight. Yucalyptus, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Outlawed – King's Orders of 1801

Philip Gidley King became governor in 1800, and he took a much harder line. On 1 May 1801 he issued a government and general order that Aboriginal people around Parramatta, the Georges River and Prospect could be driven off by gunfire. The ADB and the National Museum both read it as an order that they could be shot on sight. He also outlawed two runaway convicts, William Knight and Thomas Thrush, who had joined the resistance.

In November 1801 troops went out to Mill Creek on the Georges River, and King issued a proclamation that outlawed Pemulwuy and offered rewards for him "dead or alive". The National Museum quotes the sliding scale of rewards:

To a prisoner for life or 14 years, a conditional emancipation. To a person already conditionally emancipated, a free pardon and a recommendation for a free passage to England. To a settler, the labour of a prisoner for 12 months. To any other descriptions of persons, 20 gallons of spirits and two suits of slops.

Wikipedia, quoting the Historical Records of New South Wales, dates the order to 22 November 1801. It blamed Pemulwuy for killing two men, badly wounding several others and a string of robberies.

Portrait of Governor Philip Gidley King, about 1798
Philip Gidley King, about 1798. As governor he outlawed Pemulwuy in 1801 and sent his head to Banks in 1802. Unknown artist, State Library of NSW ML 546, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Death of Pemulwuy – June 1802

The rewards worked. Pemulwuy was shot dead on or just before 2 June 1802. The ADB gives it as about 1 June, and Smith says 2 June. His head was cut off.

Who fired the shot is still argued about. King told Lord Hobart in London in October 1802 that "two settlers, not having the means of securing the person of Pemulwuye and another native, shot them". King also claimed that other Aboriginal people had asked for the head to be cut off and sent to him. His clerk, David Dickinson Mann, wrote in 1811 that King had offered a reward "to any person who should kill him and bring in his head. This was soon accomplished by artifice, the man received the reward, and the head was sent to England in spirits by the Speedy."

The name most often given is Henry Hacking, first mate of the Lady Nelson, which was lying in Sydney Cove at the time. Hacking was a First Fleet man, a quartermaster on the Sirius, and he'd led a lot of the colony's hunting trips. Wikipedia says he had shot Aboriginal people before, at Middle Harbour in 1789 and on the Hunter River in 1799. The evidence comes from Samuel Smith, a seaman on Flinders's Investigator, who wrote in his journal on 20 July 1802 that "Bumbleway … a Severe Enemy to White people" had been "shot by the Master of the Nelson Brig, that was shooting in the Woods, his head being brought Tranquility was again restor'd".

Not everyone accepts it. In 2013 the historian Doug Kohlhoff looked at the evidence again and suggested the killers were more likely settlers from around Parramatta, Toongabbie and Prospect Hill. The National Museum quotes his conclusion, and I think it's worth repeating: "Knowing who fired the fatal shot does not affect Pemulwuy's place in history. Pemulwuy was, as [Governor] King recognised, 'a brave and independent character'. He inspired others, fought hard and died for his land and his people."

There's a sad twist in the timing. About a week after Pemulwuy was killed, according to the National Museum, a dispatch arrived from Lord Hobart telling King that "any instance of injustice of wanton cruelty towards the natives will be punished with the utmost severity of the law". Wikipedia, quoting King's letter to Hobart, says King then ordered that Aboriginal people were not to be molested and could come back into the Parramatta and Prospect districts.

The Lady Nelson in the Thames, 1803 engraving
The Lady Nelson. Her first mate in 1802 was Henry Hacking, the man most often named as Pemulwuy's killer. James Grant, 1803, State Library of NSW, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Aerial view of the Port Hacking estuary
Port Hacking, south of Botany Bay, was named after Henry Hacking. Amble, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

"A Brave and Independent Character" – The Head Sent to Banks

On 5 June 1802, a few days after the killing, King sat down and wrote to Sir Joseph Banks in London. The letter is in the Banks Papers at the State Library of NSW, and volunteers have transcribed it. Here is the passage, spelling and all:

I send by this Conveyance the articles named in the enclosed list --- The printed paper will explain how I came by the Head, the bearer of it [Pemulwuy] you will find mentioned in [David] Collins's Books, altho a terrible pest to the Colony, he was a Brave and independent character, understanding that the possession of a New Hollander. Head is among the desiderata I have put it in spirits and forward it by the Speedy.

"Desiderata" means things wanted, a wish list. Banks liked to send his collectors lists of specimens. What makes it so hard to read today is the next line of the letter, where King goes straight on to a box of protea specimens from the Hunter River and a lump of salt from the mountains. To King, Pemulwuy's head was another item for the collection.

The whaler Speedy got to London in November 1802. On 24 November the owners, Samuel Enderby and Sons, wrote to Banks from Paul's Wharf that the master "has a Black Swan, a Native's Head in Spirits and a number of other things for Sir Joseph Banks". In April 1803 Banks wrote back to King. He said the head "is said to have caused some Comical consequences when opened at the Customs house" and that it now "makes a figure in the Museum of the Late Mr Hunter". That was the anatomist John Hunter, whose collection became the Hunterian Museum at the Royal College of Surgeons. He was no relation to Governor John Hunter.

Portrait of Joseph Banks by Joshua Reynolds
Joseph Banks, painted by Sir Joshua Reynolds about 1771 to 1773. King sent Pemulwuy's head to him in 1802. Joshua Reynolds, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Where Is His Head Now?

The short answer is that nobody knows. Smith says that in the 1800s the head was known to be in the Hunterian Museum at the Royal College of Surgeons, and that its location is now unknown. The ADB says plainly that it "has not been found in an English repository to date".

A 2012 news.com.au report says the museum's records note that the heads of two Aboriginal people in jars of alcohol were given to the Royal College of Surgeons in 1802. No names were recorded with them, though, and there's no record of what happened to them after 1818. The College was heavily bombed in 1941, during the Second World War, and more than half its specimens were destroyed. In 1948 about 3,000 skulls went from the College to the Natural History Museum in London.

Engraving of the Hunterian Museum at the Royal College of Surgeons, London
The Hunterian Museum at the Royal College of Surgeons in London, where the head was believed to be in the 1800s. T. H. Shepherd and E. Radclyffe, Library of Congress, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Prince William and the Redfern Elders – 2010

When Prince William visited the Block in Redfern in January 2010, a group of elders and activists, including Mick Mundine of the Aboriginal Housing Company, gave him a petition asking for Pemulwuy's skull to be returned. A couple of months later Mundine got a letter with the royal insignia on it. The prince's private secretary, Jamie Lowther-Pinkerton, wrote: "On his return from Australia, Prince William told me that he intended to do all that he could to investigate the circumstances surrounding the missing head". The letter, as reported in the Sydney Morning Herald, called it a "supremely important search".

The same letter quoted Michael Dixon, director of the Natural History Museum. He said the museum might have taken in the head in 1948 with the College's skulls, but that it could have been destroyed before then: "The Royal College of Surgeons was extensively bombed in 1941 and over half the specimens in their collection were destroyed." A History of Aboriginal Sydney summarises the letter a little differently. It says the head might have been destroyed in 1941, "or possibly may even have been returned to Australia in 1998". Mundine told the ABC: "For Aboriginal people, it will heal part of the wound."

Mural at the entrance to The Block, Redfern
The mural at the entrance to the Block in Redfern. Elders here asked Prince William in 2010 to help bring Pemulwuy home, and the Block's redevelopment is called the Pemulwuy Project. Pimlottc, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Trail Goes Cold

Christopher Pyne, then a federal MP, took up the cause and wrote to the prince in 2012. The answers he got back weren't encouraging. The prince's office said British investigations hadn't found the remains. Jeremy Hunt, the Culture Secretary, and Dr Dixon both said there was no evidence they were in the museum. Dixon added that identifying any one person's remains was extremely hard, and that using DNA raised ethical questions, including concerns from Aboriginal communities.

In 2014 the British High Commissioner, Paul Madden, visited the Natural History Museum and wrote about it. He called Pemulwuy's case "particularly prominent" and said what happened to the skull "remains a mystery". After the Blitz, some of the College's surviving collection went to the Natural History Museum and some was sent back to Australia. He wrote that the museum had "no positive information that indicates that Pemulwuy's skull is there".

The National Museum of Australia unveiled a plaque to Pemulwuy in March 2015. At the time it said it was working with the federal Ministry for the Arts on research into where his remains might be. Speaking to Australian Geographic in 2017, the museum's director, Mathew Trinca, said: "The Museum has searched and others have searched for records of his remains in the United Kingdom in vain… The problem of course, we simply do not know what happened." The National Museum's Pemulwuy page, last updated in May 2025, still says "the current whereabouts of the head is unknown".

The Natural History Museum in London
The Natural History Museum, London. It took in about 3,000 skulls from the Royal College of Surgeons in 1948, but says it has no record of Pemulwuy's. Diliff, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Tedbury – Pemulwuy's Son

Pemulwuy's son Tedbury, also known as Tjedboro, kept up the fight after his father's death. The ADB tells his story. Strangely enough, he became attached to John Macarthur, who let him come and go at Elizabeth Farm. When Governor Bligh was put under arrest in 1808, Tedbury turned up at Macarthur's cottage in Sydney with a bundle of spears and reportedly said he'd come to spear the governor. The next year he and a man called Bundle tried to rob a traveller on the Parramatta Road, and he was in an attack on a settler's farm at the Georges River. In 1810 Edward Luttrell shot Tedbury at Parramatta, and he died of his wounds. He had a wife and possibly a son, Tommy Dadbury, who was living with the Wianamattagal clan at Penrith in 1837.

Joseph Lycett painting of John Macarthur's residence near Parramatta
John Macarthur's house near Parramatta (Elizabeth Farm), by Joseph Lycett, about 1823. Pemulwuy's son Tedbury was allowed to come and go here. Joseph Lycett, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The "Rainbow Warrior" – A Novel's Title, Not a Traditional Name

A lot of people call Pemulwuy the "Rainbow Warrior". It's worth being clear about where it comes from. In 1987 the Aboriginal scholar, engineer and author Eric Willmot published a novel called Pemulwuy: The Rainbow Warrior (Weldon, McMahons Point). The ADB and the Dictionary of Sydney both list it. Smith calls it "a brilliant work of fiction" and says that in it Willmot "constructed a black hero for Australia's Aboriginal community". In Willmot's story, Pemulwuy can turn himself into a bird to escape.

So "Rainbow Warrior" is the title of a novel, not a name Pemulwuy was given in his own lifetime or by his own people. None of the early records I've read use it. The Sydney Morning Herald, in its 2010 story on Prince William, said he was "known as the 'rainbow warrior', for the colours he wore". It gives no source for that, and I couldn't find one in the colonial records or the reference works.

There are Darug names linked with him, though. Cumberland Council, which looks after the suburb named for him, says Butu Wargun means "Black Crow: Clan Leader", Pemulwuy's totem. Butu Wargun Drive in the suburb carries that name.

How He Is Remembered Today

For a long time Pemulwuy was left out of the history books. Mathew Trinca of the National Museum said in 2017 that there had been "a growing awareness of Pemulwuy as a historical figure" since the 1980s. Today his name turns up all over Sydney.

  • The suburb of Pemulwuy. It was created in 2004 on historic Prospect Hill, near Greystanes. The name was put forward by the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Consultative Committee of the old Holroyd City Council. Many of its streets and parks have Darug names, and Watkin Tench Parade is a reminder of the first Europeans to climb the hill.
  • The ferry Pemulwuy. It's one of the first six Emerald-class harbour ferries, which came into service in 2017. Another of them is named after Bungaree.
  • The Pemulwuy Project. The Aboriginal Housing Company's redevelopment of the Block in Redfern has housing for 62 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander families, which was finished in December 2020.
  • Pemulwuy Park in Redfern, according to Wikipedia.
  • The National Museum plaque. It was unveiled in Canberra on 20 March 2015 as part of the museum's Defining Moments project. Bidjigal elder Uncle Vic Simms said: "What the Museum is doing is so important for getting the history right about Pemulwuy as a Bidjigal man."
  • Songs and screen. Redgum's "Water and Stone" and Marlene Cummins's song "Pemulwuy" are both about him. According to Wikipedia, Cummins's song was presented to Prince William along with the petition. A feature film, First Warrior, was announced in 2024.
The Emerald-class ferry MV Pemulwuy at Milsons Point wharf
The harbour ferry Pemulwuy at Milsons Point wharf, one of the six Emerald-class ferries that came into service in 2017. Philip Terry Graham, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Aerial photo of the suburb of Pemulwuy
The suburb of Pemulwuy from the air, on the old quarry country around Prospect Hill. Mark Merton, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Driftway Reserve in the suburb of Pemulwuy
Driftway Reserve in Pemulwuy. Many of the suburb's streets and parks carry Darug names. Chris.sherlock2, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Old Government House, Parramatta, in jacaranda season
Old Government House, Parramatta, today. Michael Cleary, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Timeline

  • c.1750 – Pemulwuy born near Botany Bay, on the northern side of the Georges River.
  • January 1788 – The First Fleet arrives.
  • 1789 – Smallpox hits the Aboriginal people of Sydney.
  • October 1790 – Bennelong asks marines to join a war party against Pemulwuy, the first time the British hear his name.
  • November 1790 – Pemulwuy stays about two weeks in Bennelong's hut at Bennelong Point.
  • 10 December 1790 – Pemulwuy spears the gamekeeper John McEntire near the Cooks River.
  • 14 December 1790 – Tench's punitive expedition sets out, and finds no one.
  • 20 January 1791 – McEntire dies.
  • May 1792 – First raid, at Prospect.
  • 1792–1797 – Raids at Prospect, Toongabbie, Georges River, Parramatta, Brickfield Hill and the Hawkesbury.
  • January 1795 – Pemulwuy attends the initiation ceremony at Farm Cove.
  • December 1795 – A false report that John Caesar has killed him.
  • March 1797 – Toongabbie raid and the Battle of Parramatta. Pemulwuy is shot seven times and captured.
  • April 1797 – Escaped in irons, he's seen near Botany Bay.
  • 1800 – Surgeon Price writes that he carries "eight or ten ounces of lead".
  • 1 May 1801 – King's order that Aboriginal people near Parramatta, Georges River and Prospect be driven off by gunfire.
  • November 1801 – Proclamation outlawing Pemulwuy and offering rewards (dated 22 November in the Historical Records).
  • c.1–2 June 1802 – Pemulwuy is shot dead and beheaded.
  • 5 June 1802 – King writes to Banks and sends the head in spirits on the Speedy.
  • 24 November 1802 – The Enderbys tell Banks the head has arrived in London.
  • April 1803 – Banks says the head is in "the Museum of the Late Mr Hunter".
  • 1808 – Tedbury threatens to spear Governor Bligh.
  • 1810 – Tedbury is shot by Edward Luttrell at Parramatta and dies.
  • 1941 – The Royal College of Surgeons is bombed and over half its specimens are destroyed.
  • 1948 – About 3,000 skulls go from the College to the Natural History Museum.
  • 1987 – Eric Willmot publishes Pemulwuy: The Rainbow Warrior.
  • 2004 – The suburb of Pemulwuy is created.
  • January 2010 – Redfern elders give Prince William a petition, and his office promises to search.
  • 2012 – British officials and the Natural History Museum say there's no evidence the head is there.
  • 2013 – Doug Kohlhoff questions whether Hacking fired the fatal shot.
  • 20 March 2015 – The National Museum of Australia unveils its Pemulwuy plaque.
  • 2017 – The ferry Pemulwuy enters service.
  • 2025 – The National Museum still lists the head's whereabouts as unknown.

Where the Sources Disagree

  • The date of the spearing, and when McEntire died. Smith (Dictionary of Sydney) and the National Museum give 10 December 1790, and Smith says McEntire died on 20 January 1791. Cumberland Council gives 9 December and says McEntire "died 3 days later". Tench's account, on Wikipedia, has the shooting party setting out on 9 December and the men creeping up "about one o'clock", after the sergeant had been asleep. I've gone with 10 December and 20 January.
  • Phillip's orders. Wikipedia, following Tench and the historian John Moore, says Phillip first wanted ten men killed and beheaded and two captured, and Tench talked him down to six prisoners. Smith describes the orders as six killed and two captured for execution.
  • Black Caesar in 1795. Smith says the report that John Caesar had killed Pemulwuy was false. Wikipedia says Caesar cracked Pemulwuy's skull in a fight at Botany Bay and that he survived.
  • How many died at Parramatta in 1797. Smith and the National Museum say at least five warriors were killed. Henniker Heaton, writing in the 1870s, claimed 50.
  • The date of his death. The ADB says "about 1 June 1802". Smith says 2 June. The National Museum says "on or just before 2 June".
  • Who killed him. King wrote of "two settlers". Mann wrote of one man who got the reward. The ADB names Henry Hacking outright, and Smith says "suspicion falls on" Hacking, based on Samuel Smith's journal. Doug Kohlhoff (2013), as summarised by the National Museum, thinks settlers from Parramatta, Toongabbie or Prospect Hill were more likely.
  • What happened to the head. Smith says it was in the Hunterian Museum through the 1800s. The 2012 news report says the College has no record of the two 1802 heads after 1818. Dixon (2010) said it might have reached the Natural History Museum in 1948 or been destroyed in 1941. A History of Aboriginal Sydney's summary of the same letter adds that it might have been returned to Australia in 1998. Madden (2014) said the museum had no positive evidence it was there.
  • His name. The ADB says pemul means earth. Smith says Pemall (bimul) means earth or clay. Wikipedia gives Bemul Wagan, "the earth and the crow". Cumberland Council gives Butu Wargun, "Black Crow: Clan Leader", as his totem.
  • The "Rainbow Warrior". The ADB and the Dictionary of Sydney tie the name to Eric Willmot's 1987 novel. The Sydney Morning Herald (2010) said he was called that "for the colours he wore", but gave no source.
  • The only picture. The National Museum says the 1803 engraving of "Pimbloy" in a canoe, after a lost drawing by James Grant, is "believed to be the only known depiction" of Pemulwuy. It also says the face is hard to make out and the feet are hidden. Australian Geographic says it's "thought to feature" him. Nobody can be certain it's him.

My Earlier Posts

Sources

  • J. L. Kohen, "Pemulwuy (c.1750–1802)", Australian Dictionary of Biography, supplementary volume, 2005. adb.anu.edu.au/biography/pemulwuy-13147
  • Keith Vincent Smith, "Pemulwuy", Dictionary of Sydney, 2010. dictionaryofsydney.org/entry/pemulwuy
  • Dictionary of Sydney, "Pemulwuy" (suburb). dictionaryofsydney.org/place/pemulwuy
  • National Museum of Australia, "Pemulwuy", Defining Moments, updated 13 May 2025. nma.gov.au/defining-moments/resources/pemulwuy
  • National Museum of Australia, "National Museum honours Aboriginal warrior Pemulwuy", media release, 20 March 2015. nma.gov.au
  • State Library of NSW, "Letter received by Banks from Philip Gidley King, 5 June 1802 (Series 39.068)", page 4, Banks Papers transcription. transcripts.sl.nsw.gov.au
  • Josephine Tovey, "Off with his head: prince pledges to return warrior's skull", Sydney Morning Herald, 1 April 2010. smh.com.au
  • "Prince William vows to search for warrior's skull", ABC News, 1 April 2010. abc.net.au
  • A History of Aboriginal Sydney, "Prince William investigates whereabouts of Pemulway's remains" (2010). historyofaboriginalsydney.edu.au
  • Brad Crouch, "Prince William searches for missing skull of Aboriginal resistance leader Pemulwuy", news.com.au, 28 November 2012. news.com.au
  • Paul Madden, "Behind the scenes at the museum", UK Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office blogs, 20 March 2014. blogs.fcdo.gov.uk
  • "On this day: Pemulwuy is killed", Australian Geographic, 1 June 2017. australiangeographic.com.au
  • Cumberland City Council, "Aboriginal heritage in Cumberland". cumberland.nsw.gov.au
  • Aboriginal Housing Company, "About Us – The Pemulwuy Project". pemulwuyproject.org.au
  • Wikipedia, "Pemulwuy" (for Tench's account of the McEntire spearing, the November 1801 order, King's letter to Hobart, and the songs and films). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pemulwuy
  • Wikipedia, "Emerald-class ferry". en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emerald-class_ferry
  • Wikipedia, "Henry Hacking". en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Hacking
  • Eric Willmot, Pemulwuy: The Rainbow Warrior, Weldon, McMahons Point, 1987 (as cited by the Dictionary of Sydney and the ADB).
  • Primary sources quoted through the works above: David Collins, An Account of the English Colony in New South Wales (1798–1802); Watkin Tench, A Complete Account of the Settlement at Port Jackson (1793); J. W. Price, Journal on the Minerva (SLNSW); Samuel Smith, Journal on the Investigator (SLNSW); Samuel Enderby to Banks, 24 November 1802 (SLNSW Banks Papers); King to Hobart, 30 October 1802 (Historical Records of NSW).
  • Pictures: Wikimedia Commons, with credits under each image.

Friday, October 16, 2026

Sir Henry Browne Hayes – The Convict Knight Who Built Vaucluse – And Why Vaucluse Is Called Vaucluse

Sir Henry Browne Hayes was a knight, a former sheriff of Cork and a convicted kidnapper, and he's the man who built the very first house at Vaucluse. In 1797 he carried off a Quaker heiress named Mary Pike and forced her through a sham wedding. He was sentenced to death, had it commuted to transportation for life, and turned up in Sydney in July 1802 with plenty of money in his pocket. Over the next ten years he fell out with a ship's surgeon and with Governor King, held what's regarded as the first Masonic meeting in Australia, and got himself sent to Van Diemen's Land and then the Newcastle coal mines. In between he set himself up on a pretty patch of harbourside land near South Head, which he called Vaucluse. Legend says he ringed it with Irish turf to keep the snakes out. He was pardoned, sailed home in 1812, was shipwrecked in the Falklands on the way, and died in Cork in 1832. The house he started later became William Charles Wentworth's Vaucluse House, and the name he gave it, borrowed from a valley in the south of France, now belongs to the whole suburb.

Portrait miniature of Sir Henry Browne Hayes
Sir Henry Browne Hayes in a portrait miniature dated to about 1824, back home in Cork after his Sydney years. Attributed to Adam Buck, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A Cork Man of Means

Hayes was born in 1762 (the old Dictionary of Australian Biography hedges with "1761 or early in 1762"). He was the son of Attiwell Hayes of Cork. The Australian Dictionary of Biography calls Attiwell "a reputable and opulent citizen", and Wikipedia says he was a wealthy brewer and miller who died in 1799.

Young Henry did well for himself in Cork. He became a captain in the South Cork militia and was made a freeman of the city in November 1782. In 1790 he was one of the city's sheriffs, and he was knighted that same year. The ADB thinks the knighthood was probably a reward for looking after the visiting Lord Lieutenant while he was sheriff. The same entry adds, a bit drily, that he had "an inclination to irregular behaviour".

In 1783 he married Elizabeth Smyth. Wikipedia says they had one son and three daughters, and the ADB just says "several children". Elizabeth died in 1794, which left Hayes a widower in his early thirties.

Vernon Mount

The family seat was Vernon Mount, a Georgian villa on the hill above Douglas outside Cork. It was built in the 1780s or early 1790s for Attiwell Hayes, with designs attributed to the architect Abraham Hargrave, and it was named after George Washington's Mount Vernon. Attiwell didn't move in after his wife died. He leased it to Henry instead, who is said to have spent a fortune on the interiors, murals included. The Irish Georgian Society calls the house "a building of national importance". Sadly it was gutted by fire in July 2016 and is now a shell.

Vernon Mount House, Cork, after the 2016 fire
Vernon Mount, the Hayes family house outside Cork where Mary Pike was taken in 1797, photographed in August 2016 after the fire that gutted it. Guliolopez, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Abduction of Mary Pike, 1797

Mary Pike was born in Cork in 1776. She was the only surviving daughter of Samuel Pike, whose family ran a bank in the city. When her father died in 1796 she inherited a fortune. The ADB puts it at £20,000, and Wikipedia's Hayes article gives a range of anywhere from £20,000 to £80,000. She was living at Woodhill with the family of Cooper Penrose, her aunt's brother.

On the night of 22 July 1797, Hayes set his trap. According to the Mary Pike entry, which follows the Dictionary of Irish Biography, she was lured out with a forged letter, supposedly from her mother's doctor, saying her mother was gravely ill. Her carriage was stopped on the road from Woodhill and she was taken to Vernon Mount. There Hayes and his sister tried to force her into a marriage. The old Dictionary of Australian Biography says a man dressed up as a priest went through the form of a wedding ceremony while Mary protested. She never accepted it as a marriage. Her uncle Richard tracked her down to Vernon Mount and got her out.

Hayes was outlawed and the government put up a £1,000 reward for him. He didn't go far, though. The ADB says he hid for a while and then lived quite openly for two years. Then comes the famous bit of cheek. According to the Dictionary of Australian Biography, he walked into the shop of an old family follower and suggested the man might as well collect the reward himself. Mary Pike's Wikipedia entry gives a slightly different version: Hayes wrote to Mary offering to give himself up for trial if the reward was withdrawn.

The Trial

The trial opened at the Cork spring assizes in April 1801. Mary Pike's entry gives the date as 13 April. It was, as one writer put it, "one of the sensations of the day", and Hayes turned up with a crowd of influential friends. Prosecuting was John Philpot Curran, the most famous courtroom voice in Ireland. Hayes was found guilty and the jury recommended mercy. He was sentenced to death, and the sentence was commuted to transportation for life to New South Wales.

Mary Pike never really got over it. The Dictionary of Irish Biography, as quoted on Wikipedia, says she appears to have "developed a pathological fear of the male sex" and lived in a Quaker retreat. Other reports say she was admitted to an asylum. She died in 1832, the same year as Hayes, leaving a fortune of £55,000.

Portrait of John Philpot Curran
John Philpot Curran, the famous Irish barrister who led the prosecution against Hayes at the Cork assizes in 1801. Unknown artist, National Portrait Gallery London, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Voyage of the Atlas, 1801–1802

Hayes was shipped out on the convict transport Atlas under Captain Richard Brooks. The ship sailed from Ireland on 29 November 1801 and called at Rio de Janeiro and the Cape on the way. The ADB says flatly that it was "the worst in the history of transportation". Of the 151 men and 63 women on board, 28 men and 2 women died on the voyage, and more died just after landing. Governor King blamed Brooks, saying the deaths came from his negligence and from overcrowding, because the captain had packed the ship with his own private cargo.

Hayes didn't suffer like the men below decks. He paid the captain a hefty sum for a privileged passage and ate at his table. That didn't stop him making enemies, though. He fell out badly with the ship's surgeon, Thomas Jamison, and when the Atlas reached Sydney in July 1802 Hayes was given six months' imprisonment "for his threatening and improper conduct".

Engraving of Sydney about 1802 after Lesueur
Sydney about 1802, the year Hayes stepped ashore. Engraving after Charles-Alexandre Lesueur of the French Baudin expedition, published by François Péron in 1807. After Charles-Alexandre Lesueur, State Library of NSW, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A Thorn in Governor King's Side

The ADB sums up Hayes's time in New South Wales as "noteworthy largely for his war against authority". He made friends with the colony's awkward customers. Among them were Maurice Margarot and John Grant. All three kept up their defiance of Governor Philip Gidley King. Grant ended up exiled to Norfolk Island, and Margarot and Hayes were packed off to Van Diemen's Land. King called Hayes "a restless, troublesome character", and he was keen to keep him well out of town.

Portrait of Governor Philip Gidley King
Governor Philip Gidley King, who called Hayes "a restless, troublesome character". Oil portrait, about 1798. Unknown artist, State Library of NSW, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Did Hayes have a hand in the Castle Hill rising of March 1804? The ADB says there's "no positive evidence" he took an active part, but he was certainly a suspect, and "it would have been out of character if he had not encouraged it behind the scenes". That's a hunch, not a finding, so take it as one.

Portrait of Maurice Margarot
Maurice Margarot, one of Hayes's friends among the colony's troublemakers. Unknown artist, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The First Masonic Meeting, 14 May 1803

Hayes was a keen Freemason, and in 1803 he set about founding a lodge in Sydney. The old Dictionary of Australian Biography says King had already refused permission for the meeting, so Hayes held it anyway. It's doubtful he really had a warrant to set up a lodge, though he claimed he did. The meeting went ahead on 14 May 1803. The Sydney Gazette of 22 May 1803 is among the ADB's sources for it, and the ADB says the date "is regarded as the foundation day of Freemasonry in Australia". It also got Hayes into hot water with the Governor all over again.

Building Vaucluse

In 1803 Hayes bought land on the south side of the harbour, out past Rose Bay towards South Head. In those days it was isolated bush country. The New South Wales State Heritage Register listing, as summarised on Wikipedia, says he bought the grant made to Thomas Laycock in 1793 and the grant next to it. Laycock's grant was 80 acres (32 hectares). Wikipedia's Vaucluse suburb page names the second one as Robert Cardell's grant of 1795, which was 25 acres (10 hectares). The same listing puts his holding at about 105 acres (42 hectares). So yes, the Laycock grant was the heart of it, together with Cardell's next door.

One observer described the place as "a mere waste of land until Sir Henry Hayes built a dwelling house upon it and cultivated a garden". He put up a small stone cottage, two huts and some outbuildings, cleared about 50 acres (20 hectares) for farming and planted several thousand fruit trees. None of the trees survive. The newspapers called it a small but very charming farm. When he wasn't away on his enforced "travels", the ADB says, he lived there "in remarkable style and freedom for a convict".

Aerial view of Rose Bay and Vaucluse
Rose Bay and Vaucluse from the air, undated. In 1803 this was bush country well away from town, which is just where Governor King wanted Hayes. NSW State Archives and Records, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Irish Turf and the Snakes

This is the story everyone remembers. Vaucluse was snake country, so the tale goes, and Hayes, being an Irishman, knew that St Patrick had driven the snakes out of Ireland. So he had Irish turf (or soil, depending on who's telling it) shipped out and laid in a ring or trench around his house to keep the reptiles off.

How true is it? It's best treated as a legend with a grain of truth in it. The old Dictionary of Australian Biography of 1949 is careful to say only that "there is some warrant for the story". The ADB of 1966 tells it straight: he "surrounded it with a moat of turf which he had imported from Ireland", and it adds with a wink that "curiously, the turf appeared to have had the desired effect". Neither says how much turf, how it got here or who dug it in. The fancier versions, with Irish convict women singing and calling on St Patrick as they worked, turn up in later popular retellings. I couldn't find them in any of the reference works.

Vaucluse House front
Vaucluse House today. Hayes's little stone cottage is still in there, swallowed up inside the Wentworths' Gothic additions. Cismok, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Bligh, the Rum Rebellion and the Coal Mines

Hayes came back from Van Diemen's Land and spent most of his time at Vaucluse. Then came 26 January 1808, when the New South Wales Corps arrested Governor William Bligh. Hayes, never one to keep his head down, said he was on Bligh's side. For that, Major George Johnston sent him to the coal mines at Newcastle.

He was let out after eight months but was back there by May 1809. This time the commandant, Lieutenant William Lawson, charged him with trying to bring the rebel government into ridicule. Given what most of Sydney thought of the rebel government, that can't have been hard.

Portrait of William Bligh
Governor William Bligh. Hayes took his side after the Rum Rebellion and paid for it with a trip to the Newcastle coal mines. John Condé after John Russell, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Pardon, Shipwreck and Home to Cork

The sources tell the pardon two ways. The ADB says Bligh made out a pardon in 1809 and that Governor Lachlan Macquarie honoured it. The older Dictionary of Australian Biography says Bligh would have pardoned him if he could have got hold of the Great Seal, and that Hayes was pardoned under Macquarie in 1812. Either way, Hayes sailed for home in December 1812.

Portrait of Lachlan Macquarie
Governor Lachlan Macquarie, under whom Hayes's pardon finally took effect. Painted by Arthur Levett Jackson in 1874. Arthur Levett Jackson, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The trip home had one last adventure in it. He sailed on the Isabella, and also aboard was Joseph Holt, the United Irishman of the 1798 rebellion. The ship was wrecked in the Falkland Islands. They survived, and Holt's memoirs give an account of the wreck.

Portrait of Joseph Holt
Joseph Holt of the 1798 United Irish rebellion, who sailed home with Hayes on the Isabella and was wrecked with him in the Falklands. Unknown artist, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Hayes then lived quietly in Ireland for nearly twenty years. He died at the end of April or the start of May 1832, aged about 70, and was buried in the family crypt of Christ Church on South Main Street in Cork. His portrait miniature at the top of this page dates from his later years there. In 2017 a play called Sir Henry was staged about his life.

Why Is Vaucluse Called Vaucluse?

Short answer: Hayes named it, and he borrowed the name from France.

There's a famous spring in Provence called the Fontaine de Vaucluse. It sits at the foot of a limestone cliff about 230 metres high, it's the source of the River Sorgue, and it's the biggest spring in France. The village beside it, Fontaine-de-Vaucluse, isn't far from L'Isle-sur-la-Sorgue and Avignon. The village was once just called Vaucluse, and it later gave its name to the whole French department of Vaucluse. The word comes from the Latin vallis clausa, meaning "closed valley". That's a fair description of a valley shut in by cliffs.

The spring of Fontaine de Vaucluse
The spring itself, the Fontaine de Vaucluse, where the River Sorgue comes out from under a limestone cliff. JYB Devot, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What made the place famous across Europe was the Italian poet Petrarch. In the 1300s he made Vaucluse his favourite home and wrote about it in his poems. He said the spring, "famous for itself long ago, became even more famous by my long stay and my songs". He left in 1353. A Petrarch museum now stands on the site of his house, and in the 1700s a column went up in his honour. By Hayes's time Vaucluse was a byword for a romantic hideaway in a wild, rocky valley.

Portrait of Petrarch
The poet Petrarch, who made Vaucluse famous in the 1300s. Italian portrait, first half of the 16th century. Italian 16th century, National Gallery of Art, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

So when Hayes found his own secluded spot of rocks, gullies and bush tucked in behind South Head, he called it Vaucluse. Most sources go further and say he did it because he admired Petrarch. Wikipedia's Vaucluse suburb page calls him "an avid admirer" of the poet who named the house after Petrarch's poem about the spring. The Vaucluse House article is more careful: he named it "probably" after Petrarch's Fontaine-de-Vaucluse. Another passage there just says he named it after the village in the south of France. So the French Vaucluse is certain. The Petrarch-loving knight is the usual explanation, but I couldn't find Hayes himself saying so in any source I could read.

The name stuck to the house, then to the estate, and eventually to the whole suburb. Wikipedia's suburb page says plainly that the area "derived its name" from the original Vaucluse House.

View of Fontaine-de-Vaucluse village
Fontaine-de-Vaucluse in Provence, seen from the castle. This is the Vaucluse our Vaucluse is named after. Mathieu Brossais, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Petrarch museum at Fontaine de Vaucluse
The Petrarch museum and library at Fontaine-de-Vaucluse, on the spot where his house stood. Alessandro Colombo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What Happened to the Estate After Hayes

Once Hayes left in 1812, the place drifted for a while. The heritage listing says Vaucluse was leased until 1814 and then sat mostly empty, apart from a year's rental to Captain John Piper in 1814. Ownership seems to have been muddled for a few years and the estate "passed through several hands". Piper then acquired it in 1822.

In 1827 William Charles Wentworth bought it from Piper. The heritage listing gives the date as 7 August 1827 in one place, while Wikipedia's history section says 27 August 1827. Wentworth built it up with further grants and purchases to 515 acres (208 hectares), stretching from the Macquarie Lighthouse on South Head to the eastern heights of Rose Bay. Over the next decades he and his wife Sarah turned the farm cottage into the Gothic mansion we know now.

Hayes's little house didn't vanish, though. According to the heritage listing, parts of his Vaucluse Cottage are still there inside Wentworth's house: the vestibule, the little tea room, the east end of the dining room and the stone walls inside the drawing room. There's also a good chance the Wentworths' kitchen garden was first laid out by Hayes. The State Government bought Vaucluse House in 1910 and opened it to the public, and today Museums of History NSW looks after it.

Vaucluse House photographed in 1932
Vaucluse House photographed by Sam Hood for Cinesound in November 1932. Sam Hood, State Library of NSW, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Vaucluse House in the 1930s
Vaucluse House in the 1930s, by then a public museum. Royal Australian Historical Society, Osborne Collection, no known restrictions, via Wikimedia Commons
Vaucluse House, Sydney
Vaucluse House in 2009. Bgabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Timeline

  • 1762 – Henry Browne Hayes born in Cork, son of Attiwell Hayes.
  • November 1782 – Admitted a freeman of the city of Cork.
  • 1783 – Marries Elizabeth Smyth.
  • 1790 – One of the sheriffs of Cork, and knighted.
  • 1793 – Thomas Laycock granted 80 acres on the south side of the harbour, the future Vaucluse.
  • 1794 – Death of his wife Elizabeth.
  • 1795 – Robert Cardell granted 25 acres next door.
  • 22 July 1797 – Abducts Mary Pike and takes her to Vernon Mount. She is rescued and he is outlawed.
  • April 1801 – Tried at the Cork assizes, prosecuted by John Philpot Curran, and found guilty. His death sentence is commuted to transportation for life.
  • 29 November 1801 – The Atlas sails from Ireland.
  • 6 or 7 July 1802 – Arrives in Sydney and is given six months' imprisonment over his clash with surgeon Thomas Jamison.
  • 1803 – Buys the Laycock grant and the land next to it, builds his cottage and names it Vaucluse.
  • 14 May 1803 – Holds the Masonic meeting regarded as the foundation of Freemasonry in Australia.
  • March 1804 – Castle Hill rising. Hayes is suspected, but no evidence ties him to it.
  • King's time – Sent to Van Diemen's Land for defying Governor King.
  • 1808 – Sides with the deposed Governor Bligh and is sent to the Newcastle coal mines. Released after eight months.
  • May 1809 – Back at Newcastle and charged by Lieutenant William Lawson.
  • 1809 or 1812 – Pardoned (sources differ, see below).
  • December 1812 – Sails for home on the Isabella with Joseph Holt and is shipwrecked in the Falklands.
  • 1814 – Captain John Piper rents Vaucluse for a year.
  • 1822 – Piper acquires the estate.
  • August 1827 – William Charles Wentworth buys Vaucluse from Piper.
  • April or May 1832 – Hayes dies in Cork and is buried in Christ Church. Mary Pike dies the same year.
  • 1910 – The NSW Government buys Vaucluse House.
  • 2016 – Vernon Mount in Cork is gutted by fire.

Where the Sources Disagree

  • Arrival date. The ADB and the Dictionary of Australian Biography say Hayes arrived on 6 July 1802. Wikipedia's article on the Atlas says the ship arrived at Port Jackson on 7 July 1802.
  • Mary Pike's fortune. The ADB says £20,000, the Dictionary of Australian Biography says "over £20,000", and Wikipedia's Hayes article says anywhere from £20,000 to £80,000.
  • His children. Wikipedia says one son and three daughters. The ADB says "several children".
  • How he was caught. The Dictionary of Australian Biography says he walked into a family follower's shop and invited the man to claim the reward. Mary Pike's Wikipedia entry says he wrote to her offering to surrender if the reward was withdrawn.
  • The pardon. The ADB says Bligh made out a pardon in 1809 and Macquarie honoured it. The Dictionary of Australian Biography says Bligh couldn't issue it without the Great Seal, and that Hayes was pardoned under Macquarie in 1812.
  • Where he was exiled. The ADB says Van Diemen's Land under King, then Newcastle under the rebel government. Norfolk Island is sometimes mentioned in connection with him, but in the ADB it was his friend John Grant who was sent there, not Hayes.
  • Who had Vaucluse after him, and when Wentworth bought it. The ADB says it "passed to John Piper after Hayes's departure" and went to Wentworth "in 1829". The heritage listing says Piper rented it in 1814 and acquired it in 1822, and dates Wentworth's purchase to August 1827, either the 7th or the 27th depending on which part of the article you read.
  • Why "Vaucluse". Every source agrees the name comes from Vaucluse in France. The Petrarch connection is given as fact on Wikipedia's Vaucluse suburb page, but the Vaucluse House article only says "probably".
  • The snake-proof turf. The 1949 Dictionary of Australian Biography says there is only "some warrant" for the story, while the 1966 ADB tells it as fact. It's best read as a legend with something behind it.

My Earlier Posts

Sources

  • N. S. Lynravn, "Hayes, Sir Henry Browne (1762–1832)", Australian Dictionary of Biography, vol. 1, 1966 – adb.anu.edu.au
  • Percival Serle, "Hayes, Sir Henry Browne", Dictionary of Australian Biography, 1949 – Project Gutenberg Australia
  • "Henry Browne Hayes", Wikipedia – en.wikipedia.org
  • "Mary Pike", Wikipedia (drawing on T. O'Riordan, Dictionary of Irish Biography) – en.wikipedia.org
  • "Vernon Mount", Wikipedia – en.wikipedia.org
  • "Atlas (1801 South Shields ship)", Wikipedia – en.wikipedia.org
  • "Vaucluse House", Wikipedia (based on the NSW State Heritage Register listing 00955) – en.wikipedia.org
  • "Vaucluse, New South Wales", Wikipedia – en.wikipedia.org
  • "Fontaine-de-Vaucluse", Wikipedia – en.wikipedia.org
  • Further reading cited by the ADB: C. H. Bertie, "The Story of Vaucluse House and Sir Henry Browne Hayes", JRAHS, vol. 3, 1917; P. H. Morton, "The Vaucluse Estate from 1793 to 1829", JRAHS, vol. 15, 1930; Sydney Gazette, 22 May 1803; Rolf Grunseit, Australia's Rebel Convict (2011).

Thursday, October 15, 2026

The Castle Hill Rebellion – Battle of Vinegar Hill – 5 March 1804

On the night of Sunday 4 March 1804, a hut was set on fire at the Government Farm at Castle Hill. It was the signal for a few hundred convicts, most of them Irishmen sent out here after the 1798 rebellion back home, to rise up, grab whatever weapons they could find and march on Parramatta and Sydney. By the next morning they'd been chased all the way out towards the Hawkesbury, and at a spot near today's Rouse Hill a small force of soldiers and armed settlers under Major George Johnston broke them in a few minutes. Their leaders were seized during a parley — remembered in some accounts as talks under a flag of truce, though the official report and later commemorative writing disagree about what that meeting meant. Loyalists called it "Australia's Vinegar Hill", after the battle in Ireland where the 1798 rising was crushed. It was the first major convict uprising in Australia to be put down under martial law, and it's one of the very few times Europeans have fought a pitched battle against each other on Australian soil.

I grew up hearing about the Rum Rebellion, but this one, four years earlier, doesn't get anywhere near the same attention. So here's the whole story: where it came from, how the night went, what happened at the hill, the hangings and floggings afterwards, and where you can go today to see where it all happened.

Convict uprising at Castle Hill
Unknown artist, watercolour of the Castle Hill convict uprising, traditionally dated about 1804. National Library of Australia / Wikimedia Commons. Public domain. Period painting, not a photograph; some details may be interpretive.

Where It Started – Ireland, 1798

As Anne-Maree Whitaker tells it in the Dictionary of Sydney, the Castle Hill rising grew straight out of the 1798 Rebellion in Ireland. That rebellion has been called one of the most concentrated outbreaks of violence in Irish history, and the death toll on all sides has been put at around 30,000. The rebellion's main field campaign in Wexford was crushed at the Battle of Vinegar Hill, outside Enniscorthy, in June 1798. That was not the end of the rising: fighting, repression and smaller outbreaks continued afterwards, military and legal mopping-up ran into the early 1800s, and later attempts such as Robert Emmet's rising in Dublin in 1803 kept the cause alive in people's minds. In the aftermath of 1798 and the years that followed, 400 or more of those involved were transported to New South Wales.

Defeat at Vinegar Hill, County Wexford, 1798 — later illustration of the Irish battle that gave Sydney's fight its nickname
Defeat at Vinegar Hill, County Wexford, 1798 — later illustration of the Irish battle that gave Sydney's fight its nickname. George Cruikshank plate for W. H. Maxwell (1845). Public domain_p184_Defeat_at_Vinegar_Hill_(cropped).jpg), via Wikimedia Commons. This is an 1845 illustration, not an 1804 Sydney picture.
Green harp flag associated with Irish nationalism (modern rendering of a historical emblem)
Green harp flag associated with Irish nationalism (modern rendering of a historical emblem). CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Cruikshank etching of the rebels at Vinegar Hill 1798
The original Vinegar Hill: George Cruikshank's picture of the rebels at Vinegar Hill, outside Enniscorthy in County Wexford, 1798. George Cruikshank, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Remember that name, Vinegar Hill, because it comes back to Sydney.

When the Minerva and Friendship arrived from Ireland in 1800, Sydney Town was a 12-year-old settlement of about 2,500 people, 43 per cent of them convicts. Parramatta and Toongabbie together had a bit under 1,500 people, more than two thirds of them convicts. The Hawkesbury was mostly free settlers, and the soldiers were mostly in Sydney, with only small garrisons anywhere else (Dictionary of Sydney).

The Plots of 1800

The Irish could see how thinly guarded the place was, and they didn't stop being rebels just because they'd been shipped to the other side of the world. They wanted to escape, get home and help with the next rising they expected in Ireland. The Dictionary of Sydney lists the trouble through 1800. In February a seditious gathering was broken up in Sydney, and in May another plot was reported. In September and October more conspiracies were investigated, and the men suspected were flogged or sent to Norfolk Island. In December a plot on Norfolk Island was stopped by hanging two of its leaders.

Wikipedia, drawing on Whitaker's book Unfinished Revolution, gives the outline of the September 1800 plan. The rebels would meet at Parramatta and take it, then take the Sydney barracks before daylight, and then live off the settlers' farms until they heard from France, where they meant to send a ship.

More ships kept coming from Ireland: the Anne in 1801, then the Atlas I, Atlas II and Hercules in 1802. Every one brought more veterans of 1798 and more news of trouble in the Irish countryside.

The Government Farm at Castle Hill

Castle Hill was the colony's Third Government Farm. According to its State Heritage Register history (reproduced on Wikipedia), work started there in 1801, on soil described as the "best and most productive kind". The surveyors' field book of 1801–02 mentions bridges, a watering place and a long hut 100 feet by 20. When the French explorer François Péron came through in October 1802, he called Castle Hill an "infant town" of "a dozen houses" with cultivated land and "several handsome farms". On 30 June 1803 Governor King reported that he was building a two-storey stone barracks there, 100 feet by 24, and it was still going up that August.

Later painting of the Third Government Farm at Castle Hill
Later painting of the Third Government Farm at Castle Hill. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Not a contemporaneous 1804 view.
Castle Hill Heritage Park today, on the government farm site
Castle Hill Heritage Park today, on the government farm site. Photograph, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The heritage listing makes a pointed observation. King's policy of putting Irish political prisoners together in one remote place could have looked naive to London, and it says "almost certainly was". It suggests that possible embarrassment is one reason so few official records explain why the uprising happened.

There'd been warning signs. Wikipedia, citing Helen Mackay, says that a year earlier 12 convicts had escaped from Castle Hill and gone looking for friends and sympathisers around the district. When they were caught, every one of them had the same story: they were walking to China over the Blue Mountains. Lynette Ramsay Silver's book explains that many Irish convicts really did believe China lay just past the mountains. Either way, the authorities learned later that the trip had told the rebels where their friends were.

News From Dublin

On Sunday 22 January 1804 the whaler Ferret arrived in Sydney, five months out of London, carrying newspapers up to 22 August 1803. They had the first reports of Robert Emmet's rising in Dublin (Dictionary of Sydney).

Governor Philip Gidley King, who declared martial law on 5 March 1804
Governor Philip Gidley King, who declared martial law on 5 March 1804. State Library of New South Wales collection. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
Robert Emmet portrait
Robert Emmet, whose failed Dublin rising of July 1803 was the news that set Castle Hill alight. This is a later print. Thomas Kelly, 1874, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Emmet's rising had failed, but it fired up the Irish at Castle Hill. Two of them, Philip Cunningham and William Johnston, began planning a rising of their own. In the Dictionary of Sydney the second man's surname is spelt Johnson.

Philip Cunningham

The Dictionary of Sydney describes Cunningham as a stonemason and publican back in Ireland who had tried to reorganise the United Irish network, was transported for sedition and "remained a rebel til his death". He'd been a United Irish captain and recruiting officer, and at Castle Hill he was overseer of the government stonemasons. Wikipedia adds that he was a veteran of 1798 and had taken part in the mutiny on the convict transport Anne. Lynette Silver says he'd been involved in two earlier rebellions, so he knew how much depended on keeping things secret.

His fellow leader at the hill was William Johnston (the Dictionary of Sydney sometimes spells him Johnson). He is not Major George Johnston of the New South Wales Corps, who commanded the soldiers who broke the rising.

The Plan

According to Wikipedia, the plan was for more than 685 Castle Hill convicts to join nearly 1,100 from the Hawkesbury River district. They would rally at Constitution Hill and march on Parramatta and then Sydney. Helen Mackay says the aim was to set up Irish rule in the colony and get ships for anyone who wanted to go home and help restart the failed rising of 1803.

The Dictionary of Sydney has Cunningham's own version, from his speech on the night. Sydney and Parramatta were ready to be taken. After scouring the settlements for arms, he'd lead them to the Hawkesbury, where they'd form a combined force of 1,100 men. That army would come back to Castle Hill on Tuesday morning for breakfast and then take Parramatta. They'd plant a Tree of Liberty at Government House and then go on to Sydney, where ships would be waiting. He finished with the cry, "Now, my boys, Liberty or Death!"

The Night of 4 March 1804

The rising began exactly six weeks after the colony first heard about Emmet. The Dictionary of Sydney says the sun set at 6.28 pm and the rebels moved at seven o'clock, as it got dark. One of the leaders' houses at Castle Hill was set on fire as the signal. Wikipedia, following Silver, puts it at 8 o'clock and names the man as John Cavenah, who set fire to his own hut. Nobody saw the fire at Green Hills, today's Windsor, which was a bad start.

The Dictionary of Sydney says the 200 convicts at Castle Hill were guarded only by a few convict constables, and most of them joined in. The rebels raided every house in Castle Hill for weapons. Wikipedia says about 200 to 300 of them broke into the Government Farm buildings and took firearms, ammunition and other weapons. Then they went from farm to farm, picking up guns, food and rum and spirits, and bringing in recruits, some of them willing and some not. Silver says that at one stage the rebels held about a third of all the weapons in the colony.

Things Go Wrong

Secrecy didn't hold. Wikipedia lists two defectors, an Irish convict overseer named Sloane and Lewis Bulger. Captain Edward Abbott, the commandant at Parramatta, was warned while the rising was happening, started his defences and sent word to the governor in Sydney. Cunningham's courier, John Griffen, had second thoughts about passing his orders on to Brian Furey and was arrested. So the call-outs to Windsor, Parramatta and Sydney never went out, and the rising stayed in the country west of Parramatta. A party of about 70 under Samuel Humes got lost in the night.

Meanwhile the main body gathered on Constitution Hill at Toongabbie. The Dictionary of Sydney explains why that spot made sense. Its crest, three and a half kilometres north-west of Parramatta, gave a view over the whole country. The rebels could see anyone coming with torches from Sydney or Parramatta, their own fires could be seen from miles off, and the hill commanded the road to the Hawkesbury. According to the My Place education site cited on Wikipedia, while they were on Constitution Hill Cunningham was elected "King of the Australian Empire" and his men named the area "New Ireland".

Panic in the Colony

The colony had about 5,000 people, and the news caused real panic. Wikipedia, drawing on Silver, says Samuel Marsden got away by boat with Elizabeth Macarthur and her children, because an informer had warned that the rebels would attack the Macarthurs' farm to draw the troops out of Parramatta.

The Government Strikes Back

The Dictionary of Sydney gives the timetable. Word reached Parramatta soon after 9 pm. In Sydney the alarm went at 11.30 pm with cannon fire and drums. At midnight a trooper woke Major George Johnston of the New South Wales Corps at his home at Annandale and told him the governor was on the way. King soon rode up himself, saying 500 to 600 "Croppies" were in arms. At 1.30 am a company of 55 soldiers reached Annandale, and Johnston led them to Parramatta.

Wikipedia says 140 men from HMS Calcutta and the Sydney Loyal Association militia took over guard duty in Sydney. The detachment that marched through the night included Lieutenant William Davies and Quartermaster Sergeant Thomas Laycock.

Philip Gidley King and family by Robert Dighton 1799
Philip Gidley and Anna Josepha King with their children Elizabeth, Anna Maria and Phillip Parker, painted by Robert Dighton in 1799, the year before King became governor. Robert Dighton, 1799, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Martial Law

King got to Parramatta at four in the morning. Johnston reached the barracks "at the dawn of the day", not long after five (Dictionary of Sydney). By then King had declared martial law. According to Wikipedia it covered everything from Castle Hill to the Hawkesbury and Nepean. Locals could detain anyone without a proper pass, a curfew was set, and an amnesty gave the rebels 24 hours to surrender. Johnston was given his orders in writing and was allowed to fire on anyone who disobeyed him.

Old Government House Parramatta
Old Government House, Parramatta. King rode out here through the night of 4 March 1804 to take charge. BriMiDra, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The armed Parramatta Loyal Association took over defending the town. The troops split up. Lieutenant Davies took half north towards Castle Hill, and Johnston took the rest west towards the rebel camp at Toongabbie. There he was told that 400 rebels were on top of Constitution Hill. He sent a small advance guard round to the flank, then he and Quartermaster Laycock led the remaining 20 soldiers and nearly 40 armed volunteers up the hill. It was empty. The rebels had pulled back towards the Hawkesbury (Dictionary of Sydney).

George Johnston 1810 watercolour by Robert Dighton
George Johnston as a lieutenant colonel in 1810. Six years earlier, as a major, he led the troops at Rouse Hill. Robert Dighton, 1810, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Battle of Vinegar Hill – 5 March 1804

The troops had already marched all night, and now they had a chase on their hands on a day that was "intensely hot". Johnston and Trooper Thomas Anlezark of the Governor's Body Guard of Light Horse rode ahead while the rest followed on foot. After about 16 kilometres, Johnston heard the rebels were less than two kilometres in front. It was about 10.30 on the morning of Monday 5 March (Dictionary of Sydney).

Another circulation of the Castle Hill uprising watercolour used in Australian collections
Another circulation of the Castle Hill uprising watercolour used in Australian collections. Public domain.jpg), via Wikimedia Commons. Same period composition tradition as the NLA watercolour; not a photograph.

Under a Flag of Truce

Johnston sent a mounted trooper to call on the rebels to give up and take the governor's amnesty. That got nowhere, so he brought up the Catholic priest Father James Dixon, who had himself been transported after the 1798 rising, to talk to them (Wikipedia, after Silver). The Dictionary of Sydney says the rebels, an estimated 250 of them, called on Johnston to come among them. He answered that he was within pistol shot, so he was no threat, and their leaders should come out to him. Eventually Cunningham and Johnson stepped forward. When Johnston said he wanted to avoid bloodshed, their answer was "Death or Liberty, and a ship to take us home".

The rebels formed a line on what the Dictionary of Sydney calls the "second hill this side of the last Halfway Pond". Johnston, apparently unarmed, called the two leaders out again and asked them to surrender, with Father Dixon adding his own plea. He got the same answer.

Then Laycock and the main party came into view. While the rebels were distracted, Johnston pulled a pistol he'd hidden in his sash, put it to the head of one of the leaders and told him he'd "blow his soul to hell". Anlezark did the same to the other. Johnston backed off with his two prisoners and ordered his men to open fire and charge.

Later Irish and commemorative writing often calls the seizure under the parley a treacherous breach of a flag of truce. The official Gazette account presents it as presence of mind by Major Johnston under martial law. Both traditions are part of the record; the primary official narrative is Johnston's, printed within days.

The Rout

Wikipedia, following Silver, says Laycock directed more than fifteen minutes of musket fire at the rebel line, then charged and cut Cunningham down with his cutlass. Without their leaders, the rebels fired back a little, then broke and ran. The Dictionary of Sydney gives the count: nine rebels were killed at the Last Pond in the first stage, with many wounded and seven taken prisoner. Soon after, three more were killed and another 19 captured. There's no report of any soldier or volunteer killed or hurt. The rebels were chased in every direction until an "excessive dark" night came down.

According to Silver, Johnston had to threaten his own men with his pistol to stop the killing. Shots were reported in the district for up to a fortnight afterwards as old scores were settled. On Wednesday 7 March King announced that anyone who surrendered before 10 March would be treated leniently. Many who'd lost their way came in, and Humes's party of about 70 was caught back at Castle Hill by the Parramatta Loyal Association.

The Reckoning

The Dictionary of Sydney sums it up: nine rebels were executed and about 30 sent to the chain gang at the Coal River (Newcastle), and many were flogged or put in irons. Silver's book, as Wikipedia reports it, gives the names and places of the hangings:

Philip Cunningham, hanged at Windsor William Johnston, John Neale and George Harrington, hanged at Castle Hill Samuel Humes, Charles Hill and Jonathan Place, hanged at Parramatta John Brannan and Timothy Hogan, hanged at Sydney

Cunningham was still alive but badly wounded. He was carried with the wounded to the Hawkesbury (Green Hills / Windsor). He was not put before the General Court Martial that tried the other selected leaders later in the week. The Sydney Gazette of 11 March 1804, the colony's official paper, says Major George Johnston considered him "a proper object to make an immediate example of, by virtue of the Martial Law that then existed, and the discretionary power given him by His Excellency, and after taking the opinion of the Officers about him, directed him to be publicly executed on the Stair Case of the Public Store, which he had boasted in his march he was going to plunder." So Cunningham was hanged under martial law on the staircase of the public store at Windsor, without a court martial. The date is usually given as 5 or 6 March 1804. That is the sourced basis for the claim that he was hanged without trial.

The same Gazette report is also the best check on the nine names. It says ten men were tried by General Court Martial at Parramatta, all sentenced to hang, with Burke and M'Cormick then reprieved — so eight of those court-martialled were executed, plus Cunningham, making nine in all. The Gazette names the carried-out sentences as: Humes, Charles Hill and John Place at Parramatta; Johnston, Harrington and Neale at Castle Hill; Brannan and Hogan at Sydney. Charles Hill is in that Gazette court-martial list; he is not an accidental extra. Secondary lists (including Silver as summarised elsewhere) match those eight plus Cunningham. It should not be stretched to say all nine died "without trial": only Cunningham's execution skipped the court martial. Johnston and Humes were hung in chains afterwards, which is to say gibbeted, their bodies left on show as a warning.

Wikipedia, following Silver, says the officers had started a military court at the Whipping Green in Parramatta, now Prince Alfred Square, with the idea of hanging a token number of prisoners. King stopped it quickly because he was worried about what it would lead to. Two men, John Burke and Bryan McCormack, were reprieved and held at the governor's pleasure. Seven were flogged with 200 or 500 lashes and sent to the Coal River chain gang: John Griffin, Neil Smith, Bryan Burne, Connor Dwyer, David Morrison, Cornelius Lyons and Owen McDermot. Another 23, including Cavenah, went to the Newcastle coal mines, and 34 more were put in irons until they could be "disposed of". Of the remaining 150 or so, some were put on good behaviour with Norfolk Island as the penalty if they slipped up. Most were pardoned and sent back to work, on the grounds that they'd been forced into it.

The ADB entry on King says he divided the ringleaders between the different settlements, including Newcastle, which he re-established in 1804 largely to hold them. Martial law was lifted on 10 March 1804. The plotting didn't stop, though. Silver describes military call-out drills continuing for the next three years, and King, convinced that the real instigators had stayed out of sight, sent some suspects to Norfolk Island just in case.

Rewards

The ADB says Johnston was given 2,000 acres at Cabramatta as King's thanks for his part in putting down the rising. Four years later, as the Dictionary of Sydney puts it, he took part in the Rum Rebellion against Governor Bligh and made himself lieutenant-governor. The Dictionary of Sydney describes Thomas Laycock as the quartermaster of the New South Wales Corps and a landowner who helped put down the rising.

Rouse family at Rouse Hill House about 1859
The Rouse family and others at Rouse Hill House, about 1859 to 1865. The battle site is thought to lie east of the Rouse Hill estate. Major Thomas Wingate, State Library of New South Wales, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Where Was the Battle?

For a long time nobody could say for sure where the fight happened. The Dictionary of Sydney says the question stayed contentious until local historian Kevin Moore did the research, and a Commission of Inquiry confirmed his findings in 1982. That inquiry, under Commissioner Charles O'Connell, looked at land near Windsor Road at the Second Ponds Creek. Wikipedia says the site is believed to lie east of the Rouse Hill estate, and that Richard Rouse, a firm establishment man, was probably given his land grant there to stop it becoming a rallying place for the Irish. It also says some debate continues about the exact spot.

Memorials and Remembering

The Memorial at Castlebrook

The site in Castlebrook Memorial Park on Windsor Road, Rouse Hill, is marked by a memorial designed by Vladimir Sitta and Ivan Polak. It was unveiled in 1988 (Dictionary of Sydney), and Monument Australia, cited by Wikipedia, says it was dedicated that March. Blacktown City Council, whose area takes in the site, still calls it the Battle of Vinegar Hill (as cited on Wikipedia).

Castle Hill Heritage Park

The Government Farm site is now Castle Hill Heritage Park, off Gilbert Road near Old Northern Road. It was added to the State Heritage Register on 22 December 2000 (listing no. 1448) under names including the Third Government Farm, the Castle Hill Settlement Site and the Castle Hill Convict Farm. The Hills Shire Council owns it. Back in March 1986, "The Government Farm at Castle Hill", about 60 hectares, had been put on the old Register of the National Estate.

Castle Hill Heritage Park view 2
Rolling ground at Castle Hill Heritage Park, where the convicts once cleared and farmed. Collywolly, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The farm had a long life after the rebellion. In 1811 Macquarie had the barracks turned into an asylum. Commissioner Bigge recommended it be closed, and in 1826 the inmates were moved to the Liverpool Courthouse. The building was then turned into a church. Around 1886 the old asylum was pulled down, and its stone was reportedly used to build the rectory of St Paul's Anglican Church, Castle Hill. The glebe land was sold off to orchardists from 1895, and there was even a dog racing track on the western edge (heritage listing, via Wikipedia).

Castle Hill Heritage Park view 3
Inside Castle Hill Heritage Park. Most of the trees here grew back after the farm era. Collywolly, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Castle Hill Heritage Park view 4
A path through the heritage park, which covers about 20 hectares. Collywolly, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Housing has eaten away most of the old prison town. Less than 20 hectares was left undeveloped and kept as the park. For the bicentenary it got a makeover costing more than $3.4 million, and the Governor of New South Wales, Professor Marie Bashir, opened it in March 2004. There are no historic buildings left. The site of the barracks and kitchen was excavated in 2006, and their sandstone footings survive. Chicken sheds built in the 1960s had already destroyed the northern two-thirds of the barracks remains.

Castle Hill Heritage Park view 5
Castle Hill Heritage Park, reopened after a $3.4 million makeover in the bicentenary year of 2004. Collywolly, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Castle Hill Heritage Park view 6
Another view of the park, near where the barracks once stood. Collywolly, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Castle Hill Heritage Park view 7
Castle Hill Heritage Park. The sandstone footings of the barracks and kitchen were dug up in 2006. Collywolly, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Castle Hill Heritage Park view 8
Castle Hill Heritage Park today, owned by The Hills Shire Council. Collywolly, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The 2004 Bicentenary and on Screen

The 200th anniversary in 2004 was marked with a range of events, and Blacktown City Council put out an official program. In the re-enactment, Wikipedia says, the exact numbers were recruited for the rebels, the militia and the soldiers. It was held near the original site on similar country and was filmed by the ABC. The story had already been on television. The 1978 series Against the Wind dramatised the lead-up and the defeat over two episodes, and there was also a radio play, Castle Hill.

Timeline

1798 – Main Wexford campaign of the Irish rebellion crushed at Vinegar Hill; fighting and repression continue afterwards. 1800 – Minerva and Friendship bring 1798 exiles. Plots are uncovered in February, May, September and October, and one on Norfolk Island in December. 1801 – Work starts on the Third Government Farm at Castle Hill. The Anne arrives. 1802 – Atlas I, Atlas II and Hercules arrive. Péron visits Castle Hill in October. 30 June 1803 – King reports a two-storey stone barracks under construction at Castle Hill. July 1803 – Robert Emmet's rising in Dublin. 22 January 1804 – The Ferret brings the news of Emmet to Sydney. 4 March 1804, about 7–8 pm – A hut is set alight at Castle Hill and the rising begins. 4 March, after 9 pm – Word reaches Parramatta. At 11.30 pm the alarm sounds in Sydney. 5 March, about 4 am – King reaches Parramatta and declares martial law. 5 March, about 5 am – Johnston reaches Parramatta and sets out after the rebels. 5 March, about 10.30 am – The fight at "Vinegar Hill" near Rouse Hill. 7 March 1804 – King offers leniency to those who surrender before 10 March. 10 March 1804 – Martial law is lifted. March 1804 – Nine rebels are hanged at Windsor, Castle Hill, Parramatta and Sydney. Others are flogged and sent to Coal River. 1811 – The Castle Hill barracks becomes an asylum. It closes in 1826. c.1886 – The old building is demolished. 1982 – A Commission of Inquiry confirms Kevin Moore's location of the battle site. March 1986 – The Government Farm site goes on the Register of the National Estate. 1988 – The memorial is unveiled at Castlebrook Memorial Park, Rouse Hill. 22 December 2000 – Castle Hill Heritage Park goes on the State Heritage Register. March 2004 – The bicentenary, with a re-enactment and the reopening of Castle Hill Heritage Park by Marie Bashir. 2006 – The barracks site is excavated.

Where the Sources Disagree

How many rebels? The Dictionary of Sydney says there were 200 convicts at Castle Hill and puts the force at the battle at an estimated 250. Wikipedia, citing Silver, gives 233, the number in the government-controlled newspaper of the day. Chris Coulthard-Clark gives 230 to 260. The heritage listing says about 300, and Wikipedia also says 200 to 300 broke into the farm buildings. On the night, King was told 500 to 600 were in arms, and Johnston was told 400 were on Constitution Hill. The planners had hoped for 685 from Castle Hill and about 1,100 from the Hawkesbury. How many soldiers? The Dictionary of Sydney has 20 troops and nearly 40 armed volunteers going up Constitution Hill with Johnston and Laycock. The ADB says Johnston had 26 soldiers and the rebels were ten times their number. Wikipedia's summary gives 30 regulars and 67 militia. The death toll. The Dictionary of Sydney counts nine killed at the Last Pond and three more soon after, 12 in all. Official reports, as given by Silver and repeated by the heritage listing, say at least 15 fell. An unknown number more were killed in the chase, and some accounts say about 30 were killed or wounded near Parramatta's western gate earlier on (Mackay). Sent to the Coal River. The Dictionary of Sydney says some 30. Silver lists 7 flogged and sent to the chain gang plus 23 sent to the mines, and 34 more were held in irons. The heritage listing says fifty, and nine flogged. The signal fire. The Dictionary of Sydney says seven o'clock and the house of "one of the leaders". Wikipedia, after Silver, says 8 o'clock and names John Cavenah, who burnt his own hut. "Death or Liberty". The Dictionary of Sydney has Cunningham ending his Castle Hill speech with "Liberty or Death!" and the reply at the hill as "Death or Liberty, and a ship to take us home". Wikipedia says the "ship to take us home" part was recorded only once, some time later, by Suttor, and was perhaps added by some of the men. The name. The Dictionary of Sydney calls the second leader William Johnson, and Wikipedia calls him William Johnston. That's not to be confused with Major George Johnston. The site. The Dictionary of Sydney treats the Castlebrook site as settled by the 1982 inquiry. Wikipedia says there's still some debate about where the battle was actually fought. Why it happened. The heritage listing says the popular view was a bid for freedom from cruel punishment and short rations, but argues it was more likely an organised political revolt by Irishmen who never accepted English authority. Mackay sees the aim as Irish rule in the colony and ships home to help a new Irish rising.

Cunningham's end. The Sydney Gazette (11 March 1804) is clear that he was executed at the Hawkesbury public store under martial-law discretion after officers were consulted, not by the General Court Martial that sentenced the other leaders. The National Museum of Australia's Defining Moments page says Governor King had Cunningham and eight others hanged without trial; that overstates the case for the eight. People Australia and commemorative markers give 5 or 6 March 1804 at Windsor. A minority tradition, discussed by Andrew Moore, has Laycock killing Cunningham in the field and the hanging as exemplary display of a body already dead; the Gazette says he was carried wounded and still alive when ordered hanged.

My Earlier Posts

Arrest of Governor Bligh – The Rum Rebellion – 26 January 1808 The Rum Rebellion – 26th January 1808 – Governor William Bligh Is Overthrown Elizabeth Farm – Alice Street – Parramatta Parklands – Castle Hill – NSW

Sources

Anne-Maree Whitaker, "Castle Hill convict rebellion 1804", Dictionary of Sydney, 2009, with its linked entries on Philip Cunningham, Thomas Laycock, James Dixon, the Loyal Associations, Castlebrook Memorial Park and Rouse Hill – https://dictionaryofsydney.org/entry/castle_hill_convict_rebellion_1804 "Castle Hill convict rebellion", Wikipedia, citing Lynette Ramsay Silver, The Battle of Vinegar Hill (1989), Chris Coulthard-Clark, Where Australians Fought (1998), Helen Mackay (2016), Clem Sargent (1998) and Anne-Maree Whitaker, Unfinished Revolution (1994) – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_Hill_convict_rebellion "Third Government Farm", Wikipedia, based on the NSW State Heritage Register listing no. 1448 – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Government_Farm "Johnston, George (1764–1823)", Australian Dictionary of Biography – https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/johnston-george-2277 "King, Philip Gidley (1758–1808)", Australian Dictionary of Biography – https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/king-philip-gidley-2309 Images from Wikimedia Commons, credited under each picture, including the 1804 watercolour held by the National Library of Australia and the c.1806 Castle Hill view in the Mitchell Library.

Primary and scholarly additions for this revision:

  • Sydney Gazette, 11 March 1804, "Insurrection" (full text reprint): https://www.australianculture.org/insurrection-1804/
  • Trove / Sydney Gazette related offender notes, 18 March 1804: https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/626091
  • Anne-Maree Whitaker, Dictionary of Sydney, "Castle Hill convict rebellion 1804": https://dictionaryofsydney.org/entry/castle_hill_convict_rebellion_1804
  • National Museum of Australia, Defining Moments (compare carefully on "without trial"): https://www.nma.gov.au/defining-moments/resources/castle-hill-rebellion
  • Andrew Moore, "Phil Cunningham: A Forgotten Irish-Australian Rebel", ASSLH Hummer: https://www.labourhistory.org.au/hummer/vol-4-no-2/cunningham/
  • People Australia / ANU, Philip Cunningham biography: https://peopleaustralia.anu.edu.au/biography/cunningham-philip-33227