Search This Blog

Friday, November 20, 2026

Il Porcellino – The Little Pig of Sydney Hospital – Macquarie Street – From Tacca's Florence to the Fiaschi Gift – 1968 to Today

If you've walked up Macquarie Street past Sydney Hospital you'll have seen him. He sits out the front facing the street, a big bronze wild boar settled back on his haunches, mouth open and ears up, as if someone has just called his name. He's dark green-brown all over except for one spot: his snout, which shines like gold. Thousands of Sydney hands have done that, one rub at a time, for nearly sixty years.

He's Il Porcellino, Italian for 'the little pig', and he isn't really a pig at all. He's a copy of one of Florence's best-loved fountains, and he came to Sydney in 1968 as a gift from an elderly Sydney-born marchesa in memory of her father and brother, both surgeons at the hospital behind him. Every coin dropped at his feet goes to the hospital. He's been raising money for over half a century, which makes him probably the hardest-working pig in the country.

Il Porcellino outside Sydney Hospital, his snout rubbed to a golden shine.
Il Porcellino outside Sydney Hospital, his snout rubbed to a golden shine.
Greg O'Beirne, 2006, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons

His story starts a long way from Macquarie Street: with a marble boar dug up in ancient Rome, a Medici duke, one of the great bronze-casters of seventeenth-century Florence, a fairy tale by Hans Christian Andersen and a Florentine foundry that's been casting him for more than a century. So let's start at the beginning.

The Boar from Ancient Rome

The oldest boar in this story is made of marble. It's a big, realistic wild boar sitting on its haunches, carved in the ancient world and long thought to be a Roman copy of a Greek sculpture from the Hellenistic period, around the third century BC. It was found in Rome in the sixteenth century. The Italian art histories say Pope Pius IV gave it to Cosimo I de' Medici, Duke of Florence, in 1560, and it's been in Florence ever since. Today it stands in the Uffizi Gallery.

From the moment it was found, people linked it with the Calydonian Boar of Greek myth, the monster sent by the goddess Artemis to ravage the countryside, which the heroes Meleager and Atalanta hunted down. Whether the sculptor meant that boar or simply a fine wild animal, nobody knows. Its exact date is still argued over too. Some experts call it a Roman copy of a lost bronze; others, after it was restored in 2009, suggested details inside the mouth were too fine for a copyist and that it may be a Greek original.

The marble boar in the Uffizi Gallery, Florence: the ancient sculpture that Tacca's bronze was modelled on.
The marble boar in the Uffizi Gallery, Florence: the ancient sculpture that Tacca's bronze was modelled on.
Yair Haklai, 2019, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
An early photograph of the same marble boar in the second vestibule of the Uffizi.
An early photograph of the same marble boar in the second vestibule of the Uffizi.
Nicholas Catsimpoolas collection, via DPLA, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Pietro Tacca and the Medici Commission

Pietro Tacca was born in Carrara, the marble town in north-west Tuscany, on 16 September 1577. In 1592 he joined the Florence workshop of Giambologna, the most famous sculptor of the day, and became his chief pupil. When Giambologna died in 1608, Tacca took over the workshop, finished his master's uncompleted works, and soon became court sculptor to the Medici Grand Dukes of Tuscany.

He was above all a master of bronze. His best-known works include the Monument of the Four Moors at Livorno (1620s), the two strange, sea-monster fountains in Florence's Piazza della Santissima Annunziata, and his last great commission, the rearing equestrian statue of King Philip IV of Spain in Madrid. That horse balances its whole weight on its hind legs, and Galileo is said to have helped with the calculations. It was shipped to Spain in 1640, the year Tacca died, on 26 October 1640.

Grand Duke Cosimo II de' Medici asked Tacca to make a bronze copy of the marble boar. The sources don't agree on exactly when. Italian sources date the commission to 1612, which is the year often quoted in Sydney; a 1975 study of Tacca, cited by the art historians Francis Haskell and Nicholas Penny, dates it to 1621. Either way it took years. Tacca was busy with more urgent work for the court, a wax model seems to have been ready only around 1620, and the boar was finally cast in bronze around 1633, shortly before 1634.

Tacca didn't just copy the marble. He gave the bronze boar sharper bristles, tighter muscles and a livelier, more alert face, and art historians say the bronze has long since overshadowed the marble it was copied from. It was first meant for the Medici gardens at the Pitti Palace, but around 1640 Grand Duke Ferdinando II decided to turn it into a public fountain.

Pietro Tacca's original bronze, now kept indoors in the Museo Stefano Bardini, Florence. Even here the snout is worn bright.
Pietro Tacca's original bronze, now kept indoors in the Museo Stefano Bardini, Florence. Even here the snout is worn bright.
Sailko, 2009, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons

A Fountain for the Market

The fountain was set up in the Loggia del Mercato Nuovo, the 'New Market', an open arcaded market hall built for Cosimo I between about 1547 and 1551 by the architect Giovanni Battista del Tasso. It's only a few steps from the Ponte Vecchio. In Tacca's day the merchants under the loggia sold fine cloth, silks and brocades; later it was famous for straw hats, which is why English-speaking visitors called it the Straw Market. Today it's mostly leather goods and souvenirs.

For the fountain Tacca created a new bronze base that isn't part of the ancient marble at all. The boar now sat above a little marshy pool crowded with plants and small creatures: snakes, frogs, snails, tortoises, lizards, crabs and insects, modelled so realistically that he probably cast some of them from real animals. Water ran from the boar's mouth into a bean-shaped basin at the front, and the fountain was a working water supply for the traders as well as an ornament.

He was set up on the east side of the loggia, facing Via Por Santa Maria, in front of a pharmacy that soon took his name: the Farmacia del Cinghiale, the 'Pharmacy of the Wild Boar'. ('Cinghiale' is the proper Italian word for a wild boar. Florentines have always called him the Porcellino anyway.)

What survives of Tacca's original bronze base, with its pool, plants and small creatures, in the Museo Bardini.
What survives of Tacca's original bronze base, with its pool, plants and small creatures, in the Museo Bardini.
Sailko, 2013, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The Loggia del Mercato Nuovo, painted by Giovanni Signorini in 1845.
The Loggia del Mercato Nuovo, painted by Giovanni Signorini in 1845.
Giovanni Signorini, 1845, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Two centuries of market life were hard on him. People clambered over the base to reach the water spout and the bronze wore away. In 1854 the city put a protective railing around the fountain designed by Mariano Falcini, with a separate drinking tap. In 1856 the sculptor Giovanni Benelli modelled a completely new base, based on Tacca's but with changes because the worn original was hard to read. Clemente Papi cast it in 1857 and restored the boar at the same time. Accounts of the later copies differ on whether they come from Tacca's own moulds or from moulds taken during this nineteenth-century restoration.

The Porcellino fountain in an engraving from Italy from the Alps to Mount Etna (1877).
The Porcellino fountain in an engraving from Italy from the Alps to Mount Etna (1877).
Internet Archive Book Images, No known copyright restrictions, via Wikimedia Commons
The Porcellino fountain in a nineteenth-century painting by Max Albert Hauschild, with market people gathered around the boar.
The Porcellino fountain in a nineteenth-century painting by Max Albert Hauschild, with market people gathered around the boar.
Max Albert Hauschild (died 1895), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In 1928, to give the traffic on busy Via Por Santa Maria more room, the fountain was moved round to the south side of the loggia, where his copy stands today. Tacca's original base was taken away and its pieces put into storage.

The boar in his original position on the east side of the loggia, facing Via Por Santa Maria, before 1928.
The boar in his original position on the east side of the loggia, facing Via Por Santa Maria, before 1928.
Photographer unknown; Musei Civici Fiorentini, Public domain (PD-old-70), via Wikimedia Commons
The boar in his new position on the south side of the loggia, about 1928–29, soon after the move.
The boar in his new position on the south side of the loggia, about 1928–29, soon after the move.
Photographer unknown; Musei Civici Fiorentini, Public domain (PD-old-70), via Wikimedia Commons
The Loggia del Mercato Nuovo photographed by the Alinari firm around 1890.
The Loggia del Mercato Nuovo photographed by the Alinari firm around 1890.
Alinari, c. 1890; Library of Congress, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Rub the Nose, Drop a Coin

Nobody knows when the custom started, but it's old. The Scottish writer Tobias Smollett noted it in his Travels Through France and Italy in 1766. The tradition, as Florentines tell it, goes like this. Rub the boar's snout and you'll have good luck, and you're sure to come back to Florence. Then put a coin in his open mouth and let it go. If it slides down and falls through the grating where the water drains, your wish will come true. If it doesn't, bad luck.

That's tradition, of course, not a promise. Florentine writers point out that the grating is sloped so that most coins drop through anyway, especially heavy ones. What is certain is that the coins go to a good cause. In Florence they're collected for the Opera della Divina Provvidenza Madonnina del Grappa, a charity for children founded by the priest Don Giulio Facibeni; a plaque to him has been in the loggia since 1969. In 1968 the Marchesa Torrigiani told the Sydney Morning Herald that the Florence boar raised more than $6,000 a year for 'a Florence orphanage'. (The City of Sydney's own description says the money went to a hospital in Florence.)

The rubbing is why his snout shines. On a bronze left outdoors, the surface slowly darkens to a brown-green patina. Where people touch it every day the patina never gets the chance to form, and the bare bronze is polished to a bright golden colour. It happens in Florence, it happens in Sydney, and it's happened on every copy anyone can touch.

Andersen's Metal Pig

The boar has a fairy tale of his own. Hans Christian Andersen visited Florence in 1833–34 and fell for the city. In 1842 he published 'The Metal Pig' (Metalsvinet) in A Poet's Bazaar, the story of a poor, hungry street boy who falls asleep on the bronze boar's back one night. The boar comes to life and carries him through the dark streets of Florence to the galleries and churches, and the boy grows up to be a painter.

In 2005, the two-hundredth anniversary of Andersen's birth, the City of Florence put up a plaque in the loggia. It says that here the tale of the Porcellino began, written by the Danish storyteller 'who loved Florence, where he stayed many times'. In Andersen's home country there's a bronze boar in Holstebro too.

The 2005 plaque in the loggia recalling Hans Christian Andersen, whose tale The Metal Pig began here.
The 2005 plaque in the loggia recalling Hans Christian Andersen, whose tale The Metal Pig began here.
Sailko, 2021, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The orphan boy riding the bronze boar through Florence at night: an 1895 illustration for Andersen's tale.
The orphan boy riding the bronze boar through Florence at night: an 1895 illustration for Andersen's tale.
Alfred Walter Bayes, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers, 1895, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Marinelli Foundry and the Florence Copies

This is where the boar's story turns towards Sydney. The Fonderia Artistica Ferdinando Marinelli was founded in Florence in 1905 by Ferdinando Marinelli, who had learned the old lost-wax method of bronze casting. The foundry, later based at Barberino Val d'Elsa outside Florence, became famous for faithful copies of Renaissance bronzes, and for more than a century it has been the boar's main maker.

By the late twentieth century the rubbing had become a real worry. Tacca's own bronze was being worn away. So the Marinelli foundry cast a full-size copy that even copied the worn patches and the different colours of the original's surface. Florence's local paper FirenzeToday says the copy was made in 1988 and installed in the loggia ten years later, in 1998. (The English Wikipedia says it was cast in 1998 and put in place in 2008, so you'll see both sets of dates.) Tacca's original went into safekeeping and now sits indoors at the Museo Stefano Bardini, the city museum in Palazzo Mozzi, alongside what survives of his old base and Papi's nineteenth-century base. It's been there since 2004, and the museum reopened to the public in 2009 after ten years of work.

Tacca's boar in the City of Florence room at the Museo Bardini, displayed with the old bronze base.
Tacca's boar in the City of Florence room at the Museo Bardini, displayed with the old bronze base.
Sailko, 2021, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Even the copy can't escape the rubbing. In October 2011 the snout was so worn and cracked that the Marinelli foundry repaired it at its own expense, under the eye of the city's heritage staff. In October 2021 the Corriere Fiorentino reported new cracks around the much-rubbed snout, and the council said engineers were deciding whether to repair it on site or in the workshop. The boar you rub in Florence today has had his nose fixed more than once.

The modern Marinelli copy at the Mercato Nuovo in 2022, with its golden snout.
The modern Marinelli copy at the Mercato Nuovo in 2022, with its golden snout.
Diego Delso, 2022, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The Loggia del Mercato Nuovo today, still a busy market just up from the Ponte Vecchio.
The Loggia del Mercato Nuovo today, still a busy market just up from the Ponte Vecchio.
Julian Lupyan, 2023, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Boars Around the World

Copies of Tacca's boar turned up all over the world, starting long before 1968. Wealthy travellers on the Grand Tour took copies home for their gardens. Small bronze versions were made for collectors' tables from the seventeenth century on. Full-size boars sit in English country houses and gardens such as Chatsworth, Castle Howard and Osborne House, Queen Victoria's home on the Isle of Wight, as well as in the Derby Arboretum.

There are many more. You'll find him at the Royal Greenhouses of Laeken in Brussels, Antwerp Zoo, the Louvre, Aix-en-Provence, Madrid's El Capricho park, Munich, Stockholm, Holstebro in Denmark, Butchart Gardens in Victoria, Canada, the University of Waterloo in Ontario, and Japan. The United States has dozens, from university campuses to wineries, shopping centres and even a Las Vegas casino bar.

The Florentine Boar in Derby Arboretum, England.
The Florentine Boar in Derby Arboretum, England.
James Haynes, 2008, via Geograph, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Another cousin: the bronze boar at Brotorvet, Holstebro, Denmark.
Another cousin: the bronze boar at Brotorvet, Holstebro, Denmark.
RalfSkjerning, 2012, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
A small bronze boar after Tacca's model, late seventeenth or early eighteenth century, in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.
A small bronze boar after Tacca's model, late seventeenth or early eighteenth century, in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.
Metropolitan Museum of Art, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

One of those American boars matters more to Sydney's story than all the rest. On 28 April 1962 the Nichols family, who developed Kansas City's Country Club Plaza, dedicated a Marinelli boar there. Its plaque read: 'With good fortune for your children and the children of Mercy Hospital. Rub his nose – drop a coin.' The coins went to Children's Mercy Hospital, and the City of Sydney says the Kansas City boar raised so much that it gave the Marchesa Torrigiani her idea. Some accounts say the Kansas City boar and Sydney's were both among a small batch the foundry cast in 1962.

The Marinelli boar at Country Club Plaza, Kansas City, dedicated in 1962 for Children's Mercy Hospital. Its success inspired the Sydney gift.
The Marinelli boar at Country Club Plaza, Kansas City, dedicated in 1962 for Children's Mercy Hospital. Its success inspired the Sydney gift.
Daderot, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Dr Thomas Fiaschi: Florence to Macquarie Street

To understand why a Florentine boar sits on Macquarie Street, you need to meet Thomas Henry Fiaschi, one of the most remarkable doctors colonial Sydney ever had.

He was born in Florence on 31 May 1853, the son of Lodovico Fiaschi, a professor of mathematics, and his English-born wife Clarissa, née Fisher. He began studying medicine at the university, but at 21 he set off for Australia. In 1875 he was a doctor on the Palmer River goldfields in north Queensland, and then a 'house surgeon' at St Vincent's Hospital in Sydney. There he met Catherine Ann Reynolds, an Irish-born nun at St Vincent's, and in February 1876 they married. The couple went back to Florence, where he graduated in medicine and surgery in 1877, and in February 1879 they arrived back in Sydney on the Garonne. He set up practice at Windsor on the Hawkesbury.

Dr Thomas Henry Fiaschi about 1889–90, a few years before he joined Sydney Hospital.
Dr Thomas Henry Fiaschi about 1889–90, a few years before he joined Sydney Hospital.
British Medical Association (New South Wales Branch); Heritage NSW, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

He was a brilliant and fearless surgeon. The Australian Dictionary of Biography credits him with pioneering work in Listerian antiseptic surgery, goitre, hydatid disease and bone surgery, and he translated Bassini's Italian text on hernia surgery into English. He became an honorary surgeon at Sydney Hospital, the unpaid senior post that carried great prestige. Sources give different starting dates: the Dictionary of Biography says 1894, other accounts say 1890, and in 1968 his daughter said he'd been an honorary surgeon there 'for 30 years'.

He was a soldier as well. In 1896 he served as a surgeon with the Italian army in Abyssinia, and Italy made him a knight of the Order of Saints Maurice and Lazarus. He commanded the New South Wales 1st Field Hospital in the Boer War, and was awarded the Distinguished Service Order in 1901. In May 1915, at almost 62, he sailed to command the 3rd Australian General Hospital on the Greek island of Lemnos, nursing the wounded and sick from Gallipoli, until beriberi forced him out to England in November. When he recovered, he went to Italy and spent 1916–17 operating in an Italian military hospital at Schio in the Trentino, with his second wife Amy, née Curtis, nursing for the Italian Red Cross. He retired in 1921 as an honorary brigadier-general.

Fiaschi also had a second great love: wine. He was convinced that wine was good medicine, and in 1882 he started planting vines at Sackville Reach on the Hawkesbury, where he built the Tizzana winery in 1887. He later planted a vineyard near Mudgee and had cellars in Little George Street in the city. He was president of the Australian Wine Producers' Association of New South Wales for a quarter of a century, and the Herald has called him a father of Australian viticulture. The winery took its name from Tizzana, a village in Tuscany, and Heritage NSW has since honoured him with one of its Blue Plaques. He also founded the Dante Alighieri Art and Literary Society in Australia.

Thomas Fiaschi died of pneumonia at his son's home at Darling Point on 17 April 1927, and was buried in Waverley Cemetery.

Thomas Rowe's new Sydney Hospital on Macquarie Street in 1900, when Dr Fiaschi was one of its honorary surgeons.
Thomas Rowe's new Sydney Hospital on Macquarie Street in 1900, when Dr Fiaschi was one of its honorary surgeons.
City of Sydney Archives, A-01203625, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Dr Piero Fiaschi

His son Piero Francis Bruno Fiaschi was born at Windsor on 5 March 1879, only weeks after his parents came back from Italy. He went to Sydney Church of England Grammar School (Shore) and trained in New York and at the Royal College of Surgeons in England before becoming a Sydney doctor himself.

Like his father he was a soldier-doctor. He enlisted in the AIF on 20 August 1914, served on Gallipoli with the 1st Light Horse Field Ambulance, and later commanded the 13th Field Ambulance in France as a lieutenant-colonel. He was mentioned in despatches and appointed OBE. Between the wars he commanded militia field ambulances and worked at Sydney Hospital; the Dictionary of Sydney lists him there from 1936 to 1946.

Piero's end was a sad one. On 15 June 1948 he died at Sydney Hospital of accidental burns, caused, according to the accounts of the time, by an exploding spirit stove. He was 69, and he was buried at Waverley near his father.

Clarissa, the Marchesa Torrigiani

Thomas's daughter, Clarissa Louisa Fiaschi, was born in Sydney on 4 November 1885. She moved to Italy when she was sixteen and married into the Torrigiani, one of the old noble families of Florence. As the Marchesa Torrigiani she spent the rest of her life there. She knew the Porcellino well; he was part of the everyday life of her father's home city.

Around 1961, she told the Herald, she saw a 'beautiful' bronze copy of the Porcellino in a gallery in Rome, and at once wanted to give one to Sydney in memory of her father and brother. 'I used to go past the gallery and look to see if the monument was still there,' she said. It took her seven years of saving.

On 6 March 1968 the 82-year-old marchesa sailed into Sydney on the Lloyd Triestino liner Galileo. She'd been away seventeen years. The next morning's Herald quoted her:

"My father was a great one. I don't want the Fiaschi name to be forgotten… He is a gay monument, not sad, and he works for his living. He will earn lots of money for Sydney Hospital, where my father was an honorary surgeon for 30 years. The children will love him… I have dreamed of doing this all this time and I knew I must not wait too long."

She suggested that he stand where plenty of people walked by, at the Macquarie Street end of Martin Place. That's very nearly where he ended up, in front of Sydney Hospital, facing down Martin Place. By coincidence, she arrived almost exactly a hundred years after Lucy Osburn and her Nightingale nurses reached Sydney Hospital in March 1868.

Unveiling Day, 1968

The City of Sydney says the bronze was finished and installed by 18 April 1968. At the time the city had no Lord Mayor or aldermen: the State government had dismissed the City Council in late 1967 and put a panel of commissioners in charge, led by the Chief Commissioner, Vernon Treatt. A Herald photograph shows Treatt shaking hands with the Italian Ambassador, Dr Mario Majoli, at an unveiling ceremony; the archive caption dates it 17 August 1968.

The formal handover came at the end of the year. The plaque on top of the base says the sculpture was 'presented to the City of Sydney by The Marchesa Fiaschi Torrigiani of Florence, Italy, and accepted by the Chief Commissioner, The Hon Vernon Haddon Treatt… on 16-12-68'. The Italian-Australian paper Il Globo recalls that Monday, 16 December 1968, when it was pouring with rain and Ambassador Majoli handed over the lucky monument in the Marchesa's name. The City of Sydney's online history gives the presentation as 16 December 1969, which doesn't match the plaque. The City also says the Marchesa had to hurry back to Italy because of illness in the family, so she may not have seen the final ceremony herself.

The first coins were thrown by nine-year-old Tom Yates, a schoolboy from her Sydney family. The Herald calls him her great-nephew; Il Globo describes him as the son of Clarissa's sister Camilla. Fifty years later he remembered it well: 'I had a small amount of special coins in my bag with the Italian flag on one side and the Australian flag on the other.' He also remembered his mother telling him firmly to make sure his tie was straight and to keep his hands out of his pockets.

Il Porcellino in January 2021, with the sandstone of Sydney Hospital behind him.
Il Porcellino in January 2021, with the sandstone of Sydney Hospital behind him.
Maksym Kozlenko, 2021, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What the Plaques Say

Walk all the way around the sandstone base and you'll find several inscriptions. The City of Sydney records them like this.

On the left:

1968. This wild boar fountain of good luck is a donation from Clarissa Torrigiani in memory of her father Dr Thomas and her brother Dr Piero Fiaschi. 'Porcellino' collects money for the Sydney Hospital for which both worked as Hon Surgeons.

In the middle:

Il Porcellino. When you rub my nose and make a wish your donation supports research, education and development at Sydney Hospital, Australia's First Hospital.

On the right:

This wild boar has come from Florence to Sydney as a link of friendship between Italy and Australia in memory of Brigadier General Thomas Fiaschi who loved and served so gallantly for both countries.

Facing the sky is the presentation plaque quoted above, signed by the Town Clerk, L. H. Luscombe. And facing Macquarie Street:

Il Porcellino. If coins are dropped into the fountain or donations put into the box legend says that if you rub the nose of the boar, you will be endowed with good fortune. All donations will care for the sick in Sydney Hospital.
Face to face with the boar on Macquarie Street, February 2023. He sits on his left haunch above a bronze pool, with the hospital's name over the arches behind.
Face to face with the boar on Macquarie Street, February 2023. He sits on his left haunch above a bronze pool, with the hospital's name over the arches behind.
-wuppertaler, 2023, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A Closer Look

The City of Sydney describes him as a larger-than-life bronze wild boar, anatomically realistic, resting on his left haunch and front legs. He sits on a bronze base over a small pool, and in front is a cast-iron fountain receptacle. The whole thing stands on a sandstone base about 1.8 metres square, and is about 1.6 metres high altogether.

Do take the time to look down. Around his feet is a tiny marsh straight out of Tacca's Florence, full of tortoises, snakes, frogs, snails, lizards and crabs hiding among the leaves and reeds. The ones people can reach have shiny backs as well.

A tortoise climbing through the bronze undergrowth at the boar's feet.
A tortoise climbing through the bronze undergrowth at the boar's feet.
-wuppertaler, 2023, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
A snake slides through the reeds and leaves around the pool.
A snake slides through the reeds and leaves around the pool.
-wuppertaler, 2023, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
A crab, its claws polished by passing hands, with coins visible in the grating behind.
A crab, its claws polished by passing hands, with coins visible in the grating behind.
-wuppertaler, 2023, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
A frog perched on a leaf at the edge of the pool.
A frog perched on a leaf at the edge of the pool.
-wuppertaler, 2023, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Fifty Years of Coins

The Marchesa was right. Sydneysiders and visitors took to him straight away, and so did the children. He's raised more than $500,000 for the hospital in coins, according to the Sydney Morning Herald and South Eastern Sydney Local Health District at his fiftieth birthday in 2018. That's a lot of five- and ten-cent pieces. The hospital's own donation plaque says the money supports research, education and development.

The Fiaschi family has never forgotten him. They celebrated his twenty-first birthday in 1989 with a boar-shaped marzipan cake, and his fiftieth in December 2018, when about seventy of the Marchesa's descendants gathered at the hospital, some from Florence. It was organised by Thomas Fiaschi's great-great-grandson Jim Robertson, who remembered the 1989 cake: he'd been bitterly disappointed, aged three, when it turned out to be fruit cake inside. 'This time,' he promised, 'we're having tiramisu!'

The bronze boar facing Macquarie Street.
The bronze boar facing Macquarie Street.
David Stanley, 2016, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Looking After the Little Pig

Unlike his Florentine cousin, Sydney's boar has never been replaced; the bronze outside the hospital is the one that arrived in 1968. He belongs to the City of Sydney, which looks after him. In 1995 International Conservation Services prepared a full condition assessment for the council, with a heritage significance assessment by Godden Mackay, a structural report and even borescope pictures of his insides. In 1997 Sydney Artefacts Conservation, led by Anne Cummins, carried out a conservation treatment on the bronze boar and its sandstone base.

In 2016 International Conservation Services came back. The bronze had minor corrosion, worn patina and lost wax; the sandstone had delaminated in places and grown biological films; one of the four plaques had gone missing and the black lettering on the others had faded. The conservators cleaned the bronze, removed old wax, treated the corrosion and gave him a protective coating. They also cleaned and repointed the sandstone, and cleaned the plaques and re-filled their lettering. They didn't touch the golden snout. That's the public's work, and it's back as soon as the scaffolding comes down.

As of November 2026 he's still in his usual spot in front of Sydney Hospital, facing Macquarie Street and Martin Place, still collecting coins for the hospital, his nose still shining.

The Hospital Behind the Pig

The building behind him has a long story of its own, which I've told more fully in my post on Sydney Hospital – The Rum Hospital. In short: when Governor Macquarie couldn't get money from London for a proper hospital, he signed a contract on 6 November 1810 with Garnham Blaxcell, Alexander Riley and later D'Arcy Wentworth. They'd build it in return for convict labour, supplies and a monopoly on importing rum, which is how it became known as the Rum Hospital. Patients moved in in 1816. Its north wing is now Parliament House and its south wing the Sydney Mint.

The Sydney Infirmary, the former Rum Hospital, photographed by Charles Percy Pickering in 1870.
The Sydney Infirmary, the former Rum Hospital, photographed by Charles Percy Pickering in 1870.
Charles Percy Pickering, 1870, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Macquarie's old hospital building on Macquarie Street, about 1875, a few years before the central block came down.
Macquarie's old hospital building on Macquarie Street, about 1875, a few years before the central block came down.
Unknown photographer; State Library of NSW, SPF/177, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In March 1868 Lucy Osburn and five nurses trained by Florence Nightingale's school arrived to reform nursing at what was then the Sydney Infirmary. The Nightingale Wing was built for them, and that story is in my post on The Nightingale Wing. The worn-out central building was pulled down in 1879 and replaced by Thomas Rowe's sandstone hospital, completed in the 1890s, and the institution took the name Sydney Hospital in 1881. Today it's Sydney/Sydney Eye Hospital, part of South Eastern Sydney Local Health District and known especially for eye and hand surgery.

The Nightingale Wing, Lucy Osburn's nurses' home, about 1870.
The Nightingale Wing, Lucy Osburn's nurses' home, about 1870.
Walter Chaffer; State Library of NSW, SPF/178, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Fact and Tradition

Here's the boar's story at a glance, with the facts kept apart from the legends.

What the record shows

  • The ancient marble boar was in Florence by the 1560s and is now in the Uffizi.
  • Pietro Tacca (1577–1640) cast the bronze copy for the Medici around 1633. It has been a fountain at the Mercato Nuovo since at least 1640, was moved to the south side of the loggia in 1928, and was replaced by a Marinelli copy in 1998. The original is now in the Museo Bardini.
  • Sydney's boar was given by the Marchesa Clarissa Torrigiani (née Fiaschi, 1885–1975) in memory of her father, Dr Thomas Fiaschi (1853–1927), and her brother, Dr Piero Fiaschi (1879–1948). It was installed in 1968 and formally presented on 16 December 1968, according to the plaque.
  • His coins have raised more than $500,000 for Sydney Hospital.

Where the sources differ

  • When Tacca got the commission: 1612 (Italian sources, and the Sydney hospital and Herald) or 1621 (Haskell and Penny, citing Torriti). The Dictionary of Sydney's "since 1547" fits the building of the loggia, not the boar.
  • When the Florence copy arrived: cast in 1988 and installed in 1998 (FirenzeToday, Italian Wikipedia), or cast in 1998 and installed in 2008 (English Wikipedia).
  • When Sydney's boar was presented: 17 August 1968 (an SMH archive caption for an unveiling), 16 December 1968 (the plaque and Il Globo), or 16 December 1969 (the City of Sydney website).
  • When Thomas Fiaschi joined Sydney Hospital: 1890, 1894, or "30 years" before 1927, depending on the source.
  • Who Tom Yates was: the Marchesa's great-nephew (SMH) or her sister Camilla's son (Il Globo).
  • Who received the Florence coins: a children's charity, the Madonnina del Grappa ("a Florence orphanage" in 1968), or "a hospital in Florence" (City of Sydney).

Tradition

Rubbing the snout brings good luck, and in Florence it means you'll come back. A coin that falls through the grating grants your wish. Nobody has ever proved either, but you won't find many people who walk past without giving him a rub.

So next time you're on Macquarie Street, stop and say hello. Rub his nose, drop a coin in, and remember the Florentine surgeon, his soldier son and the determined old marchesa who saved for seven years to bring a little piece of Florence to Sydney Hospital.

Related Posts on My Australian History Journey

Sources

The Holey Dollar and the Dump – How Governor Macquarie Made Australia's First Coins – Sydney, 1813

Imagine a town of convicts, soldiers and settlers at the far end of the world, with almost no money. Your wages might come as a store receipt or a scrawled IOU, or as a bottle of spirits. The coins that did turn up came from half a dozen countries, and most of them sailed away again with the next merchant ship. That was Sydney for its first quarter-century. Out of that muddle came one of the strangest and best-loved coins ever made: a Spanish silver dollar with its heart punched out.

The outer ring became the holey dollar, worth five shillings. The little plug that fell out of the middle became the dump, worth fifteen pence. Governor Lachlan Macquarie ordered them. A convicted forger named William Henshall made them. They were the first coins ever produced in Australia, and today a single holey dollar can sell for hundreds of thousands of dollars. This is the story of how they came to be, how they were used and lost, and what they are worth now.

Governor Lachlan Macquarie, attributed to John Opie

Governor Lachlan Macquarie, attributed to John Opie. Macquarie governed New South Wales from 1810 to 1821 and ordered the making of the holey dollar and the dump.
Credit: Attributed to John Opie (1761–1807); State Library of New South Wales. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

A Colony Without Money

When the First Fleet sailed in 1787, no provision was made for a currency in the new settlement. The convicts were to be fed and clothed from the government stores. In practice the colony needed money from the very first years. Convicts who had served their time, small farmers, publicans and traders all had to buy and sell.

Whatever coin came in arrived in the pockets of convicts, soldiers, settlers and sailors. The Reserve Bank of Australia's museum lists the mixture: British coins alongside Dutch guilders and ducats, Indian gold mohurs and rupees, Portuguese "johannas", and above all the Spanish dollar, the great trading coin of the age. Much of it never stayed long. Every ship that brought in tea, sugar, cloth or spirits wanted to be paid in hard coin, so the colony's silver and gold kept draining away to the Cape, India, China and the Americas.

People made do. They bartered wheat for tools and meat for labour. The government stores paid farmers with receipts, which passed from hand to hand like banknotes. Merchants, publicans and even small settlers wrote their own promissory notes, some for as little as a few pence, and these "currency" notes changed hands for months. They were only as good as the person who signed them. And then there was rum, a word the colonists used for almost any spirits. With so little coin about, a bottle of spirits became one of the most trusted ways to pay for labour and goods.

Governor King's Table of 1800

Governor Philip Gidley King tried to bring some order to this. In 1800 a shipment of the big British "cartwheel" pennies arrived on HMS Porpoise. On 19 November 1800 King issued a proclamation making each one-ounce copper current for twopence. While he was at it, he published a table fixing the value of every coin legally circulating in the colony. These are the famous "Proclamation coins":

CoinValue in New South Wales
Guinea (British gold)£1 2s 0d
Johanna (Portuguese gold)£4 0s 0d
Half johanna£2 0s 0d
Ducat (Dutch gold)9s 6d
Gold mohur (India)£1 17s 6d
Pagoda (India)8s 0d
Spanish dollar5s 0d
Rupee2s 6d
Dutch guilder2s 0d
English shilling1s 1d
Copper coin of one ounce (cartwheel penny)2d

King hoped that fixed, official rates would steady local trade and discourage visiting traders from draining the colony of coin. It didn't work for long. Traders simply raised their prices, and the coins kept leaving.

Governor Philip Gidley King, about 1798

Governor Philip Gidley King, about 1798. His proclamation of 19 November 1800 set fixed values for the foreign coins passing in the colony.
Credit: Unknown artist, oil painting, State Library of New South Wales (ML 546). Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

A 1797 "cartwheel" penny of George III

A 1797 "cartwheel" penny of George III. A shipment of these one-ounce copper coins reached Sydney in 1800, and King's proclamation made each one current for twopence.
Credit: Coin by Conrad Heinrich Küchler; photograph by Петров Эдуард. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Rum, Paper and a Rebellion

Under Governors Hunter and King, officers of the New South Wales Corps controlled much of the trade in imported spirits, which is how the regiment earned the nickname "the Rum Corps". When Governor William Bligh arrived in 1806 he moved against both the spirits trade and the slippery paper money. Notices in the Sydney Gazette in November 1806 and January 1807 declared that "currency" meant money only, not barter in goods, and that promissory notes were to be drawn payable in sterling. The quarrels over spirits, trade and power ended with Bligh's arrest in the Rum Rebellion of 26 January 1808.

Macquarie arrived at the end of December 1809 and took office on 1 January 1810. He found the money problem worse than ever. By early 1813 the Sydney Gazette was reporting that paper "currency" stood at a discount of nearly fifty per cent against sterling, and that some dealers were demanding a difference of fifteen shillings in the pound. A farmer paid in local notes might find them worth half their face value when he went to buy.

View of Sydney from the east side of the cove, about 1810: the little town Macquarie inherited, short of everything, and above all short of money

View of Sydney from the east side of the cove, about 1810: the little town Macquarie inherited, short of everything, and above all short of money.
Credit: John Eyre. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The Treasure Ship of 1812

Macquarie asked London for coin, and this time help came. The British authorities arranged with the directors of the East India Company for £10,000 worth of Spanish dollars to be bought in India and shipped to New South Wales "on the Government account". At the official rate of five shillings a dollar, that meant 40,000 coins.

The coins came aboard HM sloop Samarang, which reached Sydney on 26 November 1812. The National Museum of Australia says she sailed from Madras (today's Chennai), while an 1870s account in the State Library's collection says she came from Bengal under a Captain Case. Two days later the Sydney Gazette reported her arrival "with treasure for the use of government".

On Saturday 5 December 1812, at ten in the morning, three officials met at Government House to open and count the treasure: William Broughton (acting commissary), Major H. C. Antill (major of brigade) and Thomas Archer (acting deputy commissary). Their signed report survives in the Colonial Secretary's correspondence, now held by Museums of History NSW. Thirteen of the fourteen boxes held 3,000 dollars each. Box No. 6 held 908¾. The total came to 39,908¾ dollars, a little short of the round 40,000 the shipment is usually given. The clerk spelt the ship's name "Tamarang".

Government House, Sydney, about 1809

Government House, Sydney, about 1809. On Saturday 5 December 1812 a committee met here to open, count and reseal the fourteen boxes of treasure landed from the Samarang.
Credit: John William Lewin (1770–1819), watercolour; National Library of Australia. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Why Cut the Coins?

Simply paying the dollars out as they were would not have helped for long. A whole Spanish dollar was good money anywhere in the world, so within months most of them would have sailed away like every shipment before. The coin came with instructions to keep it in the colony, and Macquarie's answer was to make it worth more inside New South Wales than outside.

The idea was not new. Cut and holed Spanish dollars had been used in other cash-starved British colonies, including Dominica in 1798 and Trinidad in 1811. In the very same year Macquarie's coins were made, Prince Edward Island in Canada punched the centres out of its own dollars for exactly the same reason. The National Museum thinks Macquarie probably knew of the West Indian coins.

The plan was simple. Punch a disc out of the middle of each dollar and stamp both pieces as New South Wales money. The ring would pass for five shillings, the same as a whole dollar, and the plug for fifteen pence. Together they were worth six shillings and threepence, 25 per cent more than the dollar they came from. The colony would have twice as many coins, and anyone who shipped them overseas would lose a quarter of their value.

William Henshall: The Forger Who Became Australia's First Mint Master

The man Macquarie chose for the job had come to Sydney for making money of a much less official kind. William Henshall had been a metal plater and cutler in England. According to the Perth Mint, he was convicted of counterfeiting "Bank of England dollars", the Spanish dollars Britain had restamped as five-shilling pieces during its own coin shortage. He was sentenced in 1805 to seven years' transportation.

Henshall struck a bargain. Numismatists Peter Lane and Peter Fleig found that he gave the authorities information about other forgers, and about ways of fighting the crime, in exchange for an assurance that his wife and family could follow him to New South Wales. He arrived in August 1806. On the 1811 muster he was listed simply as a "convict", with no trade given, so Macquarie probably learnt of his skill by reputation. On 12 September 1812, six months before his sentence was due to end, Henshall received an absolute pardon. Ten weeks later the Samarang sailed in with the silver.

A Bank of England dollar of 1804, George III side

A Bank of England dollar of 1804, George III side. These five-shilling dollars were struck over captured Spanish dollars. William Henshall had been convicted of counterfeiting "Bank of England dollars".
Credit: Photograph by Raimond Spekking. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The same Bank of England dollar, Britannia side

The same Bank of England dollar, Britannia side. Traces of the Spanish host coin can sometimes be seen beneath the British design, rather as they can on a holey dollar.
Credit: Photograph by Raimond Spekking. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Henshall was given a workshop in the basement of a government building called "the Factory", used by the government printer George Howe. It stood near the corner of Bridge and Loftus streets, on the eastern bank of the Tank Stream, beside the government lumber yard and its workshops. The National Museum calls it Australia's first mint, and Henshall its first mint master.

It was slow, frustrating work. Macquarie expected the conversion to take three months, but it took more than a year. Henshall had to build his own machinery, and Macquarie's reports say it was "defective" at first. It broke down several times, and about 90 dollars were spoiled. The counterstamps seem to have been struck with a drop hammer rather than a screw press. That explains why so many holey dollars show the lettering pressed harder on one side than the other, and why the stamps sit at all sorts of angles to the Spanish design.

Henshall also left his signature. A tiny letter H is hidden in the spray of leaves on the holey dollar's counterstamp, and on some dump dies another H sits between the words FIFTEEN and PENCE.

The first batch of finished coins went to the Deputy Commissary-General, David Allen, on 25 February 1814, and the last in August 1814. Records show 39,910 holey dollars and 39,910 dumps delivered. A few were sent to Britain as specimens, and the rest of the 40,000 are assumed to have been spoiled in the making. Henshall left the colony for England in 1817, and nobody knows what became of him.

Fish catch and Dawes Point, Sydney Harbour, painted by John Lewin about 1813, the year Henshall was at work on the coins

Fish catch and Dawes Point, Sydney Harbour, painted by John Lewin about 1813, the year Henshall was at work on the coins.
Credit: John William Lewin (1770–1819); Google Art Project. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

What the Old Colonists Said: Tradition, Not Proof

In the 1870s the collectors A. F. Basset Hull and D. W. E. Roth gathered memories from old colonists. One, a Mr Parker of Granville, said he had owned the original punch used to cut out the centres, which he described as a small, very primitive hand-lever press. He thought the inscriptions were struck with a drop hammer or even an ordinary sledgehammer. Another old colonist, a Mr Stillworthy of Wagga, said his old master, a Sydney and Hawkesbury blacksmith named Harry Richardson, had made the punch. These are second-hand recollections written down sixty years later. They are charming, but no document from 1813 confirms them, and the punch itself has never been found.

What the Coins Look Like

Macquarie's proclamation described the new coins precisely. The holey dollar carries two stamps around the inner edge of the hole:

  • On one side, NEW SOUTH WALES around the top of the hole and 1813 at the bottom.
  • On the other side, FIVE SHILLINGS around the top and a branch of laurel at the bottom.
  • The inner edge of the hole is grained (milled) on both sides.

The dump carries:

  • On one side, a crown, with NEW SOUTH WALES above it and 1813 beneath.
  • On the other side, the words FIFTEEN PENCE.
  • A grained edge.

Everything else on a holey dollar is Spanish: the king's portrait and titles on one side, the royal arms and pillars on the other, and the original date and mint mark around the rim. Henshall did not care which way up he struck. On some coins NEW SOUTH WALES sits over the king's head, and on others over the Spanish arms.

The dump was struck so hard that it spread out slightly. The 1870s researchers noticed that a genuine dump will no longer fit back into the hole it came from. The best dumps still show faint traces of the Spanish design underneath, called the "undertype", and collectors prize them.

A holey dollar cut from a Mexico City Spanish dollar of 1773

A holey dollar cut from a Mexico City Spanish dollar of 1773. On this side Henshall's counterstamp reads NEW SOUTH WALES above the hole and 1813 below it, struck over the Spanish royal arms.
Credit: Coin: Colonial Government of New South Wales; State Library of New South Wales, Sir William Dixson Numismatic Collection (SAFE/R 277a). Licence: CC BY-SA 3.0 AU. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The other side of the same coin: FIVE SHILLINGS above the hole and a sprig of laurel below, struck around the portrait of King Charles III

The other side of the same coin: FIVE SHILLINGS above the hole and a sprig of laurel below, struck around the portrait of King Charles III. The date 1773 on the rim belongs to the original Spanish coin.
Credit: Coin: Colonial Government of New South Wales; State Library of New South Wales, Sir William Dixson Numismatic Collection (SAFE/R 277a). Licence: CC BY-SA 3.0 AU. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The dump, the little silver plug punched out of the centre: a crown, with NEW SOUTH WALES above it and 1813 below

The dump, the little silver plug punched out of the centre: a crown, with NEW SOUTH WALES above it and 1813 below.
Credit: Coin: Colonial Government of New South Wales; State Library of New South Wales. Licence: CC BY-SA 3.0 AU. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The other side of the dump: FIFTEEN PENCE

The other side of the dump: FIFTEEN PENCE. Collectors prize dumps that still show faint lines from the centre of the Spanish dollar underneath.
Credit: Coin: Colonial Government of New South Wales; State Library of New South Wales. Licence: CC BY-SA 3.0 AU. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Dies and Varieties

Henshall's tools wore out and broke, so several sets of dies were cut. On the holey dollar, the main difference is on the FIVE SHILLINGS side. One die has a dagger-shaped stop between the words, and the other has no stop and sets the words closer together. Coinworks divides the dumps into four die pairs, known as A/1, D/2, C/4 and E/3. By its estimate at least 500 A/1 dumps are in private hands, about 200 D/2, about 15 E/3 and fewer than ten C/4. The E/3 and C/4 dumps are so crude that they are thought to be trial strikes, made before Macquarie approved a design.

The Proclamation of 1 July 1813

Macquarie made the coins legal by a proclamation dated 1 July 1813. It first appeared in the Sydney Gazette of 3 July 1813 and was printed again in later issues, including 10 July and 31 July. It explained that "it has been deemed expedient to send a Quantity of Dollars to this Colony, for the purpose of assisting and improving the circulating Medium thereof". It also announced that "a small circular Piece of Silver shall be struck out of the centre of every such Dollar". The dump was to pass for "Fifteen Pence" and the ring for "Five Shillings", both "of lawful Money of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland".

The new money was to come into use on 30 September 1813. From that date the government would pay out and accept the coins at those rates, and they would be legal tender for debts to the government and between private people. The proclamation also:

  • punished anyone who counterfeited or clipped the new coins, or passed counterfeits;
  • required every jeweller and goldsmith to enter a bond of £100, with two sureties of £50 each, not to forge, counterfeit or reduce the coins;
  • made it an offence to export the coins (Coinworks notes that ships' masters had to enter a £200 bond not to carry them away);
  • banned promissory notes for less than two shillings and sixpence;
  • limited copper coin to fifteen pence in any one payment.

As the government's own paper, the Gazette welcomed the scheme. It said the new silver would "immediately alleviate the difficulties under which the Colony [has] long been labouring for the want of an ostensible medium". It also predicted that the "fifteen-penny silver pieces" would put an end to the little paper notes for small sums.

Because of Henshall's troubles with his machinery, the coins dated 1813 did not reach the public until 1814. Museums of History NSW says general issue began in January 1814, and the National Museum dates the first delivery of finished coins to 25 February 1814.

The first issue of the Sydney Gazette, 5 March 1803

The first issue of the Sydney Gazette, 5 March 1803. Ten years later the Gazette printed Macquarie's proclamation of 1 July 1813 that made the holey dollar and the dump legal money.
Credit: Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser; State Library of New South Wales. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

A holey dollar made from a 1783 Spanish dollar of Charles III, with NEW SOUTH WALES and 1813 around the hole

A holey dollar made from a 1783 Spanish dollar of Charles III, with NEW SOUTH WALES and 1813 around the hole. Stamped in 1813, it went into circulation in 1814.
Credit: Coin: Administration of New South Wales; State Library of New South Wales (SAFE/DN/C 455). Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The reverse of the same 1783 holey dollar, with FIVE SHILLINGS around the hole inside the pillars and arms of Spain

The reverse of the same 1783 holey dollar, with FIVE SHILLINGS around the hole inside the pillars and arms of Spain.
Credit: Coin: Administration of New South Wales; State Library of New South Wales (SAFE/DN/C 455). Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Living with the Holey Dollar

So what was a holey dollar worth to the people who used it? Coinworks, drawing on prices in the Sydney Gazette, says five shillings would buy a bottle of rum, a bushel of maize or a pound of green tea. The fifteen-penny dump was the coin for everyday shopping.

The colonists were not won over. The 1870s researchers concluded that people were naturally reluctant to take a dollar that had seldom been worth more than five shillings as worth six shillings and threepence, just because it had been cut in two and stamped. The coins went by several names. "Holey dollar" and "dump" were the popular ones, but people also called the ring the "ring dollar", the "colonial dollar" or the "government dollar".

William Charles Wentworth, writing in 1819–20, praised Macquarie's intentions but thought the scheme had largely failed. The coins were paid out for produce taken into the King's stores, he said, but most were soon swept up by merchants and traders. Only a few, "in consequence of the minuteness of their separate value", got into everyday circulation. The use of paper money "has neither been superceded nor diminished".

View of Sydney by John Lewin, used as the frontispiece to William Charles Wentworth's description of the colony

View of Sydney by John Lewin, used as the frontispiece to William Charles Wentworth's description of the colony. Wentworth wrote that the new silver had not managed to drive out the colony's paper money.
Credit: J. W. Lewin; State Library of New South Wales (RB/E994.4/WEN). Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The Bank of New South Wales opened in 1817, in premises in Macquarie Place leased from the former convict and businesswoman Mary Reibey. It soon became the great store of the colony's holey dollars. Coinworks cites bank records showing that in 1820 the bank held 16,680 holey dollars but only 5,900 dumps. The figures suggest the big five-shilling rings mostly sat in the vault as backing for the bank's notes, while the little dumps were out in pockets and tills, wearing smooth. That is why so many surviving dumps are badly worn.

Forgers at Work

A coin worth 25 per cent more than its silver was bound to tempt forgers. On 2 January 1819 the Sydney Gazette reported forged five-shilling bank notes and counterfeit Spanish and ring dollars. On 5 May 1819 the secretary of the Bank of New South Wales warned the public about four kinds of fake:

  • dollars and dumps that were not silver at all;
  • holed dollars without the colonial stamp;
  • genuine holey dollars with silver filed or chipped from around the hole, making it larger;
  • dollars with a counterfeit stamp around the hole. Many of these could be spotted because the forger had cut the date backwards, as 3181.

Basset Hull later recorded a copper dump that had once been silver-plated, and a ring dollar cast in pewter.

A holey dollar made from a Spanish dollar minted in 1798

A holey dollar made from a Spanish dollar minted in 1798. Each holey dollar combines a different Spanish date, king and mint with Henshall's Sydney counterstamps, so no two are quite alike.
Credit: State Library of New South Wales (SAFE/DN/C 470). Licence: No known copyright restrictions. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Government gaol gang, Sydney, by Augustus Earle, about 1830

Government gaol gang, Sydney, by Augustus Earle, about 1830. Sydney still ran largely on convict labour when the holey dollar was recalled.
Credit: Augustus Earle; State Library of New South Wales. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Recall, Melting and the Coming of Sterling

Macquarie left in 1821. His successor, Sir Thomas Brisbane, decided the coins' inflated value had to go. A proclamation dated 25 July 1822, printed in the Sydney Gazette the next day and in the Hobart Town Gazette on 10 August, gave holders six weeks to hand in their holey dollars to His Majesty's stores at the full five shillings. After that a holey dollar would pass for only three-quarters of a Spanish dollar.

The dumps followed. A government notice in the Sydney Gazette of 15 November 1822 offered to exchange them at one shilling and threepence each for Treasury bills or sterling. A later notice fixed 16 December 1822 as the final day.

Even then the coins did not vanish at once. They kept passing at their silver value for years in both New South Wales and Van Diemen's Land. In 1825 a British Order-in-Council set out to make English money the only currency of the colony. Laws passed in 1826 required accounts and contracts to be written in pounds, shillings and pence, and banned notes for less than twenty shillings. The holey dollar and dump were finally demonetised in 1829. Coinworks says the recalled coins were shipped to the Royal Mint in London, melted down and sold to the Bank of England as bullion for £5,044.

The Royal Australian Mint points out an odd distinction. Australia's other old coins, including pre-decimal money and the 1 and 2 cent pieces, technically remain legal tender. The holey dollar and dump are the only Australian coins ever to have been formally demonetised.

Sir Thomas Brisbane, governor from 1821 to 1825

Sir Thomas Brisbane, governor from 1821 to 1825. His proclamation of 25 July 1822 began the recall of Macquarie's coins.
Credit: E. E. Friedrich T. Schenck, 1850; Museum of Brisbane. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Why "Holy"? The Name and Its Explanations

You'll see the coin spelt both ways, "holey dollar" and "holy dollar", so it's worth separating fact from fancy.

What the records show. The proclamations never used either word. Official papers talk of dollars "with a small circular piece of silver struck out of the centre", and of "colonial", "ring" or "pierced" dollars. Coinworks notes that "holey" was no doubt used from the start, but the term "holey dollar" did not appear in print until the 1820s. "Dump", on the other hand, was the official name for the centre piece from the beginning.

Explanation 1: it's simply the hole. The plainest explanation is that it was a dollar with a hole in it, a holey dollar, just as a sock with holes is holey. Most modern museums and mints spell it that way.

Explanation 2: a pun. Edward Morris's Austral English dictionary of 1898 lists the coin under "Holy dollar" and calls it a "punning name". Nineteenth-century writers often spelt it "holy". In 1857 Daniel Bunce remembered arriving in Van Diemen's Land in 1833 and getting change for a pound in "two dumps, two holy dollars, one Spanish dollar, one French coin, one half-crown, one shilling, and one sixpence".

What is not supported. No contemporary source gives the name any religious meaning. Despite the spelling, nothing connects the coin with the church, a blessing or a saint. "Holy dollar" is best read as an old spelling of, and a pun on, "holey".

Survivors: How Many Are Left?

Almost all of the nearly 80,000 coins went into the melting pot. The ones that escaped were mostly held by people who could afford to keep a demonetised coin: wealthy colonists, banks and companies. Experts disagree a little on how many are left:

  • Holey dollars: about 300, according to the National Museum of Australia, Coinworks and the Royal Australian Mint (2026). The standard reference by Mira and Noble (1989) estimated about 350. Coinworks reckons about a third of them are in public institutions and about 200 in private hands.
  • Dumps: estimates range from about 800 (Perth Mint, 2013) and "just over 1,000" (National Museum) to about 1,500 (Mira and Noble).

Every so often one turns up in an unexpected place. In 1881 a group of holey dollars was found in Tasmania, in what was believed to be a bushranger's hoard, though the bushranger part is tradition rather than proven fact. One of them, the "Hannibal Head", was presented to the Governor of Van Diemen's Land, Sir John Henry Lefroy. The Royal Australian Mint's chief executive has said that one was found near the Blue Mountains in 1939. Another was found on the banks of the Shoalhaven River in 1995 and later sold for $60,000. The Mint's collections manager tells of one found in an old Hills Hoist clothes line. "Every time the clothes line went around it shaved about a thousand dollars of value off it," she said.

You can see holey dollars in public collections:

  • the State Library of New South Wales (the Mitchell and Dixson collections);
  • the National Museum of Australia in Canberra;
  • the Royal Australian Mint, which bought its third holey dollar in 2025;
  • the British Museum.

The Macquarie Group has its own collection. In 2013 it staged a free exhibition at 1 Martin Place of 13 of the most important holey dollars, with a combined estimated value of $7.3 million. The Reserve Bank of Australia's museum in Martin Place tells the holey dollar story in its "Currency Chaos" displays, but the museum is currently closed while the Reserve Bank building is refurbished.

The National Museum of Australia's holey dollar, struck on a 1796 Spanish dollar of Charles IV (CAROLUS IIII), with NEW SOUTH WALES 1813 around the hole

The National Museum of Australia's holey dollar, struck on a 1796 Spanish dollar of Charles IV (CAROLUS IIII), with NEW SOUTH WALES 1813 around the hole. The museum says its host coin came from the Potosí mint, one of only five Potosí holey dollars known.
Credit: Photograph by Deon Rohmursanto, National Museum of Australia. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The other side of the National Museum's holey dollar, with FIVE SHILLINGS around the hole

The other side of the National Museum's holey dollar, with FIVE SHILLINGS around the hole. The museum bought it at auction in 2011 for $130,000.
Credit: Photograph by Deon Rohmursanto, National Museum of Australia. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

A holey dollar in the British Museum, struck on a Spanish dollar dated 1803

A holey dollar in the British Museum, struck on a Spanish dollar dated 1803.
Credit: Photograph by Mike Peel (www.mikepeel.net). Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Host Coins: Every Holey Dollar Is Different

Macquarie's order for 40,000 dollars didn't specify dates, kings or mints, and he wasn't fussy about condition. The shipment that came from India was a cross-section of Spanish silver from around the world. Each holey dollar is therefore one coin stamped on top of another, and no two are quite the same. Collectors look at four things.

The mint. Coinworks says that between 1790 and 1812 the Mexico City mint alone produced 24 million dollars, so most surviving holey dollars are on Mexican host coins. Others come from Lima (Peru), Potosí (in today's Bolivia), Santiago (Chile), Santa Fe de Bogotá (Colombia), Guatemala, and the mints of Madrid and Seville in Spain itself. Lane and Fleig count only five holey dollars from Potosí, including the National Museum's coin. Only six are known on dollars struck in Spain. Five of these are in institutions: the State Library of NSW, the National Gallery of Victoria, Yale University and Sydney's old Mint and Barracks Museum. The sixth is the privately owned "Madrid Holey Dollar", made from a coin struck at Madrid in 1802.

The king. Most host coins show Charles III (king from 1759 to 1788) or Charles IV, whose coins spell his name CAROLUS IIII. Some show Ferdinand VII. The oldest known host is a 1757 dollar of Ferdinand VI. Because news and new dies took time to reach the colonial mints, some Mexico City dollars struck in 1789, after Charles III had died, still carry his portrait and name. Coinworks sold a unique holey dollar of that kind in 2025.

The story coins. The most famous is the Hannibal Head. Its host is an 1810 dollar from Lima, struck during the years Napoleon's brother Joseph Bonaparte claimed the Spanish throne, with a crude, unflattering portrait that Coinworks and other writers identify as Joseph, and that collectors nicknamed the "Hannibal head". It is the only holey dollar known with that portrait. Another favourite was struck on a 1788 Spanish dollar, the year the colony was founded. By chance, NEW SOUTH WALES, 1813 and 1788 line up vertically on it. About seven known holey dollars also carry the private countermark "T. KNIGHT".

Condition. Collectors grade the Spanish coin and Henshall's counterstamps separately, because a well-worn host can carry sharp counterstamps, or the other way round.

A Mexico City "pillar" dollar of Charles III, 1771, showing the two Pillars of Hercules over the waves

A Mexico City "pillar" dollar of Charles III, 1771, showing the two Pillars of Hercules over the waves. Holey dollars were made from this older design as well as from the later portrait dollars.
Credit: Kingdom of Spain, Mexico City mint; image Heritage Auctions. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

A Spanish dollar struck at Lima, Peru, in 1791

A Spanish dollar struck at Lima, Peru, in 1791. Holey dollars on Lima host coins are scarce. The small hole near the rim of this coin was made by a later owner, not by Henshall.
Credit: Missouri History Museum. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Both sides of a Spanish dollar struck at Potosí (in today's Bolivia) in 1798, in the name of Charles IV

Both sides of a Spanish dollar struck at Potosí (in today's Bolivia) in 1798, in the name of Charles IV. Potosí holey dollars are among the rarest.
Credit: Numismática Pliego. Licence: CC BY-SA 3.0. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Forgeries, Replicas and How to Spot Them

Because genuine holey dollars are so valuable, copies are common. They fall into three groups.

Period counterfeits. These are the fakes the Bank of New South Wales warned about in 1819: base-metal or plated coins, unstamped holed dollars, enlarged holes and false counterstamps.

Later forgeries. A well-known group, called "Manila forgeries" in the Mira–Noble reference, puts imitation counterstamps on genuine Spanish dollars. Some even carry host dates later than 1813, which is impossible for a real holey dollar.

Replicas and souvenirs. Replicas made by Becker for the Western Australian firm Varne in the 1970s are cast from genuine coins. Others include the Mail Coach Medallion Company's Royal Visit pieces and a 1986 Port Macquarie anniversary replica sponsored by Westpac. These turn up regularly at auction and are fine as souvenirs, as long as they are sold as what they are.

A few common-sense checks help:

  • Check the host date. Every genuine holey dollar is made from a Spanish dollar dated before 1813. Most are from the 1770s to the 1800s, and the oldest known is 1757.
  • Look at the surface. Cast copies often show soft, grainy detail, tiny bubbles or a seam on the edge. Genuine coins show a sharp struck design, often with Henshall's counterstamp pressed unevenly, and a grained inner edge to the hole.
  • Look for the H. On many genuine coins Henshall's tiny H can be seen in the laurel spray.
  • Try the dump in the hole. If a "matching" dump slips neatly back into its holey dollar, be suspicious. Genuine dumps spread slightly when they were struck.
  • Ask for provenance and a die identification. Serious dealers and auction houses describe coins by their Mira–Noble number and die pair (for example "dies A/1" for a dump), and many good coins have a traceable ownership history. Coins certified by grading services such as PCGS or NGC add another layer of checking.
  • Buy from established firms. If a price looks too good for a holey dollar, it almost certainly is.

The Holey Dollar's Legacy

Macquarie's improvised coins have become a national symbol. In 1985, when Hill Samuel Australia became a bank, it took the name Macquarie Bank after the governor. It adopted a logo inspired by the holey dollar, a black ring that is still the Macquarie Group's emblem.

The mints have returned to the design again and again:

  • 1988: in the Bicentennial year, the Perth Mint issued a legal-tender holey dollar and dump in pure silver, a 1-ounce $1 ring and a ¼-ounce 25-cent dump, with a mintage of 100,000 sets.
  • 2013: for the 200th anniversary, the Perth Mint released a two-coin silver proof set limited to 4,000. A three-coin Australia–Spain silver set, with a Spanish 10 euro "8 reales" coin alongside a silver holey dollar and dump, was limited to 5,000.
  • 2026: in September the Royal Australian Mint released the "Origins of Australian Coin" $1 Holey Dollar uncirculated coin, limited to 35,000, to mark 60 years of diplomatic relations between Australia and Mexico. Its design shows the Mint's own 1804/1813 holey dollar, made from a Mexico City dollar. At the launch the Mexican ambassador traced how Mexican silver travelled on the Manila galleons from Acapulco to the Philippines, then to Madras, and finally to Sydney.

There is a Macquarie Street footnote too. In 1855 Sydney finally got a real mint, a branch of the Royal Mint, housed in the south wing of Macquarie's Rum Hospital. Macquarie had that hospital built in exchange for a monopoly on imported spirits. So the building that rum paid for became the place where Australian gold sovereigns were struck, a few hundred metres from the Tank Stream basement where Henshall had punched his dollars four decades earlier.

Holey dollars and dumps on display at the Royal Australian Mint, Canberra, in 2022

Holey dollars and dumps on display at the Royal Australian Mint, Canberra, in 2022. The Mint now holds three original holey dollars.
Credit: Photograph by Kgbo. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Lachlan Macquarie by Richard Read, 1822, painted just after he left office

Lachlan Macquarie by Richard Read, 1822, painted just after he left office. The Macquarie Group took his name in 1985 and uses a holey dollar as its logo.
Credit: Richard Read; State Library of New South Wales. Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Macquarie Street in 1842, painted by John Rae: Hyde Park, St James' Parsonage, the dispensary that afterwards became the Sydney Mint, and the convict barracks

Macquarie Street in 1842, painted by John Rae: Hyde Park, St James' Parsonage, the dispensary that afterwards became the Sydney Mint, and the convict barracks.
Credit: John Rae; State Library of New South Wales (DG SV*/Sp Coll/Rae/16). Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The Sydney branch of the Royal Mint on Macquarie Street, 1870

The Sydney branch of the Royal Mint on Macquarie Street, 1870. It was housed in the south wing of Macquarie's Rum Hospital and opened in 1855, four decades after Henshall's improvised workshop.
Credit: Attributed to Charles Pickering; State Library of New South Wales (SPF/320). Licence: Public domain. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Prices: From Five Shillings to Half a Million Dollars

In 1813 a holey dollar was worth five shillings. Two centuries later the market looks like this. All prices are in Australian dollars unless stated. A "hammer" price is the winning bid at auction, before the buyer's premium is added. A "dealer" price is a fixed retail price at which a coin was sold.

Historic Prices

In 1974 a superb holey dollar with a Macquarie family provenance sold privately to the collector Ken Wilson for $2,200. Jim Noble says he sold another to a client in 1981 for $22,000. The Hannibal Head was offered at a Spink auction in 1988 with a $45,000 estimate and is thought to have changed hands privately afterwards for about $40,500. Coinworks bought it in 2007 for $260,000.

The Record-Breakers

  • December 2011: the National Museum of Australia paid $130,000 at auction for its Potosí holey dollar.
  • 2011: Coinworks sold a superb holey dollar for $485,000.
  • August 2012: the Hannibal Head sold for $410,000 at Coinworks' "Eminent Colonials" auction in Melbourne, then an auction record. At the same sale an extremely fine dump made $100,000.
  • March 2013: a Western Australian collector paid $495,000 through Coinworks.
  • April–May 2015: the Madrid Holey Dollar, the only privately owned holey dollar on a dollar from a Spanish mint, sold through Coinworks to a Queensland collector for $550,000 after being offered at $600,000. This is the highest price reported for a holey dollar.
  • July 2015: at Noble Numismatics' Sale 109 in Sydney, the Macquarie-provenance coin Ken Wilson had bought for $2,200 fetched a hammer price of $400,000, or $477,000 with buyer's premium. That made it a world auction record for a holey dollar.
  • July 2018: Coinworks sold the Hannibal Head again, to a private collector, for $500,000.
  • Before August 2024: a holey dollar stolen from a museum in Toruń, Poland, made from a 1777 Mexico City dollar, sold at a Melbourne auction to a Perth collector for $525,000. The Australian Federal Police seized it in August 2024 and it was returned to Poland in February 2025. Nobody in Australia faced charges, because every buyer had acted in good faith.

Recent Sales, 2023 to 2026

Over the past three years, ordinary well-circulated to very fine holey dollars have mostly sold for between about $55,000 and $160,000:

  • November 2023: Noble Sale 134, a nearly very fine to very fine coin on an 1806 Mexico City host, hammer $130,000 against a $120,000 estimate. Yahoo Finance reported a total of $150,600 with premium.
  • April 2024: Noble Sale 135, a very fine coin on a 1799 Mexico host, hammer $109,000, or $132,980 with buyer's premium and GST. A "T. KNIGHT" countermarked coin made $37,000 hammer, or $45,140 with premium.
  • May 2025: Coinworks sold the unique 1789 Mexico coin with the Charles III portrait, ex-Philip Spalding collection, for $145,000.
  • July 2025: Noble Sale 139, a good very fine coin on an 1804 Mexico City host, hammer $160,000, after failing to sell at $200,000 and $150,000 estimates in 2024 and early 2025. In 2026 the Royal Australian Mint said it had paid $160,000 at auction for its 1804 holey dollar, and the host date and price match.
  • August 2026: Drake Sterling sold the most heavily worn holey dollar ever certified by PCGS (Fair 2), listed at $55,000.
  • September 2026: Coinworks sold a well-matched holey dollar and dump pair, presented in a case of Australian timbers, for $85,000.
  • Coming up, 23–27 November 2026: Noble Sale 143 in Sydney offers a holey dollar on a 1799 Mexico City host, described as one of the top twenty known, estimated at $200,000.

Not every coin sells. A very fine 1793 Mexico City coin was passed in at Noble's sales of November 2024 (estimate $150,000) and November 2025 (estimate $120,000).

Dumps, Replicas and Modern Commemoratives

Dumps are far cheaper than holey dollars, but fine examples are rarer than their rings. Recent Noble hammer prices:

  • About $3,800 to $5,500 for worn coins (very good to fine);
  • About $8,600 to $11,500 for fine to nearly very fine coins;
  • About $14,500 to $18,500 for nearly very fine to very fine coins.

Many very fine dumps estimated at $12,000 to $35,000 were passed in. Exceptional dumps are a different matter: the extremely fine dump in the 2012 Coinworks auction made $100,000.

Replicas usually make a few hundred dollars, though a group of six Becker and Varne replicas made $2,600 in 2025. The 1988 Perth Mint silver holey dollar and dump set is listed by dealers at about $195. The 2013 sets cost about $108 to $119 when issued and are now listed at around $150 to $300. The 2026 Royal Australian Mint $1 coin was issued at $35.

Full details, dates and links for every price are in the table at the end of this page.

More on My Australian History Journey

Sources

  • National Museum of Australia, "Holey dollar" (collection highlights): nma.gov.au
  • National Museum of Australia, Defining Moments, "Holey dollar" (updated 20 February 2026): nma.gov.au
  • National Museum of Australia, "Holey dollar and dump: Macquarie Bank": nma.gov.au
  • Museums of History NSW, "Holey dollar & dump coins, 1813" (On this day, 30 September 1813), with transcript of the treasure committee's report of 5 December 1812: mhnsw.au
  • State Library of New South Wales, "Australia's first unique coins: holey dollar and the dump": sl.nsw.gov.au
  • State Library of New South Wales, A. F. Basset Hull, notes on colonial currency, c. 1873 (B 444), transcript: sl.nsw.gov.au
  • Reserve Bank of Australia Museum, "Crisis in the Colony of New South Wales" (Pocket Guide): museum.rba.gov.au; Permanent exhibition labels, "Currency Chaos": PDF; Collection Spotlight (museum closure notice): museum.rba.gov.au
  • Australian Bureau of Statistics, Year Book Australia 1965, "Pre-Federation coinage" (texts of the 1800 and 1813 proclamations): abs.gov.au
  • Downies, "The Currency Proclamation of 1800" (4 July 2024): downies.com
  • Royal Australian Mint, "New Holey Dollar coin brings to life the extraordinary story of Australia's first currency" (3 September 2026): ramint.gov.au; "Origins of Australian Coin: the Holey Dollar" (18 August 2026): ramint.gov.au
  • Canberra Daily, "True tale of convicts and counterfeit" (3 September 2026): canberradaily.com.au
  • The Canberra Times, "Australia's oldest coins on display at Royal Australian Mint" (16 August 2019): canberratimes.com.au
  • The Perth Mint, "Incredible facts about the holey dollar and dump" (3 January 2013): perthmint.com; "Australia's first mint operated in the early 1800s" (7 May 2012): perthmint.com; 1988 numismatic mintages: PDF
  • Coinworks, "1813 Holey Dollar and Dump" (history booklet): coinworks.com.au
  • Macquarie Group, "History": macquarie.com
  • James Cockington, "Holey sound decisions", Sydney Morning Herald, 25 September 2013: smh.com.au
  • Edward E. Morris, Austral English (1898), "Holy dollar": archli.com
  • Fellowship of First Fleeters, "Words of Early Colonials – Part 2" (16 February 2025): fellowshipfirstfleeters.org
  • Wikipedia, "Holey dollar" (for the Sydney Gazette citations of 28 November 1812 and 10 July 1813, and Prince Edward Island): en.wikipedia.org; "Hannibal Head Holey Dollar": en.wikipedia.org
  • Australian Federal Police, "AFP helps return stolen 1800s coin worth $525,000 to Poland" (17 February 2025): afp.gov.au; The Canberra Times, 18 February 2025: canberratimes.com.au
  • Auction and dealer records as listed in the price table below (Noble Numismatics, Coinworks, Drake Sterling, Numismatic News, ABC News, Sterling & Currency, SMH, Yahoo Finance, CoinNews, The E-Sylum, Wynyard Coin Centre, Coins Australia, Town Hall Coins).
  • Pictures: Wikimedia Commons and the collections credited in each caption.

Price Table: Holey Dollars, Dumps and Commemoratives

All prices are in Australian dollars. Hammer = winning bid before buyer's premium. With premium = total paid including buyer's premium (and GST where stated). Dealer = fixed retail price at which the coin sold. Asking = current or recent listed price, not a sale. Estimate = auction house guide only.

DateItemPrice (AUD)Type of price / sellerSource
1974Holey dollar, Macquarie family provenance (1792 Mexico host)$2,200Private sale (Bill Barrett to Ken Wilson)Numismatic News, 17 Aug 2015
1981Holey dollar later sold in Noble Sale 134$22,000Private sale by Jim NobleYahoo Finance, 21 Nov 2023
1988Hannibal Head holey dollar (1810 Lima host)$45,000 estimate; thought to have sold privately for about $40,500Spink auction (estimate) / private sale (reported)SMH, 25 Sep 2013
2007Hannibal Head holey dollar$260,000Purchase by CoinworksSMH, 25 Sep 2013
2011Superb holey dollar$485,000Dealer (Coinworks)SMH, 25 Sep 2013
Dec 2011Holey dollar, Potosí host (now National Museum of Australia)$130,000Auction (price paid by NMA, as reported)ABC News, 14 Dec 2011
Aug 2012Hannibal Head holey dollar (1810 Lima host), nearly extremely fine$410,000 (estimate $450,000); auction record at the timeAuction, Coinworks Eminent Colonials, Melbourne (reported sale price)ABC News, 27 Aug 2012; Sterling & Currency, 31 Aug 2012
Aug 20121813 dump, ex Lingford, extremely fine$100,000 (estimate $200,000)Auction, Coinworks Eminent Colonials (reported sale price)Sterling & Currency, 31 Aug 2012
Mar 2013Holey dollar bought by a WA collector$495,000Dealer (Coinworks)SMH, 25 Sep 2013
Apr–May 2015Madrid Holey Dollar (1802 Madrid host), good extremely fine$550,000 (asking $600,000); highest reported price for a holey dollarDealer, expressions of interest (Coinworks)Coinworks; SMH, 5 May 2015
Jul 2015Holey dollar, Macquarie provenance (1792 Mexico host), as struck$400,000 hammer; $477,000 with premium; world auction recordAuction, Noble Numismatics Sale 109, SydneyNumismatic News, 17 Aug 2015
Jul 2018Hannibal Head holey dollar$500,000Dealer (Coinworks)Coinworks
Sep 2018Holey dollar, 1793 Mexico host, fair$49,500Dealer (Coinworks)Coinworks
Before Aug 2024 (date not given)Holey dollar stolen from Toruń museum (1777 Mexico host); seized 26 Aug 2024, returned to Poland Feb 2025$525,000Auction, Melbourne (as reported by AFP)AFP, 17 Feb 2025
Nov 2023Holey dollar, 1806 Mexico host, nearly VF/VF (lot 1282)$130,000 hammer (estimate $120,000); reported $150,600 with premiumAuction, Noble Sale 134Noble; Yahoo Finance
Nov 2023Dump, dies A/1, nearly VF (lot 1283)$18,500 hammerAuction, Noble Sale 134Noble
Apr 2024Holey dollar, 1799 Mexico host, VF (lot 1791)$109,000 hammer; $132,980 with premium and GSTAuction, Noble Sale 135Noble catalogue; Noble sale report, 28 Apr 2024
Apr 2024Holey dollar countermarked T. KNIGHT, 1805 Mexico host, very good (lot 1792)$37,000 hammer; $45,140 with premiumAuction, Noble Sale 135Noble sale report
Apr 2024Dump, dies D/2, nearly VF (lot 1794)$14,500 hammer; $17,690 with premiumAuction, Noble Sale 135Noble sale report
Apr 2024Dump, dies A/1, very good (lot 1795)$3,800 hammer; $4,636 with premiumAuction, Noble Sale 135Noble sale report
Jul 2024Dump, dies A/1, fine (lot 1440)$8,600 hammerAuction, Noble Sale 136Noble
Jul 2024Replica holey dollars (3), incl. 1988 Perth Mint set$180 hammerAuction, Noble Sale 136Noble
Nov 2024Replicas by Becker for Varne (3)$600 hammerAuction, Noble Sale 137Noble
May 2025Unique holey dollar on 1789 Mexico host with Charles III portrait, good fine$145,000Dealer (Coinworks)Coinworks
Jul 2025Holey dollar, 1804 Mexico host, good VF (lot 1597); passed in at $200,000 (Jul 2024) and $150,000 (Mar 2025) estimates$160,000 hammer (estimate $150,000)Auction, Noble Sale 139Noble; RAM purchase: Canberra Daily, 3 Sep 2026
Jul 2025Dump, dies A/1, VF+ (lot 1598)$18,000 hammerAuction, Noble Sale 139Noble
Nov 2025Holey dollar, 1793 Mexico host, VF (lot 843)Passed in (estimate $120,000; also passed in Nov 2024 at $150,000)Auction, Noble Sales 137 and 140Noble
Nov 2025Dumps: VF+ / nearly VF / D/2 good fine (lots 844–846)$16,000 / $11,500 / $5,500 hammerAuction, Noble Sale 140Noble
Nov 2025Becker and Varne replicas (6)$2,600 hammerAuction, Noble Sale 140Noble
Apr 2026Dumps, VF (lots 598–599)Passed in (estimates $25,000 and $18,000)Auction, Noble Sale 141Noble
Apr 2026Varne replica holey dollar plus Kodak medal$300 hammerAuction, Noble Sale 141Noble
Aug 2026Holey dollar, PCGS Fair 2 (most worn certified by PCGS)$55,000 list price; soldDealer (Drake Sterling)Drake Sterling
26 Sep 2026Matched holey dollar (1806 host) and dump, in timber case$85,000Dealer (Coinworks)Coinworks
23–27 Nov 2026 (upcoming)Holey dollar, 1799 Mexico host, "one of the top twenty" (lot 841); dumps (lots 842–843); Manila forgery (lot 844)Estimates $200,000; $9,000 and $8,000; $100Auction, Noble Sale 143 (estimates only)Noble
1988 issuePerth Mint silver holey dollar ($1, 1 oz) and dump (25c, ¼ oz) set; mintage 100,000$195 regular price (sold out)Asking (Wynyard Coin Centre, viewed Nov 2026)Wynyard Coin Centre; Perth Mint mintages
Jan 2013 issuePerth Mint 200th anniversary holey dollar and dump silver proof set; mintage 4,000$108.18 at issue (CoinNews); $119 (E-Sylum); now $299Issue price / asking (Town Hall Coins, viewed Nov 2026)CoinNews, 2 Jan 2013; E-Sylum; Town Hall Coins
2013 issueAustralia–Spain three-coin silver set (holey dollar, dump, Spanish €10 8 reales); mintage 5,000AU$150 (out of stock)Asking (Coins Australia, viewed Nov 2026)Coins Australia
Sep 2026 issueRoyal Australian Mint 2026 $1 Origins of Australian Coin Holey Dollar, uncirculated; mintage 35,000$35 issue priceIssue price (RAM)Royal Australian Mint