Search This Blog

Monday, September 28, 2026

City No Bed Of Roses - Sydney In 1832 - The Dowlings - Newcastle Sun - Saturday 4th April 1936 - Page 2

Walter E. Bethel wrote this piece for the Newcastle Sun in April 1936, looking back at Sydney in 1832 through the Dowling family. Sir James Dowling (1787–1844) came out as a judge of the Supreme Court and became the second Chief Justice of New South Wales, serving from 1837 until his death in 1844. The article says he had been offered a post in Dominica and chose New South Wales instead – “no bed of roses”, as it turned out.

Bethel walks us around the Darlinghurst Hill and Old Woolloomooloo of the day, taking in Brougham Lodge and Craigend, Sir Thomas Mitchell's house. South Dowling Street is named after the judge. I've linked my Craigend post and J. Arthur Dowling's paper on Potts Point and Darling Point below, as they go well with this one.

Related posts on this blog: Craigend – Darlinghurst – Demolished 1922 · Potts Point, Darling Point And Neighbourhood – J Arthur Dowling

Sir James Dowling, second Chief Justice of New South Wales – by Henry Samuel Sadd, c. 1850s (National Library of Australia)
Sir James Dowling, second Chief Justice of New South Wales – by Henry Samuel Sadd, c. 1850s (National Library of Australia)
Image: Henry Samuel Sadd (National Library of Australia) – via Wikimedia Commons (Public domain). Source


City No Bed Of Roses – Sydney In 1832 – The Dowlings
Newcastle Sun – Saturday 4th April 1936 – Page 2

Transcription (Newcastle Sun, Saturday 4 April 1936, page 2)

## CITY NO BED OF ROSES
## SYDNEY IN 1832
## The Dowlings
## NOTABLE FAMILY
(By Walter E. Bethel)

[Portrait] Sir George Gipps

Our first Chief Justice, Sir Francis Forbes, came from the West Indies. Our second, Sir James Dowling, was offered the Chief Justiceship of the island of Dominica, in the West Indies but preferred to come to New South Wales, on account of the climate.

He found Sydney no bed of roses. In 1832 he wrote: "During the last four years I have had a most laborious, anxious and, I must say, unequal share of the judicial duties of this colony cast upon my shoulders. It has been my painful lot to try a great number of cases pregnant with political excitement and local party feeling."

Later in the same letter he says: "Nay I will assert that it is impossible for any man to act otherwise than honestly and uprightly, nay with fearful anxiety to do right, considering the rigid, harsh and ungenerous supervision to which a judge is exposed in this colony."

[The first words of the next column are not in the clipping] was called) will always be associated with two old-time names, those of Sir James Dowling, the second Chief Justice, and of Sir Thomas Livingston Mitchell.

Sixty years ago, in my own boyhood, there still existed, as land marks of the earliest settlement on the Hill, Brougham Lodge and Craigend, built by Sir James Dowling and Sir Thomas Mitchell respectively. They were being rapidly hemmed in, and William-street, as the main thoroughfare to the east, was changing every day.

It was still largely a residential thoroughfare in my young days, but shops kept opening until the private residences became few and far between. The row of cottages, with their gardens, were still on the southern side between Forbes and Bourke-streets, and Burdekin's Terrace ran on the same side up to Dowling-street.

"Rosebank," a fair mansion, the grounds of which fronted William-street, was soon blocked out by the post office and Perth Terrace. This old street will always be first in my memory.

Darlinghurst Hill

The Hill was steeper in my day; the grade has been considerably reduced. It owes its construction to Sir Thomas Mitchell, who, when he built "Craigend," desired a roadway, not a bush track, as a more direct route to the city. Its smart 'bus service and splendid coaching teams—the stately landaus and broughams, the phaetons and dogcarts, all created an effect never to be seen in Sydney again.

Well-to-do people came to town on their own hacks, notably the late T. S. Clibborn, secretary of the A.J.C., who lived then at Elizabeth Bay. Many other business men walked in and walked out for preference—the stalwart Sir Matthew Darley, the Chief Justice, being a familiar figure, moderating his pace so that the diminutive Sir Julian Salomons could keep up with him.

Sir William Windeyer, father of Richard, and the rert [sic], lived in one of those three old mansions built on part of Sir James Dowling's original property. There are many, too, who will remember "Keary's," that old-fashioned inn at the corner of Brougham and William streets.

It is still there—but metamorphosed. Its bar was a mere detail, but its pleasant parlors, with their solid horsehair couches and chairs, mahogany, sideboards and steel engravings, were havens to the pedestrians who climbed the hill on summer days. Tankards of good ale, biscuit, and cheese—and the walk home was resumed.

Early Society

The social life of those days was easier, and few were too great to avoid breaking their journey there, and receive their refreshment from Mrs. Keary, with her big cameo brooch and motherly smile.

From the windows of this old licensed house, George Houston Reid first wooed the electors of East Sydney, and embarked on that great career that conducted him to the Premiership of New South Wales—then to the Prime Ministership, and, finally, to the High Commissionership.

Before the building of the present Government House, it was almost decided to build a new Government House at Potts Point. What gave rise to the idea was that Government officials had secured most of the grants on Darlinghurst-road, Macleay-street. Fortunately, the unexampled site on which it now stands was chosen.

Sir James Dowling's first Sydney residence was in Kent-street, in a commodious cottage, that afterwards become [sic] the manager's house, attached to the soup kitchen—but it was a different Kent-street then, where open paddocks prevailed.

Among the earliest homes on the hill were those of Messrs. Macleay, Mitchell, Laidley, Dowling, Hallen, Jones, Barker, Stephen, Lithgow, Shadforth, Goodsir, and Potts—after whom Potts Point was called.

Old Woolloomooloo

Before William-street was built, the way round from town was along the old South Head road—now Oxford-street—turning on to Darlinghurst-road by the gaol.

Sir James Dowling selected nine acres on Woolloomooloo Hill, afterwards called Darlinghurst. The following streets were all named by Sir James Dowling, and were originally on his estate, Dowling, Forbes, Victoria, Brougham. The house, Brougham Lodge, stood where Brougham Terrace was afterwards erected. In my day, it was a school, kept by a Mr. Horniman. It originally commanded a view of old Woolloomooloo Bay, not the dense, packed Woolloomooloo of to-day, but the one that Commissioner Palmer knew when he built his house just where Palmer-street now runs down to the bay.

As nature made it, there were few prettier spots; the water came right up to St. Mary's road.

Sir James was born in London, on November 25, 1787. While studying for the Bar he did Press work, reporting Parliamentary debates. He was called to the Bar on May 5, 1815, and practised at the home circuit, and at the Middlesex Sessions. He came under notice as the joint author with Mr. Rylands of King's Bench reports—1822, 1831, and of reports of cases relating to the duty and office of magistrates, 1823-31.

Overwhelmed With Work

He was selected for a puisne judgeship in April, 1827, having refused offers of the Chief Justiceships of Sierra Leone and of Dominica for climatic reasons. After eight years' work as puisne judge he acted for Sir Francis Forbes, who went on leave and on Forbes's resignation in 1837, he received the appointment of Chief Justice.

The rapid expansion of the law—and the limited Bench overwhelmed Dowling with work, and he was regarded as a martyr to his duty when premature decease overtook him in 1844. For this reason he was largely unable to pay due regard to his private interests, and died before he had leisure to do so.

In writing to Sir George Gipps in the interests of Lady Dowling, Sir Alfred Stephen stated that he did so because he felt that he was more called upon than others by "friendship for Sir James and by knowledge of his affairs." He pointed out that Sir James died before he could retrieve himself, which accounted for the fact that his estates would barely pay 20s in the £1, and described Sir James's life as having been "marked by the most laborious, incessant, and painstaking devotion to his duties than perhaps ever distinguished any judge."

Upon the recommendation of Sir George Gipps, a pension was granted to Lady Dowling.

Sir James wrote a most remarkable letter to his second son, James, on the eve of the latter's departure to finish his education in London. The letter aimed at guidence [sic] when, remote from paternal influence in London, the lad would be faced by life's problems.

Sir James was one of the earliest to receive a knighthood for services in the colony. The first knighthood so conferred was on John Wylde, temporary Judge Advocate, at the instance of Governor Macquarie. Sir Francis Forbes was the second and Sir James Dowling's title followed, on Governor's [sic] Bourke's recommendation, in 1838.

A Legal Jig-Saw

Sir James settled an important question of precedence soon after his elevation to the Chief Justiceship. Conflicting regulations and charters had brought the matter into something like a jig-saw puzzle. The officers of State concerned were the Chief Justice, the Bishop of Australia, and the officer commanding the troops in the colony. Sir George Gipps, in his despatch to Lord Glenelg, reviewed the position caused by Sir James Dowling's definite claim to rank always next to the Governor, basing his claim on the Charter of Justice, dated October 13, 1823.

In Governor Darling's time the Bishop sat in the Legislative Council below the officer commanding the troops. When, however, the Bishop took his seat in June, 1838, he claimed to be put next to the Chief Justice, as authorised in the sign manual.

While agreeing with this claim of the Bishop for precedence in the Council, Sir George Gipps pointed out that outside the Council, the Book of Regulations, dated March, 1837, placed the officer-in-charge of troops first, the Bishop second, and the Chief Justice third. Sir George went on to say that the claim of the Chief Justice for complete precedence raised the point that even if the Charter of Justice could not be over-ruled by the regulations, the question would still remain whether the Charter gave the Chief Justice precedence over the Bishop, inasmuch as the Charter admitted persons to take precedence of the Chief Justice of the Queen's Bench, which Bishops (he believed) always did.

[Portrait] Sir Thomas Mitchell

Claim Supported

Lord Glenelg, in a despatch dated December 21, 1833, wrote:—

"There can be no doubt of the accuracy of the opinion of the Chief Justice, that the Royal Charter cannot be superseded by any less solemn expression of the pleasure of the Crown. It grants to that officer precedence over all persons excepting such as in this country (England) take precedence of the Chief Justice of the Court of Queen's Bench. There is no doubt that this precedence is due to a Bishop being a Peer of Parliament over a Chief Justice who does not enjoy that dignity—but between a Chief Justice and a Bishop, of whom both are Commoners, the precedence is assigned to the Judge. The titular distinction of Lord, which is borne by the Bishops of the Church of England, even when not Peers of Parliaments, is a mere title of courtesy and carries with it no actual rank. The claim of the Chief Justice of your Government in regard to precedence must therefore be admitted."

The Bishop was Bishop Broughton, and the commander of the troops, Major-General Snodgrass. The latter was a gallant soldier, who served in the Peninsula Wars, and led the forlorn hope at the siege of San Sebastian. He stood high in the opinion of Governors Darling, Bourke and Gipps. He was sent temporarily to Hobart to command the troops there, and on that occasion acted as Lieutenant-Governor pending the arrival of Sir John Franklin. He did so well that Governor Bourke urged his appointment to Port Philip [sic], but nothing came of the recommendation.

He returned to Sydney and acted as Lieutenant-Governor, until the arrival of Sir George Gipps. He was a member of the Legislative Council that was taken to task by Dr. Lang for leaving him out of the Presbytery designed for the stabilisation and control of the Presbyterian Church in the colony. Snodgrass retired and lived on his Raymond Terrace estate, where he died in 1853.

Sir James Dowling founded a notable family in Australia. He left two sons and two daughters. The son to whom the father wrote the famous advisory letter was James Sheen Dowling, who, at the time of his father's death, was busily engaged in following the paternal counsels in London.

He was then 25 years of age, had gained his LL.B. degree, and had been admitted to the Bar. He returned to Sydney, and was admitted to the New South Wales Bar. In 1846 he was made Judge Advocate of the Gladstone Northern Colony, but the project fell through. He became a police magistrate in 1857, then Crown Prosecutor for the colony, and finally District Court judge in 1858. He died in 1902.

He wrote valuable reminiscences of old Sydney. Outstanding amongst his family is his son, J. A. Dowling, a well-known solicitor, who at a ripe old age is still residing at Darling Point amongst surroundings that have greatly changed since his own boyhood's days. He, like his father, has placed on record his own recollections of the eastern district of Sydney.

Pen Pictures of Past

Three generations of Dowlings have left pen pictures of past days. Sir James's account of how he came ashore from the Hooghly on January 25, 1828, helps to show some of Sydney's vanished scenes. The day was hot and oppressive, and the new judge wore his robes and wig. He left the ship to a salute of 11 guns from a shore battery. The guard of honor was composed of the New South Wales Veteran Battalion, formed after the removal of the unsavory New South Wales Corps.

He landed at the stairs at the foot of Government House lawns. In the great drawing-room Governor Darling, then in his second year of office, was ready to receive him in full military garb. A handshake followed, and Sir James's commission was read by John Stephen, junr., the Acting-Registrar of the Supreme Court. Then the oaths of allegiance, supremacy and of office were administered.

This ended, Dowling made his bow and retired through a lane of civil and military officers down to the water's edge, accompanied by Chief Justice Forbes, and then the return was made to the Hooghly.

Darling seemed to the judge to be "a cold, stiff, sickly military person." The Chief Justice "looked unwell and more than 55 years of age, though but 43." In manner he was cold and forbidding and did not seem too happy. Mr. Justice Stephen, father of Sir Alfred, was there, and appeared to be "infirm, shattered and in bad health, and seemed marked down for another world."

Among the company was Alexander Macleay, the Colonial Secretary, and Captain Dumaresq, Governor Darling's brother-in-law, who appeared to Dowling to be "a mild, modest and unpretending gentleman" and who most favorably impressed him.

Old Government House

As we walk from the Quay up Phillip or Young streets to-day we are treading on the grounds of old Government House, that stood at the eastern end of Bridge-street. Offices and stores have taken the place of the gardens and lawns that greeted Sir James 109 years ago, and this old scene embraced the calm waters of Sydney Cove, where the good ship Hooghly was swinging at her chains, doubtless foul and grimy after a voyage of three months and 19 days from the Nore. She was still plying to this port when six years later Sir James's second son took ship in her for London to complete his education.

A good story is told of an Irish witness who was reluctant to answer the question whether he had not come out in a convict ship. After some fencing the judge (Sir James Dowling) took a hand:—

"Did you or did you not come out in a convict ship?"

After some further hesitation the witness, with a broad grin, replied: "Yes, your Honor, I did, and I hope that there is no harm in that, for we both came out in the same convict ship—the Hooghly."

________________________________________

No comments:

Post a Comment